I want an iPhone Mini-sized Android phone (2022)

by asimops • 1 year ago

457 684 1 year ago

hammyhavoc5• 1 year ago

With a battery that can be swapped rapidly without tools. Bonus points for pogo pins like a Samsung XCover phone.

Smaller size means smaller battery, but that's mitigated by the above. I want utilitarian. I don't want a phablet. I want practical and unobtrusive. The smartwatch was meant to replace the phone, but doesn't hit the right notes for me.

micromacrofoot2• 1 year ago

foldables are possibly good for this, I'm considering the fold 7 personally

hammyhavoc5• 1 year ago

I'm definitely open to the idea of foldables or even flip phones (perhaps even enthused!). I'm gutted that the Japanese "Galapagos syndrome" keitei are becoming extinct with fewer and fewer releases each year. The ones that are newly available tend to run Android 10 (yikes). The keitei were always very tasteful, ergonomic, and sensible. Sure, not always flashy in specs, but they didn't need to be when they prioritized the form above everything. Would love for the rest of the world to pick up this dropped ball and run with it.

micromacrofoot2• 1 year ago

(sorry, meant the flip 7)

jauntywundrkind2• 1 year ago

In past lives, I've clung to 3.5mm jacks and battery swaps (although I consider myself much reformed, yes I maybe would buy an updated LG v20 if one were released: that was an amazingly built metal slate of a phone with both. Just hot and slow, on that Snapdragon 820).

Today, bluetooth works quite well for me (I love not having cables... but it sucks that performance with a microphone is trashfire). 3.5mm adapters are cheap and easy when needed (rarely. I also have a $10 bluetooth->3.5mm in my travel kit that does get used once a year!). And with usb-c providing fast charging, I rarely feel like I'd benefit from battery swaps. I can give myself 50%+ in 30 minutes, with a portable battery that will power not just my phone, but any other device I run into. With Qi 2.2 releasing with 25W wireless charging, and magnetic coupling being standard now, you don't even need wires anymore. Carrying a bespoke phone-only battery seems like a massive downgrade today. (It also felt like a massive fire hazard!) Time to update your expectations!

Worth mentioning that battery swaps make water-resistance much much trickier to pull off. There' a real cost to battery-swappability.

I do wish we saw something like Ara, some phone modularity & extensibility. Fairphone has some modular parts, but it doesn't feel like an open ecosystem, and the parts dont seem super designed for expansion but more just replacement. I guess maybe Framework is doing the best work, albeit in a bigger form factor space, with their Expansion Cards, which are basically just a card form factor USB-C. Licensed CC-BY-4. https://github.com/FrameworkComputer/ExpansionCards

hammyhavoc5• 1 year ago

For me, the battery swap interest is down to using CGMs and uploading that data to a mesh of local "follower" devices belonging to family members, as well as to my Nightscout server. That's quite intensive with new data every minute. We've had blackouts here before, and it's those moments you really value stuff like battery banks, however, keeping them charged and making sure others don't siphon your juice from time to time can be annoying (lol!). Would be nice to keep an additional battery just for my device in my pouch of diabetes-related paraphernalia.

Once upon a time, I had a Motorola A920 in the early '00s that came with a dock to put a second battery into to charge it (pre-CGM era of course), but something like that would be lovely when combined with a foldable or flip phone.

After Google pushed a firmware update to my Pixel 6a today, it definitely gives a feeling of vulnerability. https://support.google.com/pixelphone/answer/16340779?hl=en

Would love to recommend the Fairphone, but not available in every country. One of my cousins wanted one (his dad is diabetic too), but unfortunately not available to buy in Canada.

Hopefully Framework humour the idea of a phone at some point, but it'll be difficult to please everybody, and I'm not sure it's economically viable.

The Samsung XCover are mil-spec with swappable batteries (major selling point on their site) and don't struggle with being waterproof, so it can be done. I don't think it's as niche an idea as people would expect.

I excitedly followed the Ara for years! Was gutted it never amounted to anything.

grishka• 1 year ago

My first Android phone was an HTC Desire S. It had a rather sturdy metal case with some plastic inserts for the antennas. The bottom insert slid off to reveal the battery and SIM and SD slots. The only downside is that because of this construction it has the USB port on the side. I used it way beyond official support by installing custom ROMs, but eventually apps got so bloated it couldn't run them without frustrating me.

So, uh, can I please have that but with a more modern SoC and a non-potato camera?

rtpg4• 1 year ago

I've come around on swapping batteries, and have decided that external battery packs are the way to go. Works on more devices, and you're not buying batteries that work on exactly one device.

Still want my phone battery to be replaceable, but I'm pretty fine with not being able to do it myself.

oc13• 1 year ago

just get a larger phone and you don't have to carry bulky battery packs.

cypherpunks01• 1 year ago

Unfortunately this still hasn't happened yet. There are almost no good options for reasonable size Androids anymore. Zenfone 10 is pretty good, especially with the headphone jack, but it's already out of print and will be obsolete before long. And smaller would be nicer.

Any other current gen recommendations?

wmf3• 1 year ago

Zenfone 10 isn't even small; it's 2.5 mm narrower than an S25.

krater233• 1 year ago

Unihertz JellyStar. Has a headphone jack too.

dmonitor2• 1 year ago

3" sounds like a novelty, but the Jelly Max seems a bit more reasonable at 5". Cool company.

kbrackbill3• 1 year ago

I tried with a Jelly Max but despite what they say it doesn't work on verizon :(. It's the perfect phone for me otherwise.

barrkel• 1 year ago

I had to make this decision yesterday and picked Galaxy S25. A lot lighter than my work Pixel 9.

imp0cat• 1 year ago

Seconded. Unfortunately the latest leaks suggest that the next gen - S26 - will be a bit bigger.

https://www.androidauthority.com/samsung-galaxy-s26-screen-s...

mc3301• 1 year ago

blackview n6000. Bombproof. Cheap. Almost a week's battery life.

ChrisRR6• 1 year ago

People recommending Zenfone just proves that marketing works on a lot of people. It's literally only a few mm smaller than a standard flagship samsung and yet the small phone crowd recommends it as if it's tiny

koiueo2• 1 year ago

A few mm smaller is the best we can get.

Also don't forget to account for case to protect that beautiful glossy slippery fragile back of your Samsung phone.

ZF doesn't need any case.

RichardCA2• 1 year ago

I went through the same process as a former Pixel 5 user.

Ended up with Galaxy S25 which weighs around 165g.

I pretty much hate Samsung for the One UI interface taking away the stock Android experience. If I could turn it all off I'd do it in a heartbeat.

But I put up with it because there is no other Android phone in 2025 that meets all the checkboxes (less than ~180g, supports all the current LTE and 5G comms, supported by the vendor).

pclowes6• 1 year ago

My cynical take is that small phones don't exist because they are not the product. Similar to vape pens the product is the addictive substance the device loads. In this case its apps and ads. A smaller screen probably negatively impacts KPIs on many levels, at Google/Apple/Meta/X and on down through the ecosystem.

I understand that Apple did not make enough money to make it worth their while to continue the iphone mini line. However, it does seem like there is a profitable business for someone there given how beloved it was/is.

I only traded out my iphone 12 mini just recently for an iphone 16 pro (likely the last apple product I will ever buy but thats another story) and aside from the camera it is basically the same. Just heavier, awkward to hold and slightly worse designed.

No major player wants a smaller screen because it has downstream impacts on the pipeline of addictive material and ad pixels they can stuff into ocular nerves.

abujazar• 1 year ago

Agreed. I'd prefer a modern iPhone the size of an iPhone 4, it was perfegt. I made the same "upgrade" from 12 mini to 16 Pro, and the 16 Pro is so large and heavy. Feels like we're moving backwards in time.

walterbell4• 1 year ago

2026 iPhone Fold is rumored iPhone Mini size unfolding to iPad Mini size.

https://9to5mac.com/2025/04/28/iphone-18-fold-details-launch...

dontlaugh8• 1 year ago

Liftyee2• 1 year ago

Out of curiosity, why's it your last Apple product?

Watching lots of Louis Rossmann has put me almost ideologically against Apple (even though they design great hardware and smooth UX within their ecosystem), but I'm not good at forming coherent points to present to Apple loving friends.

For me so far, I think it's about control over what I buy - but the rebuttal is always "you're buying a product from them, if you don't like it then tough".

pclowes6• 1 year ago

I just don't see the value add anymore and the company appears to have lost its product vision and the design sensibilities are slipping. Apple is controlled by a geriatric board and a logistics expert and it shows.

I feel I am more frequently encountering software bugs, vaporware,(dESiGnEd fOr ApPle InTelLiGeNce), and ridiculous "innovation" (genmoji). I feel the hardware advances are not very relevant to me, I don't need VR or augmented reality. I want a computer to get out of my way and solve problems for me so I can spend time in plain old reality. The hardware upgrades I DO care about are ridiculously overpriced (Ram upgrades are abusively expensive).

While I prefer my computer to be a tool to get a job done and don't want the computer itself to be a hobby. I also do not want to be forced to use AI. I also dislike the rent seeking and toolbooth behavior of iMessage and the App store. Now that linux has more paved paths, things increasingly "just work" and hardware has basically caught up I don't see a good reason to support Apple's non-vision with my money.

SchemaLoad4• 1 year ago

The opinion I got from Louis's content is that in a sense he is right, but also almost every brand is even worse. Apple does pretty much nothing to help 3rd party repair and sometimes actively impeeds it, but most other tech products do that while also not even having 1st party repair options.

I remember when Samsung had removable batteries, I went in to a Samsung store to buy a replacement for my S5 battery and they told me they didn't sell them, only new phones. Meanwhile I can take my iPhone in to any Apple store and they will replace the battery for me.

So yeah Apple does need to be forced to massively improve their practices but so does pretty much the entire tech industry aside from a few small projects that focus on being repairable.

uniq7• 1 year ago

How can KPIs from Google/Apple/Meta/X have any impact on the products third-party Android phone manufacturers decide to sell?

pclowes6• 1 year ago

I think most major players have the same incentives and minor players don't have the economies of scale to make it work economically.

Also the longer I used my iphone mini and the rest of the world moved to comically large phones the more it became apparent that nobody is thinking about small screen form factors in design and when they do its only around ad placement.

Teever• 1 year ago

Funny you should mention this because disposable smartphone vapes are now being sold:

https://www.vapezilla.com/collections/smart-vape-phone

pclowes6• 1 year ago

Amazing. If someone had pitched this concept to the producers of "Idiocracy" they would have rejected it as too far fetched and ludicrous.

khurs• 1 year ago

No major player wants a smaller screen because it has downstream impacts on the pipeline of addictive material and ad pixels they can stuff into ocular nerves.

There are lots of phone manufacturers who have no ads business. They just make phones so why would they care?

Size is dictated by trouser pocket size/handbag size and usage. Editing photos and movies to upload onto social media is probably better on a big screen.

Also screen size is dictated by common panel sizes, as low volume will mean a higher price.

Folding screens and iPad Mini's existence suggests people want larger screen real estate.

rtpg4• 1 year ago

I think photos are a big deal, but IMO it's more about the photo quality. And if you put a nice fancy camera on the phone, suddenly the device gets pretty expensive.

And so while there are people who want "small screen + nice camera". There are people who want "small screen + small price". There are many people who _don't want the small screen_. So you have this phone that can cost a lot of money (in a pretty messy market where most phone models seem to not make money anyways), and you're going to cut off chunks of the market?

So we end up with small screen + shitty camera and specs etc. And people here who want a small phone (but really want a small phone that isn't miserable to use) still are unsatisfied.

makeitdouble4• 1 year ago

There are lots of phone manufacturers who have no ads business. They just make phones so why would they care?

There are still bound to the screen resolution dictated by the platforms/environment. A maker selling an android phone with a 480x640px screen would face a huge uphill battle to see any sales.

Going for a smaller physical screen means higher DPI, so higher production costs and quality control issues. It can make more sense to buy cheaper, low DPI screen and make the whole device bigger to match the needed pixel count.

const_cast5• 1 year ago

There are lots of phone manufacturers who have no ads business.

I mean... none of the big ones.

For the others, they DO make small phones, and even non-addictive phones. We have e-ink phones in pure black and white.

_carbyau_• 1 year ago

The issue is "bigger numbers" marketing. The story for much of smartphone history was the flagship had a bigger screen.

But then it hit the practicable limits of what people can pocket/hold-comfortably.

If you make a phone with a smaller screen but want to call it "flagship" then you'd better have some good marketing to reverse the perception.

w-ll• 1 year ago

I think the other thing is pretty much everyone has a smartphone android/ios, and so the rev model has changed for android its youtube/movies, and for ios its apple tv.

p0w3n3d• 1 year ago

Please note that Samsung flagship S24 is smaller than non-flagship A55 (the same release year)

javier22• 1 year ago

I only traded out my iphone 12 mini just recently for an iphone 16 pro (likely the last apple product I will ever buy but thats another story) and aside from the camera it is basically the same. Just heavier, awkward to hold and slightly worse designed.

Just did the exact same thing 5 months ago.. I still miss my 12 mini. Would strongly consider buying a 13 mini instead of its even being sold anymore.

grapesodaaaaa• 1 year ago

I wish they had made a pro mini. The only reason I got rid of mine was for the zoom of the pro.

abruzzi• 1 year ago

i have a 13 mini. Its beat up, battery life is getting worse (even though I rarely use it) and both cameras are smashed (in my pocket during a motorcycle accident), but I look at all the options now and figure I'll just keep using this one. I'd rather be using an iPhone 4, but I need some stuff that that one didn't have to work with a glucose monitor.

devjab• 1 year ago

I ended up replacing my 12 mini with a 6z flip from samsung. The only real annoyance is that Apple hasn't enabled RCS for Danish telecom companies yet. Well that and sand... We'll see how long it lives though. The reason I originally went to apple was because my first smartphone (a galaxy 2) sort of did the planned obsolescence thing exactly the same way my two buddies galaxy 2's did at the time. If the flip lives for 5ish years then I'll likely never go back to apple. Unless they make a phone that will actually fit comfortable in my pockets again.

The little half screen on the flip is useless though. Basically nothing works on it.

scarface_748• 1 year ago

That makes no sense. The only phone companies that make money from how often you use your phone and buy apps on it are Apple and Google. If there were a market for it other companies would make them.

As far as the mini phones - because physics - the battery life is atrocious. That was one of the main drivers for me to get a larger phone. Well that and because I can pull down the Control Center and use the widget to make everything on my phone larger and still be able to use it without wearing my glasses. With my glasses, I keep everything the smallest size

sjw9877• 1 year ago

But Apple and Google (Pixel) are a huge portion of the market..

The other manufacturers are forced to go along with the market leaders, but sometimes also side-load apps for post-device-sale revenue.

strken• 1 year ago

I used to buy ZenFones, but they're huge now. It feels like there's some combination of poor sales and parts commonality that causes the problem, not a shadowy conspiracy, since I don't think ASUS and other manufacturers have a significant way to benefit from phone addiction.

Marazan3• 1 year ago

I have the last non-huge ZenFone.

The new ZenFones are just rebadged ROGs which explains the massive size jump. I'm not looking forward to replacing this phone when it ages out.

2OEH8eoCRo0• 1 year ago

I don't think that's cynical- it's obvious that larger screens allow more phone usage and more ads on the larger screen.

NoPicklez• 1 year ago

It's still a cynical point of view nonetheless

nine_k• 1 year ago

I see it differently. Modern web → the browser → powerful CPU/GPU → big battery → big device → why not cover it with a big screen.

roxolotl2• 1 year ago

Couldn’t we make it thicker though? The rumored iPhone air is the exact opposite of what I want. Give me a thicker phone with a smaller screen and I’d pay Pro prices for it.

brightbeige• 1 year ago

That’s how I see it. Screen size is area (x^2) and battery size is volume (x^3). As battery life is a critical feature, a bigger screen fits better battery life.

jittery412• 1 year ago

This is it, for a while battery life got worse for a while with more powerful chips. But then Samsung goes full in on the big size 6"+ phone and it got better again.

Now even at 80% original capacity, a Samsung can still last me throughout the day given that I am not watching videos constantly. The Iphone 6 back in the day would go to 40% in 3 hours, then suddenly to 5% in minutes.

Plus most people replace their laptop with a phone now. So the big screen size is a must.

paulcole• 1 year ago

However, it does seem like there is a profitable business for someone there given how beloved it was/is.

Normal people didn’t love small phones. They loved their small iPhones.

When it comes down to it they will not love the Pine Phone Mini.

For the vast majority of people, the key feature is that it’s an iPhone not that it’s small.

2muchcoffeeman3• 1 year ago

You’re way too cynical and have let your cynicism cloud history.

The first phablets were probably the Galaxy Note line starting in 2011 which was met with some skepticism due to the size of them. These were well before the edge to edge screen days. So you had 5.7 inch screens with a bezel.

They were huge but I would routinely see small women pull these things out of their hand bags and press a device that obscured almost their whole face and start chatting.

