UI elements with a hand-drawn, sketchy look

by nickca • 2 years ago

766 116 2 years ago

ayhanfuat2• 2 years ago

rough.js is great. It is also powering excalidraw.

j45• 2 years ago

It's also important to appreciate and congratulate someone who started and finished something they wanted to complete and release.

ayhanfuat2• 2 years ago

True. I am not sure how that relates to my comment though. Did I seem unappreciative somehow?

throwaway290• 2 years ago

It was finished and congratulated 6 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17146451

The same author also made rough.js.

So it looks like the commenter you replied to has more context than you.

majikandy2• 2 years ago

Ah that makes sense now. I nearly said it was like excalidraw, which is really nice for architecture diagrams more than for ui/ux I find.

elric• 2 years ago

I never really used Excalidraw until I discovered the Obsidian plugin. Now I have tons of markdown notes with embedded Excalidraw doodles. It's good stuff.

airstrike• 2 years ago

Previously https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17146451 (650 points, 121 comments)

dang• 2 years ago

Thanks! Macroexpanded:

Show HN: Wired-elements – UI web components with a hand drawn, sketchy look - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17146451 - May 2018 (120 comments)

I feel like there were other threads, either about this or something very similar. If anyone finds them, we can add to the list.

seattle_spring• 2 years ago

Really nice! Not sure what I'd ever use this for, but definitely putting it in my proverbial back pocket.

greenavocado• 2 years ago

Bring back skeuomorphism. I hate flat and material design. Those two excessively eliminate subconscious visual cues from the natural world.

bmitc2• 2 years ago

Skeuomorphism goes in the other extreme direction though. One doesn't need flat design or skeuomorphism. There's a nice balance of UI elements that sit in the middle. I think Windows 7 was probably a good example of just straight up boring buttons and controls.

skydhash• 2 years ago

OS X Maverics and iOS 6 were also nice examples of skeuomophism done right.

wkat4242• 2 years ago

I hate it too. I understand what people had against it though because Apple (led by Scott Forstall) took it wayyyy too far at one point. The notepad, the game center, it was a joke. It became its own objective.

I think the current bland flatness is a kneejerk reaction to that (kicked off by Jony Ive who was probably angered by Forstall's design).

seanmcdirmid• 2 years ago

This brings back memories of Swing/JFC, back when it was thought to be a good thing to have pluggable look and feels.

TeaVMFan• 2 years ago

NapkinLAF provided a hand-drawn look for Swing:

https://napkinlaf.sourceforge.net/#Snapshots

SoftTalker• 2 years ago

Well we used to use "sketchy" looking mockups so that users would understand that this wasn't a finished, working interface. I guess that's out the window now.

pech0rin• 2 years ago

thats the entire point of this. to generate mockup software

samuria• 2 years ago

Wouldn't it be easier to just decide on a UI library to be used for the project and use that instead?

Dalewyn2• 2 years ago

I find the deliberate choice of a left-handed font for this example intriguing.

hammock2• 2 years ago

Was it deliberate?

Dalewyn2• 2 years ago

From the source code:

<link rel="preload" href="fonts/font.woff2" as="font">
@font-face { font-family: 'Gloria Hallelujah'; ... src: local('Gloria Hallelujah'), local('GloriaHallelujah'), url(fonts/font.woff2) format('woff2'); ... }
body { ... font-family: 'Gloria Hallelujah', sans-serif; ... }

So yes, the choice of font looks to be quite deliberate.

bdcravens• 2 years ago

Reminds me of Balsamiq, which was the rage about 10 years ago.

TheBlight• 2 years ago

Wasn't there an X window manager that you could skin in the same way?

jzemeocala• 2 years ago

Compiz?

ceejayoz• 2 years ago

I still find Balsamiq super useful.

fuzztester• 2 years ago

Yes, was about to say the same, then saw your comment.

IIRC, Peldi, Balsamiq founder, had blogged about it at the time. I like it too. Also reminds me vaguely of the Comic Sans font, which was the rage even earlier.

majikandy2• 2 years ago

Perhaps more like Tekton, which was like a classier crisper comic sans

neeleshs• 2 years ago

It's still my go-to tool for mockups. I find it to be the most powerful tool to convey product behavior to stakeholders

kissgyorgy2• 2 years ago

I use it almost every day.

the_gipsy2• 2 years ago

Completely broken on mobile.