Things steadily got bigger from there. The general population WANTED this.

makeitdouble4• 1 year ago

Parent's take is not whether bigger phones shouldn't exist, it's why smaller phones stopped being produced, which is a fairly different angle.

women

To note, the initial smartphones were already too big for he taste of many: a clamshell feature phone was almost a third of the size of the original iPhone. From that POV, going to a phone that is twice as big is less of a barrier, as they had to keep it in a bag/purse in the first place.

The return of foldables is also pretty well received in that regard.

wyre• 1 year ago

The general population wants larger phones because they are addicted to their screens.

zanecodes• 1 year ago

The Dell Streak (shoutout to the other 3 people who bought one) had a 5 inch screen in 2010, a notable jump from contemporary phones like the iPhone 4 which was still 3.5", and other Android devices like the HTC Droid series which were around 3.7" and slowly starting to creep upwards to differentiate themselves from the iPhone. I think the largest Android devices you could get at the time were still smaller than 4".

thekevan• 1 year ago

The Samsung Galaxy Note (the first one) had a screen size of 5.3 inches.

The Samsung Galaxy Note 2 had a screen size of 5.5 inches. I had one and regularly had strangers ask me if that was really a phone. I had friends say, "Give me a call on your tablet" as a joke.

I loved it. Now my 6.1 inch iPhone feels on the small side.

darkwater• 1 year ago

Yeah and I also remember how Apple fans said "this is ridiculous, nobody needs a screen that big that doesn't fit in your pocket easily", and here we are 15 years later mourning the iPhone Mini/SE.

Marazan3• 1 year ago

It's amusing how people try an memory hole their negative reaction and pieces written about the Note. People's mocking web pages have disappeared. Arguments based on the size of the human hand completely forgotten. The very notion that a 5.7 inch screen is big an unwieldly is now met with disdain.

stavros3• 1 year ago

I just refuse to accept that the first phablet I ever saw, the Galaxy Note, which covered the person's face and looked absolutely comical in their hands, was smaller than my current, very regular-sized phone.

gsich• 1 year ago

Things steadily got bigger from there. The general population WANTED this.

Easy to say if the only devices are big phones. There is no choice.

okanat• 1 year ago

Smaller phones has always been limited in performance, batter life, the app support and the camera quality. Camera is the most important factor and battery is the second.

General population doesn't buy phones every year and they don't want a nerfed phone when they have to pay 500-1000 $/€s. So they gravitate towards higher end ones.

Companies including Apple has always treated the small size as an entry to mid segment phone. The only exception I know is Sony z3 and z5 compact which suffered heat and battery swelling issues due to Qualcomm messing 810 series SoCs up.

Companies also want you to buy the most expensive phone. So they market the premium models and train their store personnel to sell more of the premium line. If they stop intentionally nerfing the smaller phones, I think there is a market there. However, it will still be smaller.

protocolture3• 1 year ago

Phones had smaller screens when you needed the keypad to interact with the largest number of features.

Phone screen sizes grew as the applications that could use screen space grew in demand.

People are watching 1080p films on the train now. The people who want smaller screens are usually willing to deal with a larger one. People who want larger screens usually cant operate their use cases on a smaller screen. Larger screens also tend to mask larger case meaning less miniaturisation required for the components.

thaumasiotes4• 1 year ago

None of this explains why it's just impossible to get small phones.

You have people who want them unusably large and people who want them to fit in your hand. The solution in every other market is that products are manufactured to fit both sets of needs. You don't see pants coming in one size with the advice "wear a belt".

What's going on?

conradev• 1 year ago

The margins are also worse, which is way, way closer to a manufacturer’s bottom line than the software ecosystem.

There is demand for larger phones, yes, but manufacturers also charge more for bigger devices and most of that is margin. Following their own logic, they also charge less for smaller phones.

If your customers are sticky, then many of the people who buy the smaller phone would have otherwise bought a bigger phone for more money. Introducing a smaller phone brings down profits.

ginko3• 1 year ago

manufacturers also charge more for bigger devices and most of that is margin.

Why do they do that though? Usually more compact, high end devices would be more expensive than bulkier one. When has this trend reversed?

dangus• 1 year ago

I thought that was the case but I tried going small.

I owned an iPhone 13 mini. Basically the perfect small phone if there ever was one.

The downsides are extensive and the upsides are few.

- Battery life sucked. Since a phone is a 3D object making it bigger substantially increases battery capacity. It also makes packaging difficult especially if the goal is a flagship-quality phone. Good luck fitting in good hardware with a lot of features.

- Eyestrain. It’s small.

- Typing. It sucks. The phone is small.

And it turns out the upside of one-handed operation is limited. A simple PopSocket or OhSnap! will make large phones easy to use in one hand.

Plus, if pocketability is your issue, you can buy a folding phone like a Motorola Razr and still get a nice big screen when you pull it out.

phyrex2• 1 year ago

I disagree. I'm reading and typing this from an iPhone 13 mini. I use a big one for work so it's not like I don't know what I'm missing. I very strongly prefer the small form factor

chupchap• 1 year ago

No, the bigger devices just sold more. Larger screen size is a major factor in deciding which phone to buy globally.

nunez3• 1 year ago

I thought the theory behind the 12 and 13 minis was that Apple had a huge surplus of parts that they needed to offload, and making the minis was a profitable way of doing that.

saagarjha2• 1 year ago

But they launched alongside the flagship devices?

dontlaugh8• 1 year ago

I think that’s the SEs.

al_borland6• 1 year ago

This is the part that frustrates me. Apple keeps introducing software “solutions” for hardware problems. Reachability, Screen Time, Focus Modes, etc. A smaller phone naturally solves most of these problems. Small phones act as more of a utility device for when you’re away from a proper computer. This is all I want my phone to be. I really think they got it right the first time in 2007.

I ended up switching from a 13 mini (I had the 12 mini as well) to a 16 Pro. I was having a lot of battery life issues, and kept running into apps that clearly didn’t fully test with the smaller screen. I also really missed having a telephoto lens.

My phone usage went up; my laptop/desktop usage went down. I don’t like that. Compared to a normal computer, a phone is still worse in almost every way, other than mobility. It’s just now tolerable enough to put up with more of the time. I’m writing this on the phone, it would have been easier on a keyboard and mouse.

oc13• 1 year ago

The 13 mini didn't solve any of these issues for me plus the worse battery life. I upgraded to 16 pro max. My laptop usage also went down from there. Total screen time probably stayed, but now i carry most of the time just a phone instead of phone and laptop. If you want something less addictive there is probably the apple watch but you still need the phone to configure and now you're strapped to a device 24/7 just for the sake to be used less.

gargan2• 1 year ago

You could take the 13 mini to Apple and swap out the battery for a new one? That might solve some of the battery issues

sjw9877• 1 year ago

"Small phones act as more of a utility device for when you’re away from a proper computer. This is all I want my phone to be."

You, like me, are not representatives of a market phone manufacturers are interested in. Utilitarian and minimal use only sells one phone every few years.

They are catering for the overwhelming market that spends upwards of 5 hours screen time per day, watches movies and TVs, plays games, and generally spends as much time as possible on them, with as much payment and ad revenue as that comes with on top of the original device sale.

I always personally liked the idea of computers being fixed, or semi-fixed (like a laptop), as a place to work or study, and then leave once that is done. The replacement of computers and laptops by tablets and phones is a wider cultural shift from computers being tools and productive technology to entertainment and consumerist technology, in my opinion.

GarnetFloride• 1 year ago

What was so odd was how Apple fumbled the iPhone mini launch by launching the iPhone SE first. At that point there hadn't been a small phone for a few years, There was pent up demand. The SE came out and it was a big success, lots of people wanted ti because it was a small phone.

Then few months later they launched the mini expecting it to sell even more or something. Somehow they missed that everyone that wanted a small phone had just bought the SE, and it just wasn't long enough for them to be worth upgrading to the much better mini.

Had they waited for a year to pass the mini might have done much better because those who wanted a more powerful phone could find an excuse for an upgrade after a year, less then 6 months, not so much.

vidyesh• 1 year ago

Your theory makes sense until it falls apart if you consider SE and Mini as the same category of small iPhones. If the only reason why Mini failed was bad launch time, then why haven't Apple launched anything small (SE or Mini) after 2022? Isn't 2024 or even 2025 the perfect time to launch an upgrade for SE or Mini? They now have enough data since the last launch of a small phone.

iPhone SE 1st gen 2016 (Discontinued 2018)

iPhone 12 Mini 2020 (Discontinued 2022)

iPhone SE 2nd gen 2020 (Discontinued 2022)

iPhone 13 Mini 2021 (Discontinued 2023)

iPhone SE 3rd gen 2022 (Discontinued 2025)

microtonal5• 1 year ago

I don't know. I think the SE was there there to generate services income (Apps, Apple Music, etc.) from people who wouldn't buy an iPhone otherwise. The design was intentionally very stale to avoid cannibalization of their flagships. I don't think a lot of people who bought flagship iPhones before would go to an SE. Imagine going from an iPhone X or XS to an SE, it's a big downgrade. People were not buying the SE because of the size, but because it was cheap (the iPhone 16e that is the cheaper model now, has the same size as the 16).

My wife, I, and several people I know had iPhone 12 or 13 Mini. Their battery life was pretty terrible and word soon got out it was. I think this was in the end what killed it for people who are normally buying Apple flagships and were considering a Mini. It was very hard to get through the day with a Mini.

Besides the abysmal battery life, I think the market for small phones is maybe simply not there. Samsung keeps around one smaller model (base S-series) and arguably the Z Flip is a smaller model (but persistent hardware issues). If there was a large demand for flagship-class small phones, I am sure some Android manufacturers would make them.

whilenot-dev• 1 year ago

This is my take as well. I bought the SE 2nd gen because of its size, a longer support cycle, and granular app permissions on iOS. It was my first iPhone and has probably been my last when its time is due.

My phone isn't some entertainment device, it's a utility tool. I don't need it to be "smart", it should be useful on the go. The persona sketched by GP just isn't me: Messaging, maps, weather, 2FA, and calculator come first, email (read only) and news feed second, the camera is a third for documenting purposes (if even, I'd rather take my full frame). The easier it is to carry this thing around and the longer lasting its build quality, the better. Why would I pay almost double (USD 699 VS 399 on launch) for a less robust mini with sharper edges?!

If Apple were to continue the offer of rehashed designs from previous generations (preferably with rounder edges) for a SE line, limit its dimensions to never go beyond 140x67.5x8mm, and make it last for solid 5-year release cycles, then count me in as your most loyal customer. As it currently stands I'm looking out for a small sized phone from any manufacturer. I would even lower my expectations on support cycle and build quality quite a bit (if reasonable priced) before I'd give in on the size.

randomcarbloke2• 1 year ago

I'm still using a 13 mini, it's fractionally too large, I think the original SE is perfection.

Regardless, battery life is horrendous now, and it's starting to lag and fail so when the new ultra watch is released I'm going to replace my phone with it.

coxley• 1 year ago

That makes sense.

I love my iPhone 13 Mini. Its only issues are battery life (now), and non-competitive camera. I'm personally happy with the photos it takes, but then I look at my girlfriend's shots and get FOMO.

While I doubt it's economical, I'd love a small, simple phone with juiced up camera. I'd be fine with worse battery life as external batteries can remedy that in a pinch.

chunkyguy• 1 year ago

This is so true. I switch from iPhone 5s to iPhone SE to iPhone 13 mini. After my current phone dies I don't know what phone would I get next.

jayd16• 1 year ago

What an angry way to say "they're bigger because people use the screen for apps and media."

aucisson_masque• 1 year ago

It’s an interesting take but I believe most people just prefer bigger phone. I know it’s weird to those of us who like the opposite and funnily enough it’s often women who have gigantic phone, which they can’t put in their tiny jean pocket.

I don’t explain it and every time I get explained they like it better because it’s got bigger battery and bigger screen, I just don’t understand how you could live your life with a brick constantly on you but it’s what people want.

The market just adapted to the demand and it’s not a 40k « petition » that will change much.

LtWorf• 1 year ago

Do you have any fact at all to back your opinion?

FinnKuhn2• 1 year ago

I know it’s weird to those of us who like the opposite and funnily enough it’s often women who have gigantic phone, which they can’t put in their tiny jean pocket.

Most women carry their phone in a hand bag anyway as the pockets on most pants for women are way to small either way [1].

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/06/style/pockets-womens-clot...

BrtByte5• 1 year ago

But it's also true that manufacturers don't always serve niches well

dheera• 1 year ago

Curious, what happened to the Palm phone (https://palm.com/)?

zerr• 1 year ago

I'd say the same goes for the removal of FM Radios from mainstream phones.

keyringlight2• 1 year ago

FM radio uses the headphone cable as an antenna, so with the move to bluetooth I assume it got squashed for similar reasons. The other aspect is it assumes if you want live radio that you're happy needing an active data connection and allowance, any any local stations have a stream available. One of the things I love about streaming (via RadioDroid, etc) is that you can get a station from anywhere on the planet but sometimes you want something a bit more basic.

dakiol• 1 year ago

I don’t know.If I have a “big” phone (anything bigger than the iphone mini, at least for me), I’ll leave it at home most of the time. But if it’s small, I’ll take it with me everywhere. So I can be bombarded with crap more time if I use a small phone.

pyman3• 1 year ago

Phones are big now because people want better cameras and longer battery life. Also, people are spending 4-5 hours more per day on screens than they did 15 years ago, so they want bigger screen for reading, playing games and watching videos.

bapak• 1 year ago

Pointless rant. Apple does not earn more or less depending on how many ads it can show.

The market has spoken, it's not worthwhile for Apple to produce small phones.

There are a million companies that are not Google that could also produce mini phones and don't for the same exact reason: most people want large screens to enjoy videos and photos.

Nobody cares about small screens and pockets, everyone holds their phones in their hands or purses at all times.

raynr2• 1 year ago

I think that's the cart before the horse. People buy the big phones and so businesses cater for that.

crossroadsguy5• 1 year ago

Just like 16e, Mini and SE were meant to push up the sales of their "other" phones. Otherwise they would not have had both Mini and SE. I mean it was a joke.

But Hanlon's razor and the way Apple has been on a screwing up spree of late I doubt it was anything intentional. They f'ed up knowing not what to do at all. They don't anymore.

atemerev• 1 year ago

Sometimes assuming just a tiny bit of malice can explain what otherwise had to be explained by a lot of stupidity.

Occam's razor beats Hanlon's razor.

TulliusCicero• 1 year ago

Conspiracy minded bullshit.

Like it or not, Apple keeps cancelling smaller phone lines because they don't sell well. That's it. If they sold really well then they'd keep selling them, but they don't.

I would also love more capable small phones personally, but I can't deny that people overall don't seem to want them.

sjw9877• 1 year ago

I posted a bit too late and didn't see your post first, which more or less is exactly along my thinking.

Modern phones are sold (even at profit) with the intent that there is more payments/ad revenue coming down the line, for movies, TV, games and web browsing/social media. A big screen makes that experience better for people and advertisers. It's a cynical take, but the entire business model is based on building and promoting addiction.

They have no interest in selling phones for utility purposes only, even though that's largely how they advertise the phones, because advertising a 5 hour plus daily screen time isn't sexy at all.

amelius3• 1 year ago

Yes, the iPhone is basically a vending machine in your pocket. Owned and run by Apple. But you paid for it. Quite smart, actually.

vbezhenar2• 1 year ago

I feel that the problem with small phones roots in software. Obviously you would need to run smaller resolution. My sweet spot was iPhone 4S. It has 3.5" display with 640x960 resolution. If you would try to run modern Android with this resolution, you would hit multiple obstacles, from popular apps to popular websites scaling badly.

raxxorraxor• 1 year ago

Many people in Asia seem to prefer gigantic screens and since it is the largest market, most phones get produced that way.

mpascale002• 1 year ago

I mean, are the phones themselves really making money off ads or are those totally separate companies? I don't disagree that this brings in business, but I don't agree that this is a significant motivator in terms of phone sizes

BrtByte5• 1 year ago

Bigger screens mean more time spent, more ad real estate, more "content," more dopamine loops

robertoandred2• 1 year ago

I want an iPhone mini-sized iPhone again...

mobilio• 1 year ago

SE user here... AMAZING device for it's size.

Now i'm on SE 2020, but every day i miss original SE form-factor.

SchemaLoad4• 1 year ago

I considered the SE2 but went with the regular iphone after seeing the battery life was much worse on the SE2. Think that's probably what killed the iPhone mini too.

luxuryballs• 1 year ago

Theory: I prefer the iPhone mini because my hands are bigger. I think some people with smaller hands care less because they aren’t losing as much control as I am when the phone is bigger, not as much of a ratio difference.

theendisney6• 1 year ago

I want a thick clunky device without a screen that can run for 4-7 days without charging. Then i want 1) a normal size device, 2) a tiny one and 3) a tablet. These should be terminals, little more than a screen, a battery and some radio to communicate with the herefore mentioned brick that does all of the heavy lifting. It needs only 20-30 meter range. The brick may also feature a webserver captive portal with public bluetooth and wifi access.

rjsw• 1 year ago

I have a Nokia 6300 4G Dual SIM KaiOS phone that I can use as a 4G router for larger devices but has good battery life as a feature phone.

derefr4• 1 year ago

Except that the screen and the radio are 80% of power usage, so this doesn't help anything. For what most people do with their laptop/tablet/phone, the little bursts of CPU are effectively "free" — increasingly cheap with each process shrink! — while the IO is as expensive as ever.

theendisney6• 1 year ago

What fun comment. You are mistaken in so many ways :)

When idle GSM uses a lot of power. Listening for a wakeup signal doesnt seem expensive at all. It even seems one could pull off the trick for free.

Free < bluetooth < wifi < gsm

There shall be e-paper ofc

The brick can have a battery like that of a quality powerbank. For emergency charging the display snaps on top with some magnets.

There will be heavy cpu loads with lots of reads and writes.

Think a room full of people hammering the media server.

Host websites on it. Imagine the fun!

GPUs may work quite hard to decode and fit the picture on the screen. How to do io better is left as an exersize for the reader. (这意味着你)

Whatever components we can get rid of buys extra space for the battery.

It also makes the handheld device cheaper to replace.

You may swap the battery or have a spare.(slide the empty one into the brick)

You may also break or lose it. It can conveniently be replaced. Nothing important is stored on it.

Lets make them with and without cameras. Imagine the opportunity to not make photos :)

SchemaLoad4• 1 year ago

I initially thought this was a satire of the absurd devices HN users would ask for.

theendisney6• 1 year ago

Then it would be monochrome cli ssh only.

carlosjobim• 1 year ago

I want a thick clunky device without a screen that can run for 4-7 days without charging.

That's a landline phone, you can buy it for cheap.

nomel2• 1 year ago

It needs only 20-30 meter range.

And, this is trivially satisfied with a $10 extension cord.

ianburrell• 1 year ago

What you need is a power bank. Then you can charge your phone, or any other device Why do you need multiple days? Charge your devices overnight. Get a fast charger that charges in minutes if you forget or are out. There are power banks with builtin chargers.

Also, if you want really small device, I found smartwatches are nice adjunct to phone. Can check notifications and do basic things on watch instead of pulling out phone. The watch uses phone for data, but there is no point in terminals when smartwatch chip can handle that. There are watches with LTE that work without the phone.

theendisney6• 1 year ago

Why would you want one more thing to think about 2000 times per year?

system22• 1 year ago

There is Unihertz, but their 5G model is crap. They also don't update their OS.

I believe the big manufacturers don't want to make a small phone (as other users have indicated) because of the big screen's addictiveness. Also, they can't fit a large battery in them so battery life would be a few hours with 1000mp 16k cameras.

I'd rather carry a 1" thick, 4" tall phone than a 0.3" thick 8" tall phone. No pants pockets look normal anymore, and it is even more awkward to walk with tight pants.

krater233• 1 year ago

Got two weeks ago a update for my jelly star. Don't know what they changed, whas not many, maybe some bugfixes. But I would be really angry when they just change the android version and the way I have to use the phone just with a over the air update that is installed without warning with one button press.

system22• 1 year ago

Android 16 is out, and Jelly Star is still Android 13. Unihertz doesn't even have that many phones to worry about updates. I don't understand why they aren't updating it to the latest. Look at the iPhone 11. Got iOS 18 after 6 years.

ActorNightly• 1 year ago

I had the titan pocket. The freaking wifi would just randomly disconnect.

theshackleford5• 1 year ago

I believe

You can believe whatever you want, but it doesn’t make it true. We know exactly why they make larger devices and it’s not a secret, it’s what consumers by and large want. It’s not a conspiracy.

Every time a vendor falls for the “we want small phones” thing, they sell poorly thus proving the point again and again that it’s a minority at best that are interested.

krater233• 1 year ago

I want it too. And I have it: https://www.unihertz.com/en-de/products/jelly-star

I have it since more than a year. I had the first one two weeks because I lost it as it fall through a hole in my pocket. So fix your pockets and buy this phone. I'm really happy with it :) And didn't found bugs since I have it.

fgblanch2• 1 year ago

Funny enough, in 2023, Asus released a good very close to iphone Mini-size android phone. The asus zenfone 10. https://www.asus.com/us/mobile-handhelds/phones/zenfone/zenf...

wilsonnb3• 1 year ago

I don't know why it was reported so frequently as a compact phone, the ZenFones are much larger than the iPhone mini. It's the same size as a standard iPhone or Galaxy S series.

quirino• 1 year ago

https://www.phonearena.com/phones/size/Apple-iPhone-13-mini,...

I was convinced you were wrong but that's correct. The Mini is much smaller and the Zenfone is about the same size as the regular iPhone.

pohuing• 1 year ago

Not only is it not a very small phone, I can't even properly type this message one handed. It's also not a good phone which I regret purchasing.

Zenphones until the 10 had easy to unlock bootloaders, leading to long in official support by the community. However with the 10 ASUS stopped that tool and they've been lying ever since that they're still working on it.

My zenfone is now on its final major android update, the rather minor android 15 version, and I've only got two years of security updates left until I need to look for a new phone. That's one thousand euros for barely four years of software support, it's such a disappointment.

That aside the camera is lackluster, it's auto whitebalance is horrific, turning the same snowy scene into a sunset or illuminated by fluorescent light depending on the phase of the moon and it's sampling questionable making images much more blurry in a surreal way. But the optical stabilisation is seriously impressive. Overall I preferred the pixel 4a's images though. A smaller phone and my zenfone's predecessor.

At least I get to just plug it into my stereo thanks to the 3.5mm jack though.

Marazan3• 1 year ago

Agree on the Camera, bafflingly bad.

Thumbs up on the headphone jack though. Can't fault it there.

sabellito• 1 year ago

Despite sibling comments, it's still a smaller phone compared to others from the same year. I have one and I'm extremely satisfied with it.

mdasen• 1 year ago

The Zenfone 10 is closer to an iPhone than an iPhone mini.

iPhone 16/Zenfone/13 Mini (in mm)

Height: 147.6/146.5/131.5 - the mini is 15mm shorter than the Zenfone which is only 1.1mm shorter than an iPhone.

Width: 71.6/68.1/64.2 - the mini is 3.9mm thinner than the Zenfone which is 3.5mm thinner than an iPhone

Depth: 7.8/9.4/7.7 - the Zenfone is significantly thicker than the iPhones.

Volume: 82.4/93.8/65.0 cubic cm - the Zenfone is physically larger than an iPhone 16 by a decent margin.

The Zenfone simply isn't close to an iPhone mini size. It's larger than an iPhone by volume and the depth does matter when holding it. If we're talking about front-edge to opposite front-edge, we're talking about 87.2mm for the iPhone vs 86.9mm for the Zenfone and 79.6 for the Mini. The Zenfone saves you 0.3mm in grip-distance over an iPhone, but a Mini saves you 7.6mm in grip-distance.

Heck, let's look at weight. A Zenfone is 172g, iPhone 170g, iPhone mini 141g. The Zenfone is the heaviest of the three.

One of the big limiting factors for Android phone manufacturers is the battery. iOS is a ton more efficient. The Zenfone is thicker to accommodate a 4300mAh battery compared to the iPhone 16's 3561mAh (21% larger battery). And the Zenfone's battery is kinda small by Android standards.

People often don't think about the challenges of making a small phone. The electronics don't shrink. If you need a certain square mm for those electronics, they take up a larger percentage of the interior on your mini. You don't need as large a battery because the screen it is powering is smaller, but not proportional to its size - you're still drawing the same power for all the electronics. So you have a smaller percentage of interior space for the battery and you need a larger battery relative to the interior space - or you need to sacrifice battery life as Apple did with the mini.

For example, the iPhone 13 mini is 84.4 sq cm and has a 2438mAh battery. The iPhone 13 is 104.9 sq cm with a 3240mAh battery. The iPhone 13 is 24% larger, but can accommodate a 33% larger battery - because the electronics take up basically the same space regardless of form factor.

So to make an Android mini, you'd be sacrificing a lot of battery life. The Zenfone is not a mini. Its grip-size is basically identical to an iPhone. In every way, it's much more an iPhone than a mini.

fgblanch2• 1 year ago

Commenting just to appreciate this analysis. I totally bought the marketing that this was a small phone, while it seems it just had a small screen.

burnt-resistor3• 1 year ago

Of phones I owned 10+ years ago:

iPhone 6S: 138.3/67.1/7.1 = 65.9 cc the mini is just barely smaller.

iPhone 4S: 115.2/58.6/9.3 = 62.8 cc smaller than the mini.

Treo 650: 113/59/23 = 153 cc which is about the same volume as a Galaxy Z Fold 3... the displacement was so uncomfortable, people often used hip holsters for the former.

roytam872• 1 year ago

but I missed MicroSD slot. I think my requirement is simple: not too wide (<=70mm), has 3.5mm audio pack, and has MicroSD slot.

and end-up only Sony products comes out. and I sacrificed performance for a shorter phone so I bought Xperia Ace III.

but I don't know when will my ISP shutdown GSM-1800. If this happens I have to buy Xperia 10 series then.

kps• 1 year ago

I want a pocket computer with phone connectivity (because too much still demands a phone number).

derefr4• 1 year ago

Why not a pocket computer with wifi + a softphone app + a virtual PBX service (e.g. voip.ms) for that softphone app to connect to?

As a bonus, your phone number wouldn't be bound to that device, but instead would exist everywhere you can install the same softphone app.

SchemaLoad4• 1 year ago

Most things which require a phone number block any kind of virtual number service since the only reason they are asking for a phone number is anti spam and KYC.

efskap• 1 year ago

I tried to make the softphone approach work but I was unreachable far too often when Android decided to kill whichever softphone app I tried.

And if it did keep running, I'm pretty sure it consumed decently more energy than a dedicated telephony module. And yeah as mentioned, even with a "real" local phone number ported to voipms, I wasn't able to get sms codes from some services.

MiddleEndian8• 1 year ago

6" doesn't register as small to me at all lol. The HTC 8X was 4.3" and that was a "normal" sized phone for me.

I used the Palm Phone (PVG100) (3.3" screen) (basically the size of a credit card) [ https://www.ricklohre.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/dsc_097... ] as long as I could until it became too slow to use as software got slower and increasingly battery-hungry and I had to give it up last year.

Right now I have a Soyes S10Max, which has a 3.5" screen (same screen size as the original iPhone), but it's kinda chunky. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CRZ47T53?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_...

The specs are more than strong enough to handle whatever I need on a daily basis. But I miss the slimmer size of the Palm Phone.

Right now I've pre-ordered this phone https://aiphor.com/products/bluefox-nx1-4-0-android-smartpho... with the 8gigram+128gig storage capacity. Has an even stronger cpu than the Soyes, but I am slightly worried about the resolution of 540x1168px because some elements may end up overlapping.

Even though it's 4", it has a tiny bezel so it's only slightly bigger than the Palm Phone, although a bit thicker cuz of a bigger battery. But still relatively slim, especially compared to the Soyes.

Front comparison: https://preview.redd.it/dtwnubx05scf1.png?width=3840&format=...

https://preview.redd.it/s2391amd7hbf1.png?width=320&crop=sma...

Will see!

frosted-flakes3• 1 year ago

At $138 I can't imagine that the Bluefox NX1 will perform very well.

(By the way from some reason aiphor.com automatically redirects me to google.com unless I disable Javascript.)

MiddleEndian8• 1 year ago

The Soyes S10Max performs fine with 8 gigs of ram and a slightly slower mobile CPU. The most intensive thing I do on it is probably video call with people on FB Messenger or Telegram (or I guess load TicketMaster, but even my gf's expensive iPhone struggles with that one lmao), and it does that fine.

But I'll write a review on reddit once I've used it for a week or two.

No clue on aiphor.com, webdevs (or their managers) love javascript lol

jauntywundrkind2• 1 year ago

Doesn't sound stellar, but 2x A75 and 6x A55 is probably not the worst experience? Helios G81. 12nm process. https://www.notebookcheck.net/Mediatek-Helio-G81-Ultra-Proce...

An even slightly more mid-range spin on this would be very very viable.

dannyfreeman• 1 year ago

Do these little phones work well in the US?

MiddleEndian8• 1 year ago

They seem to work fine on T-Mobile. I hear the Palm Phone had some issue with Verizon where it only worked as a "companion phone" and I hear AT&T limits what phones are allowed somehow, but I cannot speak to those things.

They only have 4G rather than 5G. This has not bothered me but perhaps it would bother others.

jbaber2• 1 year ago

PVG 100 worked great with my carrier.

jbaber2• 1 year ago

I, too, used a PVG100 until it died. The "juicepack" battery doubled the thickness, but it still fit in my pocket. Now I've got a Motorola Razr. I figure the only way companies will give me a small phone if it folds.

MiddleEndian8• 1 year ago

I tried out the Razr and Z Flip 4 at a store but I thought they were too hard to use while closed and way too big when open.

If you check /r/smallphones I'll post a review of the NX1 in a couple months (or whenever I get it + a week or two). It looks like the closest spiritual successor to the Palm Phone (although the single button on the foot with multiple actions will probably never be beat)

notatoad• 1 year ago

you have to compare the actual phone sizes, not the screen sizes. bezels have gotten smaller.

the article's "small phone" benchmark with a 5.4" screen is almost the same size in every dimension as your benchmark of the HTC 8x

https://www.phonearena.com/phones/size/HTC-8XT,Apple-iPhone-...

MiddleEndian8• 1 year ago

you have to compare the actual phone sizes, not the screen sizes. bezels have gotten smaller.

This is true, and it's hard to fully assess without a tool like you linked, which is pretty neat.

the article's "small phone" benchmark with a 5.4" screen is almost the same size in every dimension as your benchmark of the HTC 8x

But as mentioned, I don't consider the 8X to be small. It's a standard-sized phone in my eyes.

vbezhenar2• 1 year ago

For me, screen size is what matters. Because I'm using screen. Small bezel is very bad thing, because it registers accidental touches now. Best phone in the history of mankind was iPhone 4S. Perfectly balanced. It's all went downhill since then.

ItsHarper• 1 year ago

Plus, the diagonal measurement doesn't reflect the width of the phone. Phones got taller/narrower probably about the same time as we started ditching physical buttons below the screen, so the screen size numbers went up without making phones wider, even if you keep the bezels the same size.

People comparing old smartphone diagonal screen measurements to modern ones as if they're equivalent is a huge pet peeve for me. Diagonals are a horrible way to measure screens.

mnmalst• 1 year ago

Thanks for all the interesting links, the bluefox-nx1-specifically looks interesting to me. Do you have any information how are handling the new EU law, which requires 5 years of security updates? https://single-market-economy.ec.europa.eu/news/new-eu-rules...

MiddleEndian8• 1 year ago

I have no idea, I don't work for them or live in the EU. But given that other users report problems loading the site, maybe they don't support EU customers. The phone exists in China but only started taking pre-orders in the US, so maybe it will change in the future.

diggan3• 1 year ago

https://aiphor.com/products/bluefox-nx1-4-0-android-smartpho...

Huh, for some reason, this page loads properly and I can see it for 1-2 seconds, but it seems like as soon as it's done loading, it redirects me to google.com. Based in Spain, so guessing it's their way of turning away EU or European customers I guess?

MiddleEndian8• 1 year ago

They seem to be doing stuff by countries, probably due to regulations. The phone has existed in China for a bit already and only recently became pre-orderable in the US.

layer83• 1 year ago

No 5G, no eSIM, no NFC, and a bit thick, though.

paxys• 1 year ago

We've seen this story play out before. Every phone manufacturer has had the bright idea of introducing a small flagship. They spend a ton of money developing and marketing it. Internet people get excited. And when launched - no one buys it. They learn their lesson and move on.

rtpg4• 1 year ago

the foldables seem to have found their niche at least in this space though. But they get away with it by... also being a big phone

walterbell4• 1 year ago

iPhone Fold is rumored to be 5.5" screen size.

makeitdouble4• 1 year ago

They spend a ton of money developing and marketing it.

I beg to differ. How much marketing money did Apple spend on the mini line, in comparison to the "standard" size ?

And when launched - no one buys it.

Pixel 3 and 4a are still the most sold phones in the Pixel line.

The news when Pixel7 was launched:

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/gadgets-news/this-is-the...

MostlyStable• 1 year ago

It does not surprise me that the things that "internet" people want are not generally popular. What I don't understand is why that means they can't make money selling them anyways. Companies used to make money when the entire cell phone market was _dramatically_ smaller than today. Sure, maybe only 5% of customers want that phone, but 5% of a huge market is still a lot of people! I just have trouble believing that there isn't room for serving that segment of the consumer base.

bigstrat20037• 1 year ago

Yeah, that is surprising and frustrating to me as well. I don't mind being a smaller market. Hell, I don't mind paying more because of it. But companies these days are largely unwilling to have a steady, sustainable business in a smaller market. The insatiable desire to capture the biggest market at all times leaves society as a whole much worse off, because if your needs aren't the most common - you simply cannot find anyone who will do business with you.

adithyassekhar3• 1 year ago

Slight tangent, I thought nowadays everyone is (are?) internet people. Everyone's on their phone all the time. Even if it's tiktok or instagram, why aren't brands spending to reach this audience.

anxoo2• 1 year ago

1% of people post/comment, 99% like/retweet or just read. everyone you read on the internet is weird by default

meatmanek• 1 year ago

Apple never released a flagship iPhone Mini, i.e. an iPhone Mini Pro. If you wanted good cameras (like the more useful 2x or 3x lens, rather than the mostly-useless 0.5x lens that they added to the base models), you had to get the large or larger phone.