HPsquared• 2 years ago

Works for me on Chrome Android

throwaway_ab• 2 years ago

Works for me on iPhone.

the_gipsy2• 2 years ago

Clicking on the dropdown entries also selects the radio button below it.

nonesuchluck• 2 years ago

Maybe someone here can help me remember. I had a PalmOS app that I loved, back in the day, and I can't remember what it was called. It was a shareware clock app, with hand-drawn time that animated from one numeral to the next. I used to use it as an alarm clock, in my Sony Clie dock, by my bed. Would love to see it again.

r1chard007• 2 years ago

ChatGPT thinks it was called 'TimeDraw' :)

xyzzy_plugh4• 2 years ago

Every time I go to reach for rough.js I get a bit uncomfortable when I read this:

Some of the core algorithms were adapted from handy processing lib.

handy is LGPLv3, but rough.js is MIT. This line makes me think parts of rough.js are actually LGPLv3, as those parts are derivative works.

In practice this is unlikely to negatively impact me but I'm not super pleased by the uncertainty.

jacobolus• 2 years ago

Algorithms can't be copyrighted (though code can be), so this really depends on what level of copying is implied by the word "adapted".

xyzzy_plugh4• 2 years ago

"I read this code and then reimplemented it from scratch in a different language" does not release you from licensing obligations. If that were the case then brb while I go reimplement unreal engine in rust.

justinclift2• 2 years ago

Firefox's "Enhanced Tracking Protection" seems to break their React demo.

Turning that off though and things seem to load ok, even with UBlock Origin and Privacy Badger running.

jan_Sate• 2 years ago

Strange. It works here with "Enhanced Tracking Protection". Maybe I'm using a different version of Firefox?

justinclift2• 2 years ago

I'm using FF 126.0.1 on Debian Linux x86_64, if that helps. :)

hgs3• 2 years ago

This looks nice and oddly nostalgic. One bit of feedback: each time I toggled the checkbox I expected the checkmark to look slightly different, as if it were being redrawn by hand each time. Adding some "noise" might be a neat feature for a version 2.0.

duegreg• 2 years ago

Adding a noise would result differenet look on every render, I am not sure that's good

SpaceNoodled• 2 years ago

It already does that, though.

bryanrasmussen• 2 years ago

I personally like the look of this kind of thing enough I would want to use it for a real product, or maybe for the beta version of the product and then switch it up when official release.

Probably too much extra work though.

shagie• 2 years ago

There's good reason to use it for a beta build (or an alpha) - it changes the type of feedback you get.

While my google-fu is failing me as I write this, there was a blog post I read long ago about a making things look not done (I want to say it was in the context of an AWT look and feel). Related: xkcd-style Plots https://mathematica.stackexchange.com/questions/11350/xkcd-s... ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4597977 ) and https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/why_xkcd_style_graph...

If the product looks done then the feedback you will get assumes that it is done.

I made the mistake of using a nice looking header (it looked better than the existing ones that were used which were stretched gifs and I had a CSS gradient) while working on the innards of some JavaScript. While I was trying to get feedback on the "is this workflow the right sequence of pages? Are these the UI elements that need to be on the page for this functionality? For that matter, am I missing some functionality?" .... and I got feedback about the color blue and if it should go from dark to light or light to dark in the gradient.

...

And with some digging I remembered the look and feel - https://napkinlaf.sourceforge.net

Which has the links to the blog post:

Don't make the Demo look Done - https://headrush.typepad.com/creating_passionate_users/2006/...

diegof79• 2 years ago

Check out Bill Buxton's work, he wrote a lot about this: https://www.billbuxton.com/

mortenjorck• 2 years ago

Early in my design career, I ran a user test of a lo-fi prototype with some members of a customer success team, the visual presentation intended to convey the mutability of what we were presenting. I got a comment that “the sketch look was really nice” and since then have never relied on that as a signifier of where a concept was in the design process.

Lorin• 2 years ago

Doesn't seem super accessible tho', tab focus leaves me wanting.

cl3misch• 2 years ago

I love the sketchy UI elements. I hate the sketchy text font. Do normal sans-serif fonts and sketchy UI not fit together stylistically?

lloeki• 2 years ago

I liked the font myself, but as with every such "handwriting" font it sits in an uncanny valley of "sketchy but regular": a given glyph, however sketchy in isolation, always looks exactly the same!

zogomoox• 2 years ago

The cursive font should at least lean to the right.

PhasmaFelis2• 2 years ago

I think that might be how left-handed people write if they're taught how to write properly left-handed. (I was not.)

tyingq• 2 years ago

A lot (not all) of the things in their showcase are using a normal font, so you can have a look: https://wiredjs.com/showcase

hodanli• 2 years ago

Last commit is three years ago

amsterdorn• 2 years ago

HN is like Reddit, people will repost old things that aren't theirs until the end of time.

kissgyorgy2• 2 years ago

My favorite tool for this is Balsamiq Wireframes: https://balsamiq.com/wireframes/

Having to write code loses the point of quick and dirty.