I would've bought the 13 Mini Pro if it had existed, but camera quality wasn't something I was willing to compromise on.

dang• 1 year ago

Discussed at the time:

I want an iPhone Mini-sized Android phone - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31411191 - May 2022 (1053 comments)

pelagicAustral• 1 year ago

I recently got a Samsung S25 and it's the best phone I've ever had. I went for the base model and the size is just perfect. It's a small enough phone that I barely feel I carry around all day. It's light and slim and has premium tier hardware so I don't miss out. Never paid more than £300 for a phone before, but I am more than happy with this one.

sircastor• 1 year ago

My iPhone 12 Mini's camera just broke (the zoom is failing..) I have been poking around for any solution that is around the same size. The best answer is generally never-heard-of companies that pop new phone models out and no certainty as to how long they'll last or be supported. That's on top of having to switch platforms (again).

I'm resigned to getting a new iPhone in Sept - reluctantly.

strathmeyer• 1 year ago

You can still get a PVG100 on Amazon

andai• 1 year ago

I had a Samsung A3 (2016) which was almost the exact form factor of the iPhone Mini.

I loved it for being so small and light. The last few years it became too slow for regular use (and many apps refused to install) so I put it in airplane mode and used it as an mp3 player.

I'd still be using it today, but I lost it! I was very sad.

I also loved the LG K8 (2017), wonderful device. That one was a touch bigger, but had a really nice curved screen.

I used an iPhone SE (2016) until last year actually, which was even smaller.

It worked fine, until software updates made it useless. That's a recurring theme with my phones!

EvanAnderson• 1 year ago

I used an iPhone SE (2016) until last year actually, which was even smaller. It worked fine, until software updates made it useless. That's a recurring theme with my phones!

Very similar story with me. The iPhone SE 1st gen was peak iPhone. Small, had a headphone jack (and could charge while using headphones), nice display, decent battery life. I absolutely loved that phone. I miss having it every day (when I have to use two hands to use this clunker of a phone I have now, when I sit down and feel this gigantic phone in my pocket, etc).

I used my iPhone 4 until the cellular radio wasn't supported anymore. Then I moved into an iPhone SE 1st gen. When the battery bulged I killed it trying to replace the battery (I am not suited to small electronics repair). I gave up, at that point, and moved to a janky Android phone because I couldn't get any phone I wanted from Apple (small and with a headphone jack).

I wish I could have enthusiasm for phones again. Everything isn't what I want.

I certainly won't make the mistake of making a phone integral to my personal workflows and habits again. I certainly won't come to rely on any native apps anymore, either.

I recognize I'm a fraction of a fraction of a percentage of the market. Very few people regard their technology like I do. I feel like the computers (and, at one time, the phones) I use are extensions of myself. I think it's a little like how a musician might regard a beloved instrument, or a craftsman might regard a well-used tool. Very few people get bent out of shape about subtle changes in UI, appearance, latency, or functionality the way I do.

I understand technology today isn't "for me".

It makes me really sad, though.

barbs2• 1 year ago

I'm still on my first gen iPhone SE. Thankfully the apps I use are mostly compatible, and I just use web versions for everything else. Have replaced the battery and screen a few times each.

This phone looks like it might be good replacement but it could also be a bit dodgy. I'm going to wait a bit for reviews before considering buying it https://aiphor.com/products/bluefox-nx1-4-0-android-smartpho...

maz1b• 1 year ago

I have on my desk, the Galaxy S8, iPhone SE (First generation), the iPhone 13 Mini, the iPhone 14 Pro and the Galaxy S22. I intentionally now choose and look for phones that are the smallest possible now (S25, iPhone 15pro or 16pro) etc

My favorite to take with me is the 13 Mini. Would love an iPhone 18 mini.

loloquwowndueo• 1 year ago

What a coincidence, I also want an iPhone mini-sized iPhone :) the 12 mini is the perfect size but sadly it was the last of its kind.

phyrex2• 1 year ago

There's a 13 mini

bschwindHN2• 1 year ago

I used the iPhone SE 1 until January of this year, it was such a great phone and a great form factor. I wrote an article about it to send it off:

https://blog.bschwind.com/2025/01/11/the-original-iphone-se-...

jihadjihad• 1 year ago

Pour one out. I’m still on my SE 2020 and have no idea what to go to once it dies.

user_78322• 1 year ago

Likewise. The 70-something percent battery health isn't the best (and the phone lags like crazy), but the other day I realized it's still a bit smaller than my 2015 Moto G3 (that I still use, though only for basic tasks).

If you are interested, Unihertz launched the titan 2 and it's pretty nice, but no waterproofing or wireless charging are big issues for me.

littlecranky67• 1 year ago

An iPhone SE 2023 - it still gets current iOS version updates. My iPhone 8 is also still running (using iOS 16) but still gets security updates.

ghiculescu• 1 year ago

I’m still rocking mine! Gonna start looking for second hand ones soon as the home button is starting to die, and that’s the best bit.

I found using the browser is a good enough alternative for many apps, and it also makes them less addictive because they aren’t as slick. Particularly handy for work apps.

barbs2• 1 year ago

The home button's not too hard to replace, at least compared to the screen and battery.

Mine actually broke ages ago but I've just gotten used to using TouchAssist.

AiAi• 1 year ago

I’m still using as a secondary device, but the battery was never the same after I replaced, and the touch id/home button doesn’t work anymore, so I have to use that virtual home button.

I ended up getting a newer SE (2022), but I miss the first one.

mrheosuper2• 1 year ago

the ip12/13 mini have similar footprint, but with modern feature.

bschwindHN2• 1 year ago

Yep the 13 mini is what I ended up on. I hope that form factor gets a refresh in a few years!

saagarjha2• 1 year ago

I still have mine as the bedside Hacker News browsing device. It is so much nicer to use than iPhone 13 mini which I use as my main phone :(

gandalfian• 1 year ago

Mobiles are made by Asian companies to Asian tastes. They like big screens so that's what we get. The two exceptions are apple iPhones and Google pixel. The two American companies making phones for American tastes. Shame as the old 4.5" mobiles had such large bezels they could have accommodated 6" modern screens...

axus• 1 year ago

Just wait for smart watches to keep getting bigger until they are mini-phone sized?

the__alchemist• 1 year ago

I recently bought a new Pixel 4 BC I want a fresh battery, but don't want anything bigger than this.

There are so many Android phone models, but not a single one that's a reasonable size?

ghostly_s• 1 year ago

I want an iPhone Mini sized iPhone.

ls-a• 1 year ago

I also wanted one, then Samsung released the foldable phones. The Z Flip was exactly what I wanted. Now that the Fold is so thin, I want it as a small iPad. I feel that Samsung has solved the small Android phone problem in a different way with foldables

_heimdall• 1 year ago

I've wanted a small android phone for a while now too, but partly because I just don't care much for smartphones and want a small and cheap option. Ideally it'd be a pixel so that it should support GrapheneOS.

The foldables are such an interesting concept. I actually had a Surface Duo for a while (though a different style of foldable) and really liked it, but I only had one after they were a year old and I could try it out with a used phone for ~$200.

kbrackbill3• 1 year ago

I guess people want different things out of small phones. I had a Z flip 3 for a few years because I thought the small pocket size would be nice, but it still doesn't solve the main issue that I can't reach the whole screen with my thumb. (and besides that I have a million other complaints about it, never going to buy a foldable again)

grumpy_old_man_• 1 year ago

I remember when people complained that the iphone 6 was ridiculously big ... I'll keep my 12mini until it dies. Then I might buy another 12mini on ebay. I don't edit videos on my phone That's what desktops are for.

snats• 1 year ago

i get it. i want one of those. the problem is that most cellphones are not actual cellphones, they are entertainment machines. they are a pocket tv / social media feed place. most usage for my normal friends is for that.

mannyv• 1 year ago

For most consumers their phone has become their primary device, so the big screens make sense. Computer at home? Nope.

I have multiple screen with me, so my 13 mini is great.

mixmix• 1 year ago

Funnily enough, I don't consider the iPhone 12/13 mini miniature at all. Granted, my hands are quite small even for someone of my height (5'7"), but remember those times people made fun of the iPhone 5 and of how gigantic it felt compared to 4S? I don't think human hands have grown that much since then. And I still believe the 1st generation SE is the best smartphone Apple has ever released: a rectangular screen, no camera bumps, a fingerprint sensor (that is still faster than Face ID), a mini jack, light, affordable, etc.

kbrackbill3• 1 year ago

The best phone I ever had was a Sony Xperia XZ2 Compact. I would still be using it if it wasn't too slow to run modern versions of android. This is one of those things that just makes me feel so out of touch with the rest of the world. Does everyone else have giant pockets and giant hands? Does everyone use their phone with two hands and carry a bag everywhere? Is it just a trend like small phones were a trend before smartphones? Why do people want these giant phones?

ivanjermakov• 1 year ago

Why do people want these giant phones?

Most people only use computers at work, solely relying on smartphones for communication, media, shopping, etc.

It makes sense to have a big screen at inconvenience of having to carry it around.

What surprises me is how small the demand for small phones is. I have absolutely no need for a big screen - I have a monitor.

shinycode• 1 year ago

I never ever use my laptop anymore outside of work. I never surf the web, read, order stuff etc from my laptop. It’s basically useless now if I don’t code or use pro apps. So a bigger phone is confortable because some websites suck on smaller screens and using an iPad is too big sometimes

turtlebits• 1 year ago

For more and more people, their phone is their primary (or only) device. On a day to day, I have more face time with my phone than my personal laptop.

Nursie7• 1 year ago

Does everyone use their phone with two hands

A lot of us do, yes.

and carry a bag everywhere?

As a guy in 36" waist jeans (yeah I need to lose a few kg)... I can fit an iphone 16 pro max in my pocket pretty comfortably.

Why do people want these giant phones?

Well, one reason is that I'm getting older and don't find it as easy to read tiny text on tiny screens any more. Another reason is that I sometimes watch streaming services on there.

Also it's shiny and the battery lasts forever.

Ekaros• 1 year ago

Been happy with Sony Xperia 10 series, which is similar width, but taller as tallness really do not annoy me. Also massive battery. Sadly they are going to stop selling those here, so I might just need to go to Samsung next year...

pessimizer• 1 year ago

Does everyone use their phone with two hands

They have to because of stupid pinch-to-zoom. You either have to balance the phone in the palm of your non-dominant hand (literally switch the phone from one hand to the other) while pinching with your dominant hand, or do a sort of goatse thing with your thumbs while holding the phone in both hands.

Screw-to-zoom is a million times better: draw a spiral to the right and you get closer, spiral to the left and you get farther away (agreeing with the "righty-tighty, lefty-loosey" standard.) Easily done with any single finger, or even with the thumb of the hand holding the phone (for people with adequate thumb-wrestling skills.)

famahar• 1 year ago

I have an xperia compact phone I bought for $50 in Japan. It's a bit slow, but I don't do much on it other than jot down notes, maps, photos (the lens is a bit broken so it creates a cool lens flare effect), and messaging. Fits nicely in my pocket and hand. A giant phone just seems so silly to me.

BuckRogers• 1 year ago

iPhone 12 mini lover and user checking in here. The haters will berate us for our choice stating that "no one wants a small phone", but that's a lie. Normal sized phones were never going to be instant day-one hits. It's a self-fulfilling prophecy to launch them during Covid, offer them 2 years, and say no one wants them.

Give them a permanent place in the lineup, treating phones like every other very personal device meant for humans. Small, medium, and large.

If you do that, and give people time to see exactly why 5.42 screens are superior to 6.1"+ sizes, then I think the numbers will start to change from what we saw with the iPhone 12 mini and iPhone 13 mini, which were both launched when people were less on the go than in 100 years.

yumenoandy• 1 year ago

i put my whole family on the last iphone mini generation

MinimalAction• 1 year ago

I signed up for this perhaps two years ago. I don't remember the update banner being present at the top which says it's officially moving forward. I didn't find anything more on that, what's the actual status now?

david4222• 1 year ago

I think it's a dead project. There hasn't been any updates. I signed up about the same time you did.

grahar64• 1 year ago

I wrote this post https://maori.geek.nz/small-light-robust-phones-for-a-type-1... that has a bunch of examples of small phones. The requirements are not exactly the same, but in the same boat as for want of good solid small phones.

I recommend the pixel 4a 5g with LineageOS installed, or the Q9 mini.

VagabundoP3• 1 year ago

I moved from a Pixel 2 to the Pixel 5 and I'm very happy small phone user.

userbinator2• 1 year ago

12 years ago a small Chinese company made this Android clone of an iPhone 4, but with additional features:

https://www.gizchina.com/2013/11/07/jiayu-g5-unboxing-hands-...

https://www.gizchina.com/2013/09/18/exclusive-hands-video-st...

https://www.gizmochina.com/2013/09/22/teardown-picture-jiayu...

That was the "peak smartphone" era for me; lots of companies making slightly different variations on Androids, at relatively low prices, but almost all of them with the same basic set of practical features which are nearly extinct today. Now it seems all we get are faster CPUs and RAM, more (non-removable) storage and battery capacity, no headphone jacks, a very limited choice of screen sizes, and far too many cameras along with the obligatory unremovable spyware and locked-down OS.

mrheosuper2• 1 year ago

I will hold my ip13 mini until i can't.

dismalaf• 1 year ago

Small Android phones did exist. They got bigger because the big phones ("phablets") sold better.

Also, you can buy reasonably sized Android phones. They're still big-ish compared to say, 2008, but not huge considering the lack of bezel.

catlikesshrimp• 1 year ago

> "Now I'm building Beeper - a universal chat app that lets you chat on 15+ different chat networks (including WhatsApp, iMessage, etc)."

That is another idea which apple didn't like.

nunez3• 1 year ago

If there's anyone that can make this happen, it'll be Eric. I signed up and absolutely cannot wait for the Pebble hacker to do this.

david4222• 1 year ago

I signed up 2 years ago. I think it's a dead project :(

pentagrama• 1 year ago

iPhone 13 Mini (2023) = 5.4 inches (discontinued).

Pixel 9 (2024) = 6.3 inches.

I know the Pixel 9 is not that small, but is close and an excellent phone (base or Pro models, the XL is bigger).

CephalopodMD• 1 year ago

you can pry my 13 mini from my cold dead hands

jachee• 1 year ago

I want an iPhone Mini-sized iPhone again.

I busted out my old 4S, and the fit//finish,, materials, and just how nice it is to hold in your hand and operate are still really nice. Would love to fill it with modern guts.

exabrial• 1 year ago

same

zhyder• 1 year ago

I had filled out the form for this. Wish Eric stuck to this instead of the Pebble revival: it'd have a bigger market.

I don't understand how the market isn't considered big enough for any phone OEM: how can it be smaller than that of foldables? Or even if it is, isn't it still big enough, and shouldn't there generally be more sizes and form factors of phones?

It's as tho the car industry decided to only make 184" long SUVs (6.2-6.7" phones) and 200" long 3-row SUVs (foldables)... no other SUVs, no sedans/hatchbacks, no sports cars (much smaller and much lower volume). And different cars are actually hard to engineer and mass-manufacture the chassis and bodies for... in contrast a phone's HW is inherently more modular and mostly just the screen and battery need to be changed for each size.

notpushkin2• 1 year ago

Wait, is there any chance Google has released Pebble OS source code so that Eric doesn’t pursue making a small phone?

Wistar• 1 year ago

Heck, I want a new iPhone mini sized iPhone. I am stubbornly sticking to my iPhone 12 Mini because it is the form factor I really want.

ShadowBanThis03• 1 year ago

You can't even buy an iPhone-mini-sized iPhone anymore.

Get used to making calls on a TV tray, and walking around looking like a schlub in cargo shorts for the rest of your life.

Scrapemist• 1 year ago

It is simply more difficult to cram the specs into a smaller form factor and they sell for less. A loose-loose situation. The same is happening in the tv market. 32” is disappearing because it’s more expensive to build smaller 4k displays.

hollowturtle• 1 year ago

Imo the real problem here is being able to use a phone with one hand, UI standardization led both android and iphone unusable with one hand, so I'd argue we actually stopped research mobile touch interfaces. A smaller phone would still need you to stretch the thumb to the other side of the screen

RachelF• 1 year ago

The Samsung S10e was probably peak Android. Small, high-end, SD card and 3.5mm jack.

There are some decent small Android phones, if you're willing to buy non-mainstream brands. Take a look at:

https://www.reddit.com/r/smallphones/

smt88• 1 year ago

There's nothing close to the iPhone Mini anymore though

qingcharles• 1 year ago

The 13 Mini should still get iOS updates for another couple of years, I think?