McDyver• 2 years ago

I really like https://wireframesketcher.com/

No cloud dependencies, and a lifetime license for $99. These are becoming rarer and rarer

mthoms• 2 years ago

Sadly, the "lifetime license" only includes one year of updates.

riffraff2• 2 years ago

I think something like this can be useful to show your customers that something is a functional prototype and not a finished product.

This works if you can switch out The design as in the old "napkin look&feel" for Swing.[0]

Sadly I think "change design by switching out a theme" has long died as an idea in the web space.

[0] https://napkinlaf.sourceforge.net/

krsdcbl• 2 years ago

I'm asking myself if this might be a good application for a WebGL shader?

The issue with "theming to look sketched" is the same as with "hand drawn looking components" - it has to be integrated for your specific DOM or App, totally defying the purpose of "making someone understand this is a quick sketch". Because by now, it's far beyond being a sketch.

pjmlp2• 2 years ago

Exactly, I have been in too many meetings when they get shown a click dummy in the technology stack, we get the reaction, a couple of days more and it is done.

juliushuijnk• 2 years ago

For wireframing on your phone, with hand drawn style: https://www.tinyux.app

It has a non-standard ux, since I didn't want drag-drop on a small touch screen.

xixixao• 2 years ago

Wow! Awesome!

grodriguez100• 2 years ago

Looks great! No iOS version?

pjmlp2• 2 years ago

Great, thanks for sharing.

Angostura• 2 years ago

Love Balsamiq. The style of wireframe is so useful for conveying to people that this is just a sketch and to avoid the ‘I’m not sure about the font’ questions

jnsie• 2 years ago

Absolutely love Balsamiq. So quick and easy. IIRC there used to be a post-processing tool by a 3rd party that would turn Balsamiq Mockups into code - wonder if it's still kicking around.

Edit: it was called napkee. looks like it was open sourced but hasn't been touched in almost a decade

aagha• 2 years ago

I used Balsamiq for years and loved it.

It finally became too bloated and now we just use draw.io.

Terr_• 2 years ago

I wish more designers used these, precisely because it blocks them from prematurely adding too much detail.

When they start doing things like exact-padding and font-size and whatnot, it either (A) front-loads implementation into the development process when the UX hasn't really been tested or at least (B) making developers spend time guessing how precisely the beta needs to look like the design.

chr15m• 2 years ago

You might also like DoodleCSS! https://chr15m.github.io/DoodleCSS/

vanviegen2• 2 years ago

I've drawn my inspiration from this project while creating WireText, a VSCode plugin for quickly creating mockups with a hand-drawn style,

https://gitlab.com/saxion.nl/42/wiretext-code/-/blob/main/RE...

bobwaycott• 2 years ago

Wow, this is really cool and clever. Well done!

vanviegen2• 2 years ago

Thanks! :-D

bkazez• 2 years ago

Pencil and paper also has a hand-drawn, sketchy look, and you don’t have to write code!

lproven• 2 years ago

Reminds me of the Paper theme for MacOS 8.x-9.x.

There's a screenshot in the carousel here:

https://www.macintoshrepository.org/2549-appearance-manager-...

Implemented using Appearance Manager, not via Kaleidoscope or one of the other add-ons.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appearance_Manager

tunnuz• 2 years ago

I use Excalidraw for sketching with a similar outcome.

pg5• 2 years ago

Glad to have found this! I've been looking for something like this because I'm working on a fun, quick side project and don't want to use something boring like bootstrap for it.

brimstedt• 2 years ago

Nice work

It would be neat if there was an option to make input and textarea use the script font as well and an image component that made a sketch of the image provided.

And maybe charts, and...

beryilma• 2 years ago

This is UI theory gone wrong. The idea that users will give feedback more freely when something looks unfinished is at best a non-validated theory.

This used to work with actual paper prototypes. But going the extra length to make UI designs look hand-drawn, when the users know full well they are computer generated is just busy work.

Showing the users what the actual design might look like works better and it actually captures important design choices such as shapes, colors, proximity, etc. that users care about.

I have been to many UX tests. Regardless of sketchy design look or not, the user will either have no problem providing feedback or they won't give useful feedback. It mostly depends on the person, not on what you show them.

Oarch• 2 years ago

Thank you for this. I couldn't agree more about this being busy work. Which there seems to be a lot of in the PM world.

Personally I've found basic shapes and text boxes, or felt markers, infinitely more helpful at getting direct feedback from users.

shalmanese• 2 years ago

I've found the opposite. When users feel like a lot of work has gone into something, they'll restrict their critiques to minor elements that seem easy to change because they are worried about causing you too much rework. Putting it in a sketch format makes it seem like it was easy to generate and gives them much more freedom to make more radical suggestions.