Certainly iOS 26 appears to be supported.

ashellunts• 1 year ago

Fully agree. Mine has broken recently and I needed to buy a new phone. The S25 I have now is not much bigger, but even that small difference matters much. Though 120Hz screen is nice.

ChrisRR6• 1 year ago

As someone who often checks that sub, all I can say is that there's no decent small phones and it's just people constantly checking whether one has been released yet

GuB-42• 1 year ago

For me, it would be the Samsung Galaxy S5 but with modern hardware.

In addition to being small, with SD card and 3.5mm jack, it is water resistant and has a removable battery. It is also one of the most robust non-hardened phones. It has an IR blaster too if it matters to you.

It was a time when Samsung was known for its gimmicks, the one for the Galaxy S5 is "Air View", where it recognizes your finger hovers over the screen. It is actually a good one, because it supports the "hover" targets in web pages!

Most people find it ugly though, and I tend to agree, but if you use a case, like most people do, who cares what the phone inside looks like?

Tade0• 1 year ago

I've held on to my S8 as long as possible, because even if the battery wasn't removable any more, it lasted the lifetime of the device, despite heating up considerably during the summer.

My current Xperia 5 maintains battery temperature around 10°C above ambient during fast charging and since it easily lasts the whole day in the 30-80% charge regime, I believe it will outlast other components.

koiueo2• 1 year ago

Asus ZF10 is a more recent specimen. And it's more "peak" IMO. No bloatware, DC dimming, rugged design which doesn't require a case for everyday use.

dalmo32• 1 year ago

I've just bought a used s10e in pristine condition for $200. It's glorious.

Re: TFA, I'm all for filling the small phone niche, but there's no way I'm paying a cent over $500 for a phone with no resale value.

iamevn• 1 year ago

I'm very happy with my Unihertz Jelly Max aside from the camera being not great. I think it's the smallest it can reasonably be (62.7mm wide) while still having its touchscreen keyboard be usable and because it's fairly thick it actually feels good to hold in my hands and I don't need to stick one of those silly pop sockets on the back.

xarope• 1 year ago

I dream of a foldable with an e-ink screen for multi-day usage, and an OLED screen when folded open for media/game consumption.

Someone pinch me awake when that happens, thanks.

mousethatroared2• 1 year ago

Larger phones have better battery life time.

Screen power draw and battery capacity scale as the square of the linear dimension. They largely cancel out.

However, all the other hardware are a fixed size so proportionally large phones have longer battery lives.

avereveard• 1 year ago

Also panel manufacturer will not run limited run 5.4in panel just for a niche market and if they did cost would be super high.

Like internal component can be rearranged to an extent, and battery is a tradeoff, but the panel need to be one on the market, no demand, no panel

coolg54321• 1 year ago

Chinese manufactures has been using silicon carbon batteries with larger densities for long time, for example 6.3" vivo X200 FE has a 6500mAh battery which should solve small phone-smaller battery problem

mousethatroared2• 1 year ago

Ya but manufacturers believe, rightly, that folks will always prefer battery life to pocket confort.

I say this as someone who clung onto his 1st gen SE until I got my current 13 mini

qwerty2000• 1 year ago

Yeah... we definitely don't get what we want.

billfor• 1 year ago

This was written before the Pixel 8, 8a, 9, and 9 pro. All of those are just slightly larger than a iPhone mini, at about 6.2".

leidenfrost• 1 year ago

I have an S23 base for that exact reason.

A full flagship phone at 6.1" size

Trollmann• 1 year ago

They're slightly larger than a iPhone 16. Both are significantly larger than the mini iPhones. https://phonesized.com/compare/#2535,2552,1863

Abishek_Muthian• 1 year ago

I literally have dwarf hands, after experimenting with various form factors I've settled on using iPhone SE (4.7") as the main phone and a android (6.7") running FOSS stack as the secondary phone.

I get the "just works" with decent privacy aspect of the smaller iPhone, health benefits from Apple Watch and for anything requiring longer screen time, termux, shelter cloned apps etc. I use the bigger android (Infact I'm typing this on the excellent HN client Hacki from android).

Earlier I used to use Apple Watch with android using a tool I built[1] which now serves notifications from android to my iPhone.

I'm glad Eric is going ahead with the small phone.

[1] https://github.com/abishekmuthian/apple-watch-with-android

leke• 1 year ago

It was quite strange to read this title this morning as my 15 year old daughter just received her iPhone 13 mini yesterday from Swappie. She too was complaining that the android phones are too big for her little hands.

I tried all my reasoning skills to persuade her to stick with android, but ultimately she nagged me into getting a second hand one that is still way too expensive in my opinion.

Well it looks like she is right and this is popular opinion. Perhaps small Android phones not selling well is a marketing problem. I've never seen one advertised with size being a selling point.

adithyassekhar3• 1 year ago

I think she prefers an iphone even if there was a tiny android phone.

jeffhuys• 1 year ago

Thing about iphones is yea, they’re expensive, but if well-cared for can last you longer. I’m on a 6-year upgrade cycle and could stretch that more if I wanted to. Will go from my 12 pro to the 18 or 19 pro.

QAkICoU7IDNkpFu• 1 year ago

I was using Xperia XZ1 compact (4.6") and then moved to Vivo X70 pro+ (6.9") and it's so much easier for the eyes and typing. Yes, it's not the most convenient thing to carry around but I'd rather have less eye strain and typos.

Also I think China makes 3-4" android phones but they're mostly a joke spec wise

hexagonwin• 1 year ago

I'm still using a 2013 LG G2 (SD800) and can't find a single device that I can switch to. The compact size is just perfect. iPhone 5/s/e was also pretty good but apple killed them with updates :/

user_78322• 1 year ago

Just as an FYI to everyone who thinks such products are financially "infeasible" - look at companies like Unihertz (or heck, even Framework). Niche categories can and do attract a small but devoted following.

Btw:

1. Unihertz recently launched a BlackBerry esque phone (titan 2), if anyone reading this is interested. (Not sponsored by them)

2. There are many forums (and I think r/smallphones on reddit) where you can find much more discussion on such topics if you're interested.

margalabargala• 1 year ago

Unihertz's phones are unfortunately simply technologically infeasible (to use). Their software is apparently write-once update-never, and any phone you buy of theirs will be riddled with permanent bugs.

If Unihertz kept their phones up to date for a few years after launch, rather than only for the few years prior to launch, they would be an incredibly strong competitor in this space but as they are they are next to useless.

oaiey• 1 year ago

Actually Framework is often asked to build a phone. So maybe the author should partner with them.

NoGravitas5• 1 year ago

Unihertz makes phones in a ton of interesting form factors. And then never support them with updates. The number of phones where my mouse has hovered over the "Add to Cart" button on their website before deciding updates are too important...

ergocoder• 1 year ago

I want a reliable e-ink phone. Minimal phone is good but flaky to the point that it is annoying.

Odd UX that can't be configured (and no idea why). For example, if you touch the power button, it'll unlock and wake up the phone. There's no way to turn that off and require a click. Other android phones can but not minimal. like what the hell was going through their decision making process?

maxglute5• 1 year ago

At this rate better chance of waiting for cover screen of flip foldables to be mini phone sized.

rtcoms• 1 year ago

Samsung Z Flip 7 has that, it was launches few days back.

O-stevns• 1 year ago

I got the iPhone 13 mini as a work phone for the sole reason of it being the smallest iPhone at the time. I too dislike the phone landscape nowadays with their ridiculous and ever increasing sizes.

My personal device is a Motorola Razr 50 Ultra, which I got because while it's huge when flipped, it's portable enough when it's closed. I can have it in my pocket without it falling out.. without it being annoying while i put on shoes etc...

I use its cover screen a fair amount too, to avoid having to flip it open, which is also why I got the ultra rather than the slightly smaller version.

burnt-resistor3• 1 year ago

The iPhone 13 Pro -> 16 Pro upsizing is ridiculous. The 13 was just the right size, but now they had to change it so they could sell more cases. It's almost phablet-size now. Look at an iPhone 6S by comparison.

FinnKuhn2• 1 year ago

The iPhone 13 pro is 71.5mm x 146.7mm x 7.65mm [1] and the iPhone 16 pro is 71.5mm x 149.3mm x 8.25mm [2].

While it did get a tiny bit bigger I wouldn’t have noticed this u less you would look up the spec, especially as it got lighter from 204g [1] to 199g [2] at the same time.

[1] https://support.apple.com/en-us/111871 [2] https://www.apple.com/iphone-16-pro/specs/

Analemma_• 1 year ago

This is an “unpleasable customer” problem. When the 13 Pro was current, everyone was yelling at Apple that it was too thin and that they wanted a slightly thicker phone with more battery life, which is what Apple did.

BrtByte5• 1 year ago

The fact that you're using the cover screen regularly kind of proves the point: most of the time we don't need a tablet-sized display

mpweiher• 1 year ago

I just want an iPhone Mini-sized iPhone.

It's OK if they just make one every couple of years. But please: at least every couple of years.

volemo6• 1 year ago

I don't care how often they make it as long as they release a new one before discontinuing the previous one. %(

manbitesdog• 1 year ago

Same, I am a 13 mini user and will probably stay this way until there is a realistic alternative. It's obnoxious that there isn't a single phone on the market where you can reach the top corner with one hand.

quite-sfwd• 1 year ago

We happy few will probably stay with them until their last breath

BrtByte5• 1 year ago

It's wild that something as basic as "a small phone that isn't garbage" has become a niche wish instead of a standard option

udev4096• 1 year ago

I love mini phones too but how naive do you have to be to trust a random page over an actual phone manufacturer? I can get a new pixel at 500$, install GrapheneOS on it, and call it secure enough. I wish google would make mini-pixel versions, same as apple does with SE

jakegmaths• 1 year ago

I'm writing this on a Unihertz Jelly Star which is tiny, and I consider it my "protest phone" at the lack of decent small phones.

A friend jokingly calls it my "microphone", another a "prison phone" (due to its size allowing for more easily smuggling in body cavities). Occasionally I go to mobile phone shops and ask if they have a case for it just for the fun of seeing the look on their faces when they see it (I don't actually want a case, and in fact it came with one which I threw in the bin).

Personally, I couldn't be happier with it.

Only problems: they don't do software updates; camera is poor; non-OLED screen.

In an ideal world I'd have a slightly bigger phone, but not too much bigger. I've grown very fond of this phone.

userbinator2• 1 year ago

non-OLED screen

I'd consider that an advantage: No burn-in.

franga20005• 1 year ago

Is OLED burn-in really something people still care about? I have a handful of OLED devices, some of which I've used daily for nearly 10 years, and none of them have any burn-in. I've never even seen burn-in on anything other than a signage TV, and that happens even on some LCDs.

ChrisRR6• 1 year ago

The jelly star has got junk in the trunk though

helloworlddd• 1 year ago

What sort of junk?

sensen2• 1 year ago

The thickness of the phone honestly isn't an issue at all. The phone is so small that it remains easily pocketable.

ethan_smith• 1 year ago

The Jelly Star's battery life is surprisingly decent for its size - I get about 8 hours of moderate use, but it requires a mid-day charge if you're using GPS or watching videos.

normie3000• 1 year ago

So, same as iPhone mini :)

jcgl• 1 year ago

The lack of updates/general software sketchiness is what has me turned off from the Jelly. I know a product like that never has a chance in hell of running Graphene, I’d be way more interested if it could run Lineage.

twiclo2• 1 year ago

I run lineage on mine. It's much better than the OS it came with.

NoGravitas5• 1 year ago

There's an unofficial Lineage build, I believe.

NoGravitas5• 1 year ago

The Jelly Max is 5" (so bigger than previous Jellies, smaller than mainstream phones). I'd strongly consider one except for their lack of software updates.

maxglute5• 1 year ago

Market wants big phones. The solution... look to the east. Phone accessories to manage big phones. Many women with small hands using finger loops (that double as kickstands), wrist straps, full body lanyards.

Convincing main brands to dump 100s of millions to cater to small phone crowd should be proven DOA by now. The minimalist EDC crowd is niche aberration, most people throughout civilization EDC was more cumbersome. Most people are simply happy carrying more shit around. Look at Stanley cups.

TBH 99% of big phone yucky crowd problems would be solved by a lanyard, but that's too goofy in the west. IMO what we need is better pockets. Front of legs or side belly of shirt. Have a little place to attach a chain like pocket watches. Fix for big phones is not a smaller phone, but better accessory/wardrobe.

raverbashing• 1 year ago

I disagree, it seems the Eastern phones are gigantic for some reason

And yes I do want smaller phones. Samsung S10e was the perfect size tbh.

But no it seems the option dwindle and now I can't find a phone smaller than my thumb. At least some phones have a "shrink screen" option, but that's not the same thing as a smaller phone tbh

maxglute5• 1 year ago

Tiny market =/= no market, but not sustainable market. One hand mode + one hand type mode is not the same as small phone, but it makes one hand mode on big devices feasible. I'm personally waiting for eastern foldable phones to get hilariously gigantic so the front cover screen become useful "mini" phones.

Dylan16807• 1 year ago

Some people want a phone where they can use the screen with one hand.

maxglute5• 1 year ago

Phone finger strap + learn one hand mode.

ragazzina• 1 year ago

Most people are simply happy carrying more shit around. Look at Stanley cups.

This is only true for the American lifestyle of home-car-office-car-home. If you need to walk for more than 30 seconds Stanley cups become extremely inconvenient.

eertami• 1 year ago

I thought Stanley cups is a weird choice to make "more shit" sound wasteful or a bad thing. Typically I think the American lifestyle is people carrying fewer things usually. I walk or cycle most places but always take a backpack, but I've frequently seen American-centric communities dismiss this as weird (because the car becomes their backpack).

As plans develop during a day it's easy to end up being out of the house 12+ hours, so it's comfortable to have a refillable water bottle, warmer layers, sunglasses, hat, umbrella, any other comfort things etc.

deffrin3• 1 year ago

If I have money and the knowledge to build a phone, surely i will make it possible one day.

But I don't know why new innovative people are not getting into smartphone making.

Everyone is trying to make the next big software. But why that grit is missing to bring the variety into small hardware devices that target majority?

Or, is it not reaching people like me? Is it the lack of awareness?

ge96• 1 year ago

One reason is the modem, proprietary blob

I think another reason is sourcing good parts that aren't old and bulky, speaking from the Linux phones I tried

Also drivers somebody has to write em

I used to be annoyed that you had to choose between Android or iOS

I wish android phones had lidar

deffrin3• 1 year ago

yes. that makes sense.

VoxPelli5• 1 year ago

Check eg. the Mudita Kompakt: https://store.mudita.com/store/mudita-kompakt-global

And the Light Phone 3: https://www.thelightphone.com/lightiii

deffrin3• 1 year ago

both seems to be good options. will try one of these one day.

renewiltord• 1 year ago

All this is available on China market. Go buy there. Everyone always makes this post when they can just buy Chinese phone. Go get a Soyes or something.

chartered_stack• 1 year ago

I'm a convert on this topic. I went from wanting a small phone to being unable to wait to ditch mine.

Like the OP, I switched from Android (Pixel 3a) to an iPhone SE 3 specifically for the smaller form factor. After using it for over a year, I've found the trade-offs in battery life and camera quality are too significant for my daily use.

These limitations aren't an issue when I'm at home or my desk with easy access to a charger. However, they become acute the moment I'm out for the day. For example, using GPS for navigation or connecting Bluetooth accessories becomes a liability. I can't rely on the phone to last. Also, photos are noticeably more pixelated, and the quality drop-off is clear compared to larger, contemporary phones.

This thread is evidence that the niche for small phones exists. But it's for people willing to accept these compromises by carrying a dedicated camera, a power bank, and using wired peripherals. For me and as the market suggests for most consumers, small phones just doesn't work out as reliable all-in-one devices. I'll probably wait till early next year to pick up one of the new iPhones after they iron out the initial kinks.

Jolter• 1 year ago

The iPhone SE 3 might have a poor camera, but the one on the iPhone mini 13 is excellent!

My conclusion is the same as the author’s: it’s a matter of you get what you pay for. The demand here is for a small premium phone. This would come with a good set of cameras.

VoxPelli5• 1 year ago

"the trade-offs in battery life and camera quality are too significant" - a small but thicker phone would have no trouble with battery life and could for sure have the same good cameras as larger phones – and could possibly even ditch the camera bump if it just made the entire phone as thick as the camera bump to fit a larger battery.

(After all, easiest way to increase battery size is to increase the smallest dimension. Add 1mm to a 4-4.5mm thick battery and you'll increase the battery size by 22-25%. Make the iPhone 13 Mini as thick as its camera bump and you would probably add ≈2.4mm, which would make the battery 60% larger)

VoxPelli5• 1 year ago

If one were to make a iPhone 17 Pro Mini as thick as the iPhone 4 then it would:

- Likely still weigh less than a Pro Max - Have a battery with a capacity larger than the Pro Max - Have the pro cameras stick out about as much as they did on the iPhone 6

And it would feel as robust and solid as an iPhone 4 – my favorite iPhone so far

vintagedave• 1 year ago

carrying a dedicated camera, a power bank, and using wired peripherals

I'm a small-phone person, and I don't think these _should_ be necessary. I'm fine with wired peripherals (and prefer them), but in 2025, with efficient chips, I don't see why we can't power a device much longer than 24 hours. What if it had decade-old hardware, and -- this is the bit I think is the problem -- the operating system and apps were efficient?

Same with a camera. It seems more about thickness than width; I don't believe it should be impossible to put a large-phone-format camera in a smaller phone. It may take battery space, but see above, we should be ok there these days.

volemo6• 1 year ago

but in 2025, with efficient chips, I don't see why we can't power a device much longer than 24 hours.

That is only possible if we don't write the software with dozen layers of abstraction and gimmicky features (looking at you, Liquid Glass!).

ChrisRR6• 1 year ago

The biggest power drain is still the screen and those haven't really improved that much.

flakeoil• 1 year ago

Since Pixel 3a and iPhone SE 3, the battery technology has improved and especially the charging times have gone down dramatically so the battery life experience you had then would not occur today with the same form factor.

asimops• 1 year ago

Wow, that exploded over night :D It's nice to see, I am not alone.

With Android working on including a "desktop mode" where you can add a screen and HID devices, I sure hope that the phone screens will get smaller again.

raynr2• 1 year ago

I saw a post on this subject in the android subreddit back in 2019 [0] and it was clear that everyone had already accepted by then that the market was too small to sustain this. I too loved Sony's series of compact phones - the XZ1 Compact is still one of the best phones I've ever used.

It is only going to get worse. Most of us who were young adults when the iPhone was announced are in our 40s now, and presbyopia is a real thing. In a few years my daily QOL will be better served by a bigger phone and I suspect many people around my age are feeling the same thing. The "small electronic accessory I bring around" niche will be filled by smartwatches.

[0] https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/dijok5/is_there_a_... (how quaint the prices look, a mere 6 years on)

VoxPelli5• 1 year ago

The Mudita Kompakt (https://store.mudita.com/store/mudita-kompakt-global) is a 4.3” e-ink Android based phone that's about the size of an iPhone Mini.

It doesn't have the Google Play Store but one can sideload Android apps onto it

NoGravitas5• 1 year ago

My only gripe with the Mudita Kompakt is that one of the reasons I need a smartphone is to run those little apps without which you cannot navigate the modern world - 2FA, corporate proprietary 2FA, parking, bank (my bank lets you deposit checks through the app, but not through the website, else I would only use the website). And a lot of those require the Play Integrity API at some level, unfortunately.

VoxPelli5• 1 year ago

Yeah, same here :/

trumbitta22• 1 year ago

Everybody loves a mini phone. Then you hit your 40s or 50s, and you suddenly understand the benefits of having a bigger screen.

trumbitta22• 1 year ago

Yeah, thanks for the downvote. You're right. People older than 30 shouldn't exist and shouldn't be here commenting.

phplovesong• 1 year ago

The iPhone 4S was just this. Small, and had it all. It was the best iphone i owned. After this the overall phone size has ballooned. Such a shame.

crossroadsguy5• 1 year ago

$700-800

I can.

Nothing will make happier than ditching Apple and get a smaller Android phone. In fact the size of iPhone 5s was the only reason that had piqued my interest and I had migrated to the iPhones. Then I stayed for other (and important) reasons.

Stock Android OS

Ah, no. I take that back. That is not going to be worth 700-800 just for the size! In fact take more and put it to a fight which tries to force Google to "decolonise" every aspect of this mobile OS and push for apps to go for alternative app stores.

But as long as Google has it claws and fingers and feet and palm and teeth (imagine every other organ) into my data (and also existence via sensors and what not) on an Android phone in every way possible (sometimes not even imaginable), such pervasive and entangled, that getting out of this Kafkaesque privacy nightmare means using a custom ROM that no OEM supports (or probably will every support) and half the app I use (including bank/payment/Govt apps) will stop functioning and it makes me feel like puking - even the thought of being tracked like that non-stop!

Until then sadly I will contribute to the trillions of Apple and participate in this cozy duopoly these companies have established and rather be in this Kafkaesque control and closed walled garden. It is sad.

So no, I am done with "Stock Android OS" trope at this point :(

The reality is - and it is a sad truth - such a phone in today's world can only exist as a vanity/niche product and hence even with high cost it will suffer from lack of support, abandoned update/upgrade promises, and a really really bad support experience unless it is released to "just few cities" (not even few countries) because this is going to attract such a small number of people!

volemo6• 1 year ago

Doesn't "unlockable bootloader" requirement solve this problem?

karel-3d2• 1 year ago

There is no "stock android" btw. There is no such thing.

RichardCA2• 1 year ago

It's turned into a generic term that usually means the ability to remove all corporate branding from the UI. A lot of it is in the ability to apply themes. For example the Icon style for Android 6 (Marshmallow) is now considered retro.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_Marshmallow#/media/Fil...

I particularly despise the way Samsung wants to use impose a "bulging squircle" icon shape and I always find a way to override that (Nova Launcher still works well for this use case).

franga20005• 1 year ago

"Stock Android" usually means "what runs on Pixels" in Android user circles, not actually AOSP. It's a comparison between Samsung/Huawei/Xiaomi/... and Google/OnePlus/Motorola/...

crossroadsguy5• 1 year ago

“Stock Android” means where Google does inside it what I have listed above in less savoury words. The ones you’ve listed are basically compromised devices in your pockets — so a notch higher or lower, depending upon how you look at all this :)

thorio3• 1 year ago

Since Google is about to brick my Pixel 6a with the battery botchering update, i find myself in the same struggle again i had when buying the 6a.

Basically you have to make compromises on performance and camera and then this was, what i came up with: - Zenfone 10 (flagship with prices still above launch price (!), which soon gets no updates anymore) - Unihertz Jelly Max (small, but thick and bad camera) - Rakuten Hand 5G and Rakuten Mini (also bad camera and older Android) - Balmuda Phone (which i really like, but also bad camera and discontinued, so probably not even security updates and no custom rom support) - Bluefox NX1 (really tempting, but appearantly kind of bad build quality and no NFC)

All other options are even older phones. Samsung S25 line does exist, but i really like vanilla Android. I think the price chart of the Zenfone DOES somehow indicates the existence of a market and i wonder if it would be big enough for a small niche player!?

Personally I am considering a pixel 8, which is the "smallest" of current phones, but it still really isn't small. And i don't see myself as a Google customer because of the battery topic...

I personally would have been more happy had Eric made a small android phone instead of the new pebble, but hey...

mmarian• 1 year ago

I have the Pixel 8, and I've been happy with the battery and pretty much everything. It's got a great performance/price ratio.

twiclo2• 1 year ago

Couldn't you put lineage on the zenfone?

thorio3• 1 year ago

How problematic is app compatibility with Lineage nowadays? (banking, google-pay etc.)

martin_henk• 1 year ago

Rakuten hand was/is very small.

thorio3• 1 year ago

Couldn't get my hands on one so far as they don't sell in Germany. Could you elaborate a bit if you had the chance to try one?

NoGravitas5• 1 year ago

I got a Pixel 8, and it's not small, but it's reasonably sized. About the same as the Moto G7 I replaced, much smaller than my kid's current Moto G Power. The good thing about the Pixel 8 is that you can run LineageOS on it, which was the main thing that determined my choice.

tauntz• 1 year ago

I switched from a Pixel 3a to an iPhone 16 and it really bothers me that it's way too huge for everyday usage. Maybe I have extremely short thumbs but here's the maximum reach I have on the screen when I hold my phone "normally" in my hand: https://i.postimg.cc/Cx97jxLZ/iphone16reach.png - I can't reach the upper part of the screen at all, without doing finger-gymnastics or using my other hand. I'd love to switch to a phone that is 50-60%% of the size of the iPhone 16 but there are essentially no (modern) options for this. It's really a bummer :(

glandium• 1 year ago

I have both and they're surprisingly essentially the same size. Except the iPhone has less bezel and is thicker. I only have the iPhone for dev purposes and I actually prefer the Pixel 3a, but I'm afraid it might die soon...

Anyways, are you sure you're talking about the iPhone 16?

coldpie3• 1 year ago

It's clunky and stupid, but if you "swipe down" off the bottom of the screen, it will bring the top half down into the reachable area. That's the fix they chose, instead of making phones that fit in a human's hand.

karel-3d2• 1 year ago

buy a z flip

ChrisRR6• 1 year ago

I'd even be happy with a 5.5" phone nowadays but no-one even makes them

ZeljkoS• 1 year ago

You can actually find small Android phones via excellent GSMArena phone finder: https://www.gsmarena.com/search.php3?nYearMin=2023&fDisplayI...

Quick search for just display size found these 10 phones released after 2023: https://www.gsmarena.com/results.php3?nYearMin=2023&fDisplay...

einpoklum2• 1 year ago

My very lax criteria yield only 4 phones released since 2023:

* A phone, not a watch

* Android 14 or later OS

* Thickness: 9mm max

* Height: 150mm max

* Width: 71mm max

and three of them are the overpriced Samsung Galaxy S phones. Only 7 released since 2020:

https://www.gsmarena.com/search.php3?nYearMin=2020&nHeightMa...

and they are Samsung Galaxy S's, a couple of Asus ZenFone's, and Google Pixel 5.

If you're willing to add another 5mm, there are also a couple of Sony Xperia's and Sharp Aquous, and Google Pixel 8. And if you want to cap the height at 145 mm - it's just Google Pixel 5.

Raed667• 1 year ago

There are some rugged Android phones with the "mini" format ~5.5"

They can be quite chunky but honestly not too bad

OldfieldFund• 1 year ago

I think the main reason is battery.

sjw9877• 1 year ago

We are unfortunately a neglected part of the market.

I used to have a Pixel 5. As somebody who uses phones minimally (<10 min average screentime per day), but still wants utilities beyond a feature phone for special use cases (maps, translate, digital tickets, public transport, NFC payments), it was about as small as I needed it to be to tuck it away in my pocket for the whole day. It was also quite a nice form factor with a black stone-like back case, which didn't seem to scuff or attract fingerprints.

I had two of them. The first one lasted 2 years before the battery swelled up and I had to dispose of it. Google replaced it for free with another. Then eventually Google Pay stopped being supported on the second, since it was a few years beyond security updates.

After that I found no alternative within the Android ecosystem. I don't want to get into Apple products (despite minimal use, I did have the phone customised so that it was stripped bare in terms of apps and notifications, and had a launcher which I preferred over Google's native design), and every tech blog talking about small phones led back to Pixel 5, or one of the ones just after which was also out of sale and security coverage.

Even though they are sold at profit, I get the feeling phones are viewed by the industry as vehicles. Get one with a big screen into peoples hands, then keep riding on the payments for games, movies, TV and web browsing that follows that. As somebody who never used my phone for any of these things, I'm clearly not important to the market for the one-off payment of a new phone every 5/6 years.

VagabundoP3• 1 year ago

I'm using a google pixel 5 with google pay right now.

sjw9877• 1 year ago

Just a heads up, when I contacted Google Support about this, they insinuated that this is something slowly being rolled out across Pixel 5 devices, so while it may work now, it could stop at any moment.

The issue I received when tapping to pay was "Your phone doesn't meet software standards". It did mention it can be due to rooting (my phone wasn't rooted) or "uncertified software" (of which I didn't have any).

I'm sure you might already do so, but I'd advise not to rely on the phone to pay going forward. For me, I was caught off guard in a shop without any other payment method. There was no warning or notification about the change until I tapped to pay at the card terminal.

I tried a few more times afterwards with another payment method as backup, and it never worked again, even after rebooting, toggling NFC off and on. I never received an email, notification or warning in the app itself. It was quite disappointing as I reckon I could have run that phone for a few more years as a minimal phone.

Google did offer me about £100 off of a new Pixel. So if this happens to you and the lack of Google Pay is a dealbreaker, I'd give that a try.

amelius3• 1 year ago

Maybe buy a flip-phone?

By the way, Apple is horribly behind in this area. It is time for them to realize that not everybody wants the same form factor. And people are getting bored by Apple's run-of-the-mill designs.

Aissen• 1 year ago

We see those posts regularly about people wanting a flagship small phone, but I see two options:

- either the market is dysfunctional, and the niche of people wanting those devices does not meet the smartphone offer.

- or the market is even smaller than what they think, making it unsustainable.

Both can be solved with time and patience (waiting for this to happen as conditions change) — or by voting with your wallet and making this requirement have priority over others (security, updates, quality, performance, compatibility, etc.).

wkat4242• 1 year ago

Samsung's S-series (without plus or ultra or edge or whatever) is basically this. Not quite as small as an iPhone mini, but just about small enough to be ok for me. Shouldn't be any bigger though (especially not wider!). For me the width is the big issue with big phones. It just feels uncomfortable in the hand then.

betimsl• 1 year ago

Dream phone: Underclocked Samsung25 internals, iPhone SE design/dimensions, at least 90hz OLED panel, 1 back decent camera, 1 front too. 3A battery. Preferably an extenal SD card slot.

theothertimcook• 1 year ago

https://aiphor.com/products/bluefox-nx1-4-0-android-smartpho...

https://www.unihertz.com/collections/jelly-series

https://soyes.vip/en

https://www.aliexpress.com/w/wholesale-servo-mobile-phones.h...

They’re all kinda ass though

Retr0id• 1 year ago

Cameras must be as good as Pixel 5
must have great low light performance

You'll probably have to compromise here a little too. Having "good" smartphone cameras is more about the software than the hardware (there's only so much you can do with small apertures and small sensors), and the flagships have huge R&D investments behind them.

I too want a small phone, and I'd be willing to settle for "passable" camera quality.

righthand• 1 year ago

Forget Apple sizes, I want a 3-4 inch sqaure (4:3) phone. Preferrably with a keyboard that folds or slides out. Something I can use with one hand or two and not have to switch to two hands to tap an upper corner.

Piraty• 1 year ago

htc HD mini was the perfect form factor

Marciplan• 1 year ago

"My goal here is to rally other fans of small phones together and put pressure on Google/Samsung/anyone to consider making a small phone." 41k people is impressive, but that doesn't move the needle for any of these companies by a long long shot

VagabundoP3• 1 year ago

Small phone person here. I tried the Sony Compacts and it was a good phone but very fragile. Smashed quite quickly.

Moved to a Pixel 2 and then to a Pixel 5. I'm happy with the 5, good size and good features, fast enough for what I want and battery is okay.

desdenova• 1 year ago

This is almost describing the ASUS Zenfone 9 (except for some reason they wanted only 8GB RAM, while the zen 9 has 16).

The small size and clean stock Android were the main reasons I bought this, and it's still a great phone.

rickdeckard9• 1 year ago

The hard reality is that there is no PAYING market for such a device, because when it comes to the point-of-sale, most people still choose the normal-size device with better screen/battery/camera.

This is equivalent to something I called the "QWERTY paradox" more than a decade ago:

Back when the Smartphone market exploded, people disliked typing on a touchscreen and repeatedly stated that they want a device with a physical keyboard.

There was plenty of evidence, surveys, market studies, trend predictions, devices for these "Messaging-centric" use-cases were always part of this market-demand roster.

But whenever someone answered the call and built a Smartphone with QWERTY keyboard, the product failed commercially, simply because also to people claiming they want such a phone, at the point of sale they were less attractive than their slimmer, lighter, all-screen counterparts.

Every major vendor went through this cycle of learning that lesson, usually with an iteration like "it needs to be a premium high-spec device" --> (didn't sell) --> "ah, it should be mass-market" --> (also didn't sell).

You can find this journey for every vendor. Samsung, LG, HTC, Motorola, Sony.

The same lessons were already learnt for small-screen devices: There was a "Mini" series of Samsung Galaxy, LG G-series, HTC One, Sony Xperia. It didn't sell, the numbers showed that it didn't attract additional customers, at best it only fragmented the existing customer-base.

Source: I work in that industry for a long time now

GRiMe2D• 1 year ago

Every time I see messages and posts like this, I hope that big companies were being dissatisfied with the product factory scaling issue and device sell effectiveness.

I hope that small companies would launch device like this with 500-1000 devices being created and sold in a year just fulfill the niche and doesn't go bankrupt

kayodelycaon2• 1 year ago

I don’t think you could manufacture a small run like that without the price being extremely high.

Say you charge $1,000 per device. That means you need to build an entire company, pay staff, and prototype then manufacture a custom hardware device with customized software with less than a million dollars. Costs add up real fast.

neogodless3• 1 year ago

It was ginormous, but I loved my Dell Venue Pro!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dell_Venue_Pro

cubefox2• 1 year ago

4.1-inch (diagonal) widescreen

oreilles• 1 year ago

Even if was a small % of the Apple lineup, the iPhone mini was one the best selling smartphones all brands considered. I for one switched to iPhone in 2020 specifically because there wasn't a single current-gen small form-factor Android phone anymore. I have a few friend that also made the switch with the 12 / 13 Mini for that reason.