The key though is you also have to present them at least 2 - 3 very radically different versions of the same thing.

Each tool has a different purpose at different parts of the design stage. When I'm in blue sky ideation phase, I don't want users to be thinking about colors and proximity (although I do, even at that stage, care deeply about information hierarchy and hate sketch tools that make information heirarchy hard to design for). It's when I'm more in the narrowing down stage that I'll move to more higher fidelity tools.

samatman• 2 years ago

You're imputing a huge amount of intention found nowhere in the link.

A set of common UI elements with a hand-drawn, sketchy look. These can be used for wireframes, mockups, or just the fun hand-drawn look.

You made up all the stuff about users and feedback. It isn't on the page and it isn't in the README.

SteveDR• 2 years ago

Who is claiming that this style improves user feedback? From the OP, “these can be used for wireframes, mockups, or just the fun hand-drawn look.”

I like the style for its aesthetics alone

wouldbecouldbe• 2 years ago

It's great for showing work to clients, not users.

I've always gotten so much complaints when wireframes look too much as design, they will start making all kinds of comments about how it looks instead of focusing on structure.

I used balsamiq wireframes tool a lot for that reason.

DontchaKnowit• 2 years ago

Counterpoint, it looks good.

ghnws• 2 years ago

Where are you reading this?

swiftcoder• 2 years ago

Nah, the magic here is that if you hand this to your CEO, he's not going to go "looks great, ship it!" and demand your hacked-up demo be in production next week.

Izkata• 2 years ago

Sketch-style UI isn't supposed to make people comment more freely, it's supposed to help stop them from focusing on the polish and instead look at the functionality. The last thing you want is "X and Y aren't aligned" or "Would color Z be better?" when the questions are still more like "Does this work?" and "Are these numbers correct?"

danielovichdk• 2 years ago

I would like to have something like this for "text on stripped paper". Anyone know if there is a library for that ?

elevatedastalt2• 2 years ago

I like it for the aesthetics. It's cute. I don't care whether it's more useful for getting feedback or whatever.

literallycancer• 2 years ago

If you just want the visuals and don't need the JS parts, you can use PaperCSS.

elevatedastalt2• 2 years ago

Thanks for the tip, just checked it out. I prefer the aesthetics of the current one better. Paper CSS looks like a kid drew those elements. This one has the hand-drawn look of a more professional hand.

flemhans• 2 years ago

The progress bars should really be filled out like if a person was doing it, rather than re-rendering the whole contents

WillAdams• 2 years ago

There was a charming theme for Mac OS which looked something along these lines (and there was another which collapsed elements down to the bare minimum of space necessary which was a big help, and wish had been preserved, or re-created on some other platform --- in particular, being able to arrange a line of window-shaded folders and to double-click on any one to make it visible was a god-send on small displays) --- it would be nice if theming were simpler to do/implement.

endofreach• 2 years ago

Finally. I have occasionally been looking for something similar & it was not important enough to do it myself. Now i have a good basis to start from. Thank you!

sandGorgon• 2 years ago

can i use this in htmx ?

aryeshalev• 2 years ago

https://jdittrich.github.io/quickMockup/ this is another GEM from the past, super easy and you can load/save as HTML file. i like the simple design for mockup

lpellis2• 2 years ago

I'm using this for the AI annotations at https://pagewatch.ai/ Its strange how much different it makes the whole page feel from regular boxes, much more of a tangible/informal feeling. Felt perfect to go with the type of feedback LLM's give.

archon810• 2 years ago

I tried signing up and scanning apkmirror.com but it immediately came up with a 403. Perhaps your user agent is blocked, you should probably use a custom user agent.

lpellis2• 2 years ago

It is cloudflare that blocked us, we scrape using a regular chrome instance (with the latest user-agent), but cloudflare are sometimes very aggressive in their blocking. I'm busy adding a proxy option to handle these cases automatically, and some way to whitelist our scraper.

PhasmaFelis2• 2 years ago

I want to sneak this onto the test environments for my company's webapp next April Fool's.

siyejed358• 2 years ago

What are the usecases? who will use this in production?

sabaimran• 2 years ago

My absolute favorite for hand-drawn-esque elements is Excalidraw (https://excalidraw.com/). Immediately became enamored by the UX and the ability to get done what I was looking for - architecture diagrams and low fidelity mock ups. It stores everything locally on your browser, which makes it easy to work offline as well.

niels_bom• 2 years ago

tldraw.com is also excellent

UI elements with a hand-drawn, sketchy look

Related Stories