The real reason the iPhone mini failed is not related to screen size, it's because its segment was canibalized by the cheaper alternative, the SE. The 2020 and 2022 sold like hot breads, wherehas their screen was almost an inch smaller than the iPhone mini. This is the proof that there a significant market for people who don't care about size and would gladly take the smallest option at a $100 discount from the regular one.

mock-possum• 1 year ago

This is the case for me precisely - I’ve been dismayed at the “phablet” sizing trend, and leapt at the opportunity to keep my iPhone reasonably-sized - I’m on my second SE now and I’m kind of dreading what will happen when I need to eventually replace it.

I just want something small that will fit comfortably in my pocket, and I can use with one hand.

coldpie3• 1 year ago

Even if was a small % of the Apple lineup, the iPhone mini was one the best selling smartphones all brands considered

Correct. To back this up a little bit with numbers, the iPhone 13 Mini all by itself sold about the half of the rate of the entire Google Pixel lineup. I bet lots of phone manufacturers would love to have half the sales of Google's premier Android phone. I also switched from Android to iPhone solely because of the 13 Mini form factor (I prefer Android, but I prefer a human-hand-sized phone even more).

Source:

Google shipped about 10 million Pixel phones in a year https://9to5google.com/2024/02/22/pixel-2023/

iPhone Mini accounted for about 3% of iPhone sales https://9to5mac.com/2022/04/21/cirp-iphone-13-best-selling-l...

iPhones sell about 200 million units per year https://www.demandsage.com/iphone-user-statistics/

200 million * 0.03 = 6 million iPhone Minis per year

al_borland6• 1 year ago

I think the "mini" name hurt it too. People thought it would be small, when the screen was in fact bigger than the screen on the 6/7/8 iPhones. It was a similar form factor without the forehead and chin.

The mini could have been simply, iPhone. The marketing would have been that they managed to add an extra .7" of screen, while reducing the overall size and weight. That's a great pitch. Who doesn't want a bigger screen in something that more easily fits in their pocket? Instead they called in a "mini", people thought it would be tiny and hard to use, so they didn't buy it.

The iPhone 12 mini screen was only .1" smaller than the screen on the iPhone 8 Plus... the giant option from just a few years earlier.

The mini was a marketing and brand strategy failure, plain and simple. It wasn't a small phone.

dontlaugh8• 1 year ago

Exactly. I had already bought the SE by the time the mini came out. I still bought a Mini anyway, it's that good. But I imagine most people didn't.

cubefox2• 1 year ago

Exactly. Stated and revealed preferences are sometimes very different. Interestingly, preferences can also change slowly over time. For example, the Dell Streak in 2010 had a 5 inch screen size, which was considered ridiculously large at the time (people called it a "phablet"), and it didn't catch on initially. But years later, average phones did actually reach and even exceed that size. Nowadays the Dell seems relatively small.

DrewADesign• 1 year ago

Smartphone with QWERTY keyboard, the product failed commercially

Well, there was BlackBerry. Multiple phone vendors assuming they could refresh a previously world-dominating form factor with contemporary smartphone guts only seems unreasonable in hindsight.

mtmail• 1 year ago

When asking people if they'd buy a yellow Sony Walkman people said yes. Shortly after given the choice to take one home the same people picked black. https://medium.com/@diogomarta/the-yellow-walkman-paradox-th...

FirmwareBurner• 1 year ago

A bunny walks into a bakery. There he asks the baker if he has any carrot cake.

The bakers says: ‘No, I don’t sell carrot cake.’

So the bunny leaves, but returns the next day. He once again asks if the baker has any carrot cake.

Once more the baker answers: ‘No, I don’t sell carrot cake.’

Once the bunny left, the baker started making a carrot cake thinking the bunny would return the next day for the cake. And so the bunny did, and he asks: ‘Do you have carrot cake?’

To which the bakers answers: ‘Yes, today I DO sell carrot cake.’

So the Bunny says: ‘YUCK, isn't it disgusting, why do people sell these things?!’

MilanTodorovic• 1 year ago

It seems that Medium article is ripping off this one https://www.alexandercowan.com/yellow-walkman-data-art-of-cu...

ikari_pl3• 1 year ago

Well, that's a lesson on asking the right question. You like the new yellow one, but you like the black one even more. Nobody asked about black.

einpoklum2• 1 year ago

the numbers showed that it didn't attract additional customers, at best it only fragmented the existing customer-base.

So, it did sell, but at the expense of larger phones. Which means we are not offered this because it's a bit more profitable for the smartphone makers to only offer larger phones. Extremely annoying.

rickdeckard9• 1 year ago

It cost more but didn't create more sales. It's like creating a car with an additional wheelbase.

What should be much more annoying is this: There is roughly half of the entire Smartphone ecosystem systematically isolated from free market-forces by a single brand, with the other half isolated by an OS. So even if a company would come along with a compelling compact phone, if it cannot instantly replace everything Apple offers, that company can only address HALF of its potential market, and ONLY if it's based on Android then.

amluto2• 1 year ago

when it comes to the point-of-sale, most people still choose the normal-size device with better screen/battery/camera.

My theory is that much of this effect is an error, or at least a far-less-than-ideal effort, on the part of the designers. Of course it’s hard to sell a low-end “mini” device with a worse camera, worse battery life, etc. But that’s not actually what I, or many people I discuss this with, want. I would happily buy a premium device that is short and narrow, and possibly even thicker as a tradeoff. There’s plenty of unexplored room in the design space here. For example: start with an iPhone Pro or whatever the Android equivalent du jour is. Keep the camera unchanged. Shrink the display but keep the same quality (at least equal pixel density). Now puff out the back so that the camera lenses are flat or even slightly recessed. Use the resulting added volume to compensate for the decrease in volume due to decreasing the other dimensions. Market the think as a Whatever Phone Pro Compact, and advertise clearly that the battery life is every bit as good as the non-Compact model version. Show off cool pictures models sticking this thing in their cool jeans pockets without them sticking out. Charge the same price as the ordinary Pro model.

As far as I know, no one has tried anything like this in recent memory. The iPhone 12 and 13 Mini were always marketed as the cheaper versions, and the cute little old SE model was very much a low-end version. Last I checked, there was no 5G Android device with similar dimensions from any manufacturer.

nextos• 1 year ago

Unihertz sells some decent Android phones that have 3 and 5 inch displays, respectively: https://www.unihertz.com

AFAIK, these are similar to the iPhone SE? The SE form factor was great in terms of size and thickness. Easy to use with one hand. I miss that.

Topfi2• 1 year ago

The iPhone 12 and 13 Mini were always marketed as the cheaper versions [...]

No, they were not. They were literally a scaled down version of their respective regular sized counterparts, the 13 Mini had the same cameras, SOC, memory, screen quality and storage options as the regular 13 [0], yet its sales success (or lack thereof [1]) was enough to instantly cure me of any previously held notions that there is a sufficiently large group of buyers for these devices out there.

It isn't because the specs are inferior, the cameras are changed, the display has a lower pixel density (the Mini actually had slightly higher ppi) or anything else. There simply is no sufficient market, the 13 Mini was the worst selling phone in that generation by a frankly impressive margin. 38% for iPhone 13 vs 3% for iPhone 13 mini, despite them being as close to just being scaled down and otherwise identical as one can make a phone speaks a very clear language that any manufacturer wanting to succeed has hear loud and clear. Most certainly why Asus has seized with their more compact smartphones. The amount of people I know that praised Asus for making a more compact flagship with a very large battery [2] was not in any way proportional to their sales. In this case, the battery life was actually superior to many larger competitors. Same for my Xperia 5 V, the compact phone I bought and used at the time, cause I walk my talk and have been following phone releases to a sufficient degree that I can assure everyone, there have been and are flagship speced, compact phones with good battery life, that no one ever buys. I'd love more options in the market, heck, I use both the Xperia 5 and an iPhone 15 Pro Max in a Clicks case, either for different situations, so am on both sides as a consumer. Simply, the lack of any actual market demand beyond online comments makes that impossible, we need to be honest here.

[0] https://www.apple.com/by/iphone-13/specs/

[1] https://www.macrumors.com/2022/04/21/iphone-13-mini-unpopula...

[2] https://www.asus.com/mobile-handhelds/phones/zenfone/zenfone...

raydev3• 1 year ago

much of this effect is an error, or at least a far-less-than-ideal effort

No, the vast majority of people use their phones as video viewers, increasingly so after the rise of TikTok. I have family members in their 30s who don't have laptops or TVs, all media is consumed through their phone, and for most kids/teens across the world it is their primary video consumption device.

The average person is trying to maximize screen size relative to portability. And the market is everyone on earth. That's it.

leptons• 1 year ago

Maybe you haven't heard, but Samsung has been making folding phones that fold up to be very small. The Galazy Flip 7 is pretty much what you describe as far as easily being able to fit in a pants pocket, has plenty of battery life, high-res screen, and it even flips out to have a large screen. No, folding phones are not a gimmick, been using a fold 4 for a few years and it's been amazing.

https://www.samsung.com/us/smartphones/galaxy-z-flip7/buy/ga...

littlestymaar• 1 year ago

The hard reality is that there is no PAYING market for such a device, because when it comes to the point-of-sale, most people still choose the normal-size device with better screen/battery/camera.

This kind of over-generalization is always annoying me deeply.

Of course there IS a market for such a product, because at the very least I exist (as well as a good fraction of the 320 other people from HN who upvoted this submission so far).

The problem is that this market is tiny, and even a smaller share of this market is willing to make massive concessions on other aspects of the phone to have a smaller phone, so you end up with a much harder design space (because size is a big engineering constraint) for a minority market, and the endeavor is often not profitable enough for that reason.

It doesn't mean there's no market, it just means addressing this particular market is a tough business, these two statements aren't equivalent.

MetaWhirledPeas2• 1 year ago

The hard reality is that there is no PAYING market for such a device

Show me the tiny Android flagship from the past 5 years that didn't sell well. (You can't, because there wasn't one.)

neogodless3• 1 year ago

https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-zenfone-10-review-3334...

According to this article

The ASUS Zenfone 10 is a compact flagship Android phone from ASUS. Sporting a little 5.9-inch display

Though you have to argue it's not tiny. (Don't think it sold all that well, though, at least not mainstream.)

rickdeckard9• 1 year ago

Show me the tiny Android flagship from the past 5 years that didn't sell well. (You can't, because there wasn't one.)

Yeah, because in the 5 years before that, the much MUCH more diverse Smartphone industry tried to make it work for several YEARS and failed.

Of all companies, Sony had the longest stamina, releasing 5 generations of 'compact' flagship devices.

If there would have been a sufficiently sized market for that, they would have continued and grown. In reality their business decreased every year.

Today the Smartphone is dominantly a media-consumption device, the only viable answer to "tiny Android flagship" is now a foldable like the Galaxy Flip.

jeroenhd• 1 year ago

Unihertz is currently serving both the slim size and the QWERTY niche, with a QWERTY Kickstarter running right now. Their hardware actually seems quite appreciated, but they don't seem to care much for software updates.

Currently, foldable smartphones (the flip phone ones) seem to be the fashionable alternative to small phones, but they're even more expensive than the huge ones.

no_wizard• 1 year ago

This here in is one of the major differences between Apple[0] and the rest. I imagine they had similar data at various points, and chose to deliberately ignore it. I can’t say for sure but I imagine they thought through the actual end user and experience and realized the tradeoff is more than worth it

[0]: when Steve Jobs still ran the company at least

ryandrake• 1 year ago

The "mini" versions of phones (even the ones marketed as premium) always seem to be nerfed in other ways, like battery life, camera quality, or performance, which could explain why they inevitably don't sell. Nobody really offers a balls-out premium small form factor phone that is better than or equal to the flagship big-phone.

XorNot2• 1 year ago

But that's just physics. With a larger area, you can be thinner while still having more of all those things - dominated by battery volume dictating most of them.

fckgw• 1 year ago

That was the iPhone Mini! Same internal specs as the regular iPhone, smaller package, roughly same battery life. And it's gone because no one wanted it.

throw10920• 1 year ago

I've seen this pattern before, with laptops ("I want a laptop with" specific spec+feature combo not in the market) and cars ("I just want an electric car with physical controls and no subscription services or extra electronics") immediately coming to mind.

Which is a shame, because I can sympathize with most of these requests.

I want something like Kick-starter which operates the same way but isn't meant for funding the creator to get the upfront capital investment - just avoiding existing companies getting burned out of the "let's listen to a niche slice of our customers instead of appealing to the masses" mindset. Companies put up a weird product proposal and see if enough people will commit to buying it to at least break even.

Then, if there's enough of a commitment, those people get something they actually want. If there's not enough, then there's a specific reason that you can point to to explain why.

This is almost equivalent to the normal market model (people buy things they want, and niche products don't get made much), except with a more explicit feedback step, to help people realize that if they don't actually put their money where their mouth is, then things won't get made.

There's probably a better way to do this, but I'm not sure how. Ultimately I just want my non-electronic electric car.

fkyoureadthedoc4• 1 year ago

Soon to be added to that list, the army of Redditors that insist the Slate truck is the ideal vehicle for them.

singpolyma33• 1 year ago

I don't see how this would be different from Kickstarter. This is what Kickstarter is for.

sehansen• 1 year ago

Depending on how stringently you define "no extra electronics" you can get there with a 1st generation Hyundai Ioniq. The only things I need to use the touch screen for in daily life is navigation and choosing media.

Be aware that you'd need to live in a place with very good public charging infrastructure due to the ~220 km range. The infrastructure is there here in Denmark where I live and daily-drive a 2017 Ioniq.

All-in-all the Ioniq sold well enough that Hyundai release a facelift in 2020. And the most recent facelifts of the successor-Ioniqs (5 and 6) have moved back to a more button-based interface (AFAIK).

robertoandred2• 1 year ago

Who decides what a normal-sized device is?

toast0• 1 year ago

Screen manufacturers, based on orders from the big buyers. They set up their machines to build panels and cut them to size, minimizing wasted area. If you want one of the sizes built in volume, great; if not, it's very difficult.

herval2• 1 year ago

spot on.

I'm starting to see the same trend with laptops without a keyboard now. There's an entire generation of 8-16 yos who never used a keyboard and type fast on ipad screens. In a decade, it's a real possibility that keyboardless laptops become the standard...

cx42net2• 1 year ago

Wow that's awful, borderline dystopia :D

Isn't called a tablet? ;)

ikari_pl3• 1 year ago

But whenever someone answered the call and built a Smartphone with QWERTY keyboard, the product failed commercially, simply because also to people claiming they want such a phone, at the point of sale they were less attractive than their slimmer, lighter, all-screen counterparts.

I bought Motorola Droid 4 when it came out. I was so desperate to have a new phone with physical QWERTY, that I bought it blindly, even though it wasn't available in Europe, even though I have never seen it, even though I knew it *didn't support mobile networks* in Europe for a few months, to be fixed by an update. I had to use a coworker who was going on vacation to Florida.

When it arrived, the first thing I saw was that the black screen during boot shines bright blueish, horribly bad contrast. Then when image appeared, I've learned that it has two subpixels per image pixel, for efficiency. This made single color areas show the pixels very visibly.

Then I took a photo. The quality reminded me of a Sony Ericsson Walkman phone I had 6 years back, except the colors were much worse. Everything was blueish. It had a physical (touch) "search" button below the screen, but companies like Google didn't seem to understand why it would be useful to search for anything, so most of their apps didn't react to it. Especially Gmail.

But hey, I could touch-type any long message, and I could use SSH client conveniently (it even had a physical CTRL button).

Other than the keyboard (pretty solid too), it was one of the worst phones I ever had. So yeah, based on that model the market decided that "nobody wants keyboard phones", and the Droid 5 never came out.

Because it's easy to blame the most standing out feature.

rickdeckard9• 1 year ago

Because it's easy to blame the most standing out feature.

This is an odd conclusion considering that the Droid 4 was already the FOURTH iteration of a QWERTY device from that ONE brand on that ONE carrier, each iteration selling less than the one before as each faced more competition.

If you're interested, the actual reason for the end of the Droid QWERTY series was that the entire "Droid" brand was a Verizon-exclusive product-line with a big focus in sales and big budget in Marketing, just to compete with the iPhone (which was not available on Verizon until 2011).

For a vendor to win a slot in that lineup meant that Verizon Sales and Marketing put all weight behind selling that device, no matter what device it is. This made the Droid 1 and 2 a huge success, not because of the product but because of the sales channel.

But in year 3 (2011), the iPhone launched on Verizon, which put a huge dent in both sales-focus and budget of Verizon's "Droid" product-line.

Later that year, Droid 3 launched but was selling significantly less than its predecessors.

In that year, Verizon instead sold 6.5m iPhones (up from ZERO iPhones the year before).

So Motorola had to cut their losses on the already ongoing development of the Droid 4, the device was redesigned for a much lower total sales-expectation and then launched in 2012.

But the sales turned out even lower than expected: By Q4 2012 Verizon sold 14m Smartphones, with 10m (!) of them being iPhones.

The most successful Motorola device of that year was the Droid RAZR MAXX HD, a non-QWERTY flagship.

It was clear: That QWERTY keyboard didn't drive sales.

garyfirestorm• 1 year ago

It’s ironic that the author is comparing to iPhone mini which was killed just because of low demand.

ungreased0675• 1 year ago

They still sold millions of them.

raydev3• 1 year ago

There is a paying market, it's just overwhelmingly erased by the market for the larger phones, so companies stop bothering.

rickdeckard9• 1 year ago

That's not correct.

The paying market for larger phones also contains the potential market for smaller phones.

There is no ADDITIONAL market in selling smaller phones, and not enough free market to make users switch brand for a smaller phone. So there is nothing to gain.

Crucially, even if 10% of the iPhone users want a smaller phone, they won't buy a smaller phone unless it's compatible to the iOS ecosystem. So roughly half of the market can only be effectively converted by Apple and for Apple it turned out to be not profitable enough to convert them.

singpolyma33• 1 year ago

The problem is that the bar for "commercial failure" is too low. I not only would pay more for a qwerty device but I have multiple times and I've delayed purchases of a device when no qwerty option was available. And I know there are thousands of people like me.

But there aren't hundreds of millions of people like me. And the bar for "success" is selling that many units so it gets considered a "failure"

geodel2• 1 year ago

Well if company can't profit selling such device in small quantity it is commercial failure. There is not much qualification to it beyond that.

The bar appears too low to prospective customer because they lose nothing if they try this product but ultimately decide to not buy but for business it is clear loss.

This is like those mythical users who'd buy Macs once its fully hackable and officially support linux. Apple thinks it is just better to not serve those buyers.

throwawaymaths2• 1 year ago

how does Fairphone exist?

rickdeckard9• 1 year ago

The main features of the Fairphone are ethical and sustainable production, repairability and longevity.

Of all the people who prioritize those features when buying a new phone, only ~100k users end up buying a fairphone every YEAR.

A company like Samsung needs to produce roughly 10x this volume BEFORE launch just to fill their sellout channels, so their financial risk for a global ramp-up is much higher.

lastofthemojito• 1 year ago

Well there's certainly not no paying market. But the market is apparently too small to be viable.

Apple apparently sold a couple million iPhone 13 minis. Ford reliably sold more than 100,000 Focus cars in the US annually before deciding to discontinue it. But Apple and Ford decided they were better served redirecting that engineering effort towards more profitable projects.

It just frustrating when these gaps occur and there's no smaller player to fill them. A couple million small smartphones or a couple hundred thousand compact cars sounds like enough to sustain a business, but it isn't enough for the big players to care, and small players can't affordably create a competitive offering.

osigurdson• 1 year ago

I think when people start using phones less, they will again want them to be small. That is my experience at least. That being said, I expect to have to go back to a full size phone before that happens.

wmf3• 1 year ago

People will never use phones less.

andruby• 1 year ago

I really like the size of my iPhone mini, and I'm disappointed Apple has discontinued them. Apparently the 12 mini represented only 6% of iPhone sales, and the 13 mini only 3%.

I haven't upgraded yet.

Why does everyone (most of you too?) like bigger screens? The mini screen is big enough for HN, reddit, banking, photos, etc.

Reason0772• 1 year ago

Eric is now using the Lightphone 3, and apparently he loves it: https://www.thelightphone.com/lightiii

Although, it's not exactly what he wished for in 2022 since it doesn't run standard Android and obviously doesn't have industrial design like the iPhone mini.

cx42net2• 1 year ago

The Lightphone seems great on paper, but price is far from light unfortunately, which is a bummer as I would have been interested if it were at 300$ selling price.

woodpanel• 1 year ago

QWERTY paradox

Similar to the „ARTE effect“: When French TV audiences where polled, frequently around 10% responded, that they were watching Arte (an artsy government funded intelligentsia TV channel) on a daily basis.

yet the ratings rarely surpass 2%

JansjoFromIkea• 1 year ago

I think there could be a market for a small reliable Android phone. The main issue is that it'd take years to build up a model's reputation and it'd have to be reasonably low price.

As it stands the kind of people who want a smaller phone almost by definition need to be a bit savvier than the market in general to know such a thing still exists and along with that will have greater skepticism towards Android phones having any kind of post market support.

It'd basically have to come from Samsung to hit the all the price/quality/trust requirements. Feel like they've already got a lot of the pieces there with their corporate targeted XCover range just shrink them down a bit.

subhro• 1 year ago

But whenever someone answered the call and built a Smartphone with QWERTY keyboard, the product failed commercially

Blackberries? Granted, they failed but for a completely different reason.

jajuuka• 1 year ago

I think this is true for a lot of different features that get a lot of play on social media as "I wish my device had X feature." And it's not like QWERTY or small screen phones didn't try. They had models that were best of the best, cheapest of the cheap, mid range, offered a range of options and choices. And the audience just isn't there.

0xEF• 1 year ago

Remember the Palm (palm.com, not to be confused with Palm PDAs of a much earlier era) for Verizon networks? That answered all my requests at the time; about the size of an iPhone 5S but running Android 8, but with the caveat that I had to have a "big" smartphone so the Palm could piggyback off the line, even though I could just leave the "big" smartphone at home.

I have no idea why that was the case and can't even speculate since I don't know enough about how the networks worked, but I would love to hear an explanation. I was pretty annoyed by the fact that I still needed to own what I considered a phablet, which was sitting collecting dust on my bedside table at home just so I could have the type of phone I really wanted. Seemed like a punishment-by-design for trying to step off the typical customer rails.

My tastes have changed slightly these days, and I'm okay with a 5.X" screen or whatever, but now I want it to be eInk or something similar and focus more on text/sms as I've gotten pretty minimalism with my phone use.

hulitu• 1 year ago

But whenever someone answered the call and built a Smartphone with QWERTY keyboard, the product failed commercially, simply because also to people claiming they want such a phone, at the point of sale they were less attractive than their slimmer, lighter, all-screen counterparts.

No. They were a) rare and b) much more expensive. AFAIK only Blackberry had a phone with QWERTY keyboard.

Buttons are much more expensive than a touchscreen (see cars for examples).

m463• 1 year ago

I bought a mini because a phone broke and was not immediately fixable, and I just needed something to get me going.

And... I love it and use it all the time. Into the pocket it goes, great for going out.

I would buy an iphone mini 16/17/18 no questions asked.

When it comes to the marketing side of things, I think back to a story where one of the soft drink companies tried to find the best soft drink taste. They found out that they couldn't optimize for the one true taste because... different people had different favorites.

dengolius• 1 year ago

looks like iPhone SE 2025 should cover user needs for $800

CafeRacer• 1 year ago

I wish there was a phone, preferably with buttons (bb q10 like), that can run WhatsApp, banking app and Apple Pay (or whatever android version is). Also it should be running these stupid government apps. And music please... preferably with 3.5mm jack so I can connect my nice headphones. This phone can have mediocre camera.

eskibars• 1 year ago

Man this hits home. I'm a reasonably sized human, but there are almost no devices on the market outside of iPhones where I can reach from bottom right to upper left with 1 hand without shifting the phone around in my hand. I hate it.

I'd be willing to take less battery life to get something like this, but nearly everything that's anywhere close either has no NFC (which means mobile payments are out the door) or doesn't have 5G or just has such an awful camera/processor as to be basically unusable for many every-day tasks.

spankibalt• 1 year ago

"But whenever someone answered the call and built a Smartphone with QWERTY keyboard, the product failed commercially, simply because also to people claiming they want such a phone, at the point of sale they were less attractive than their slimmer, lighter, all-screen counterparts."

The slab form factor is excellent industry design; modern efforts to integrate a hardware-keyboard, i. e. in a non-detachable way, are quite frankly daft. It buys the worst of both worlds: added complexity and error-proneness, more (dead) weight, awkward handling, harder maintainability/repairability, etc.

The form factor that was represented by Psion-machines such as the 3- or 5-series was great at the time, but is now obsolete, as evidenced by Planet Computers' recreations. Integrated sliders (e. g. F(x)tec) are only marginally better.

Technically, the solution of course is very elegant and simple:

1. Slab-form factor UMPC/smartphone 2. Corresponding detachable (as "attachable folder"), roughly Psion 5-sized keyboard a similar 3. Small "click-in" keyboard dock à la Pinephone keyboard or a 4. Detachable slider

But that is indeed just one variable in the whole equation; there's a whole set of features I consider essential for a smartphone- or UMPC-like device that one doesn't find anymore.

qwertytyyuu• 1 year ago

Take the compromise the the Motorola razr and never open it. At least for now, that;s what I’m doing

moron4hire• 1 year ago

I want an Android phone that doesn't break. My iPhone is a beast, but I hate using it, I'm too used to the Android interface (especially the keyboard, I can't believe how bad the keyboard is on iOS). But every Android phone I've ever had gets dinged up very easily and eventually falls apart.

I bought an iPhone 15 and a Pixel 7 at the same time when I started a new job 2 years ago. I keep my work stuff on the iPhone. For the first year, I kept them in the same pocket and had them both everywhere with me. The Pixel within a few weeks was starting to look beat up. The iPhone still looks practically brand new.

Just last night, I got home, pulled my Pixel out of my pocket, and found a crack near the corner of the screen. Now the screen is glitching out on the bottom 15% of the screen. I didn't drop it, I didn't bump into anything. Regular pocket pressure while sitting in my car must have bent it and it buckled.

My wife has had similar experiences with Samsung phones.

If it weren't for the lack of good browsers on iOS, I'd put up with the shitty keyboard.

Mouvelie• 1 year ago

Switched from my iPhone 13 mini to a Qin F21 Pro. I will buy phones like this as long as I can ! It was a pain to setup but it works well for what I want (having a smartphone in Canada)

https://www.duoqin.com/

omgtehlion• 1 year ago

These days I want an iPhone Mini-sized iPhone phone... :(

mpascale002• 1 year ago

Number one factor for me when buying a phone is how long is it going to last. I mean durability, camera quality, os updates. Will I still want to use/be using it in 5 years?

I cannot justify $700 as much as I _really want a smaller phone_. But _maybe if it was built to last_ I would be the customer and I would tell all my friends.

Currently use a Pixel 7a because it was cheap and OK. I was debating the iPhone 12 mini but it was already a little old, and I prefer Android.

I suspect, if others are like me, that those who want small phones also just want something that works and is a little minimal - not necessarily all the power best camera etc. To be clear, I _don't_ want one of those minimalist dumbphones, I want _a smartphone_ that's small Do y'all feel the same?

Propose a $500 small phone that's OK on specs but LASTS.

JamesSwift2• 1 year ago

Yes. The iphone se was basically the exact thing I wanted (and previously the moto G series). It doesnt seem like apple wants to continue to offer the product line.

RankingMember2• 1 year ago

The 16e is the successor to the SE in case you want to take a look at that.

butz• 1 year ago

Silly question: how hard would it be to find some manufacturer in China, that could manufacture several hundreds or thousands of low-mid range devices, of iPhone SE size or similar? Would be great to have ability to run PostmarketOS.

_seiryuu_• 1 year ago

This resonates strongly. The Pixel 7 is my current holdout due to its 'acceptable' size, even though it's not exactly "mini". It's a shame to see manufacturers like Asus move away from compact form factors, as I'd have been an immediate buyer for a smaller ZenFone.

The market's push towards larger devices is making e-ink 'dumb' phones increasingly appealing for me.

otikik• 1 year ago

I want an iPhone Mini-sized iPhone. They don't do them any more

neuroelectron• 1 year ago

The idea that nobody wants a small phone seems odd to me when Asus Zen Fone 10 is extremely rare and the iPhone 13 mini only exists in retail as refurbs.

herpdyderp• 1 year ago

I was hoping that the foldable phone market would fix this, but instead of making normal sized (huge) phones that fold into half the size, they made tablets that fold into normal sized (huge) phones!

ikari_pl3• 1 year ago

It's something. (I may be biased, just switched to my 2nd foldable, even more foldable than the previous one)

arccy• 1 year ago

you can get a Samsung Galaxy Flip series phone

Eric_WVGG• 1 year ago

Heh. I want an iPhone Mini-sized iPhone (2025)!

BeFlatXIII• 1 year ago

I want an iPhone Mini-sized iPhone with the Pro model cameras.

ceedan• 1 year ago

I have a 13 mini and a case with a built-in 6800mAh battery. Without the case, this phone is low battery half way through the day. When watching videos, I do feel like 5.4" screen is a little bit small. Overall happy though. I wanted a smaller phone.

ccorcos• 1 year ago

I want an iPhone Mini-sized iPhone! You can’t buy them anymore and now I have a big phone!

A weird correlation I’ve observed is that many tech savvy designer folks have iPhone mini’s. I think partly because they do their main work on a computer and don’t lean on their phones as much.

kristopolous• 1 year ago

Japan still makes reasonably sized phones - plenty of them. Recommend shopping for one if you're going over sometime soon.

raydev3• 1 year ago

What I find fascinating is that Apple's and [Android manufacturers]'s previous attempts at smaller phones aren't even worth maintaining after they assess sales.

In my mind, these companies are all so massive they can afford a little fragmentation for the obviously small market, with no meaningful impact to their sales numbers or profits.

On the iPhone minis, there's very obviously a market for them, but the market is so small compared to the market for "all iPhones" that it practically vanishes in comparison, which leads Apple to not bother. Is it really that expensive to maintain a more niche line for each generation?

Skunkleton2• 1 year ago

Is it really that expensive to maintain a more niche line for each generation?

Think of just the work that goes into having an assembly line customized for a specific form factor. To keep price, quality, and profit in line with their other phones I think the answer here is clearly yes.

kevincox• 1 year ago

Especially if having that line means only 1% more customers and 19% customers that just buy the small model instead of the other model. And unless you are launching the Mini Pro Max Ultra X you are losing money on that 9% of customers that would have bought the higher margin phone but instead bought the mini version which is only available at the more base model.

(Numbers made up to illustrate the point)

redbell• 1 year ago

This was a hot post in 2022: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31411191

melesian• 1 year ago

I want a Linux phone based on open source hardware. I gave up an iPhone for Android then switched to Pixels. My current Pixel 7 will be my last Google phone. I want out of the surveillance economy. I want AI assistance as badly I want a hole in the head.

I carry an 8 inch tablet (fits in a jacket pocket) and do most of my mobile web, email, podcast listening etc. on that, using my phone as a hotspot. Can't buy a new 8 inch tablet with a fingerprint reader. Got a couple of 2nd hand ones on eBay and will soon look at putting LineageOS on them (they have out of date versions of Android).

the_gipsy• 1 year ago

Tha sad truth is that small screens don't work anymore, because apps are all tailored for bigger screens. I noticed this when I had an iPhone mini. It just did not work right. The UIs that are supposed to be surrounding the main part just cover too much. The range is from mildly annoying to completely blocked.

Really sad, because the device was physically very practical, and I don't really need such a big screen, just smart UIs like we used to have, that don't cram the screen full of every feature of every PM that ever worked at the company.

xorcist• 1 year ago

Make your 5.4" screen phone with:

- a 3.5mm jack

- fingerprint sensor on the back

and it's an immediate buy for me, (almost, but not really) regardless of price!

The Pixel 4 had a 5.6" screen and it feels like the local maxima of mobile phone design. Ran GrapheneOS perfectly too.

lloda• 1 year ago

I think a squat format like 4:5 would be much more practical than 9:16 or whatever most phones are. It's unfortunate that's the format that's come to dominate, especially when you consider the rise of vertical video.

nottorp• 1 year ago

Umm I want an iPhone Mini-sized iPhone...

lion__93332• 1 year ago

There are many such phone sellers in China—you can find them in the second-hand market. But I feel like all the internal parts have been replaced. It may look like an iPhone on the outside, but the components inside are probably no longer original.

kubatyszko• 1 year ago

HTC magic was just about that size ! (and it ran whooping Android up to 1.6 I believe). It was a 2nd publicly available android phone, right after the HTC with Dream.

SirMaster• 1 year ago

Ugh, yes I HATE how big phones have gotten...

I like the idea of the folding flip style phones (Galaxy Flip) though and hope Apple makes one of those!

fhcbix• 1 year ago

I gave up on finding a <6" with my requirements (audio jack, microSD, USB-C display) and can use my 6.1" Xperia 5 III reasonably well with one hand using a MomoStick. Other smartphone ring attachments exist but this one acts as a stand as well.

BrtByte5• 1 year ago

As a fellow small phone enjoyer, this speaks to my soul. The big phone trend feels like it’s being driven by media consumption and spec sheet flexing rather than actual usability. One-handed operation? Pocketability? Those used to matter!

rbits• 1 year ago

My god... are we really at the point where even in the "nice to have specifications" people don't put a headphone jack anymore? Did the phone companies actually succeed at spreading apathy towards the headphone jack?

jeffbax• 1 year ago

I would have bought the 13 mini except at the time the 13 Pro's 3x camera, 120hz and better battery was notable.

Now I kind of dread what will be available when it's time to finally upgrade this year. Am sure they could make a new mini that didn't seem as compromised, but now they think the size is non-viable.

Bring back when small was not a synonym for cheaper.

I want an iPhone Mini-sized Android phone (2022)

Related Stories