TimeGuessr

by stefanpie • 1 year ago

328 64 1 year ago

mmahemoff• 1 year ago

This is fun! I didn't immediately notice the time slider and thought it was just GeoGuessr with historical pictures, but the time element adds a whole new dimension.

xeonmc• 1 year ago

Should probably be renamed to “Spacetime Guesser”

fcatalan3• 1 year ago

I do the timeguessr daily every day almost as a ritual, it's fun, satisfying and educative.

It's also very interesting to watch people try after you've done it: how they catch on stuff you missed, their strategies to find and date things, or how they infuriatingly ignore whatever was the giveaway to you.

justbeingbored• 1 year ago

Just played 5 rounds. I wanted to see my score as ranked against others, but u didn't do that. That's like me saying here is 800 points for your post. There is no context for the score.

gblargg• 1 year ago

Does it at least tell you how close you were for each one? (feedback so you can improve)

fcatalan3• 1 year ago

Yes there's a feedback page for each round explaining the pic and showing the location, also a breakdown page after every 5 round match.

fcatalan3• 1 year ago

Yes, score rankings are missing. There's a leaderboard for the daily, but only shows accounts you have friended.

For reference, I tend to hover around 44k for the daily. 48k is a lucky/easy day, 40k some disaster happened. Under 40 is very rare. I like to think that would be above average, but without rankings I don't know :)

xboxnolifes• 1 year ago

The context is how close you were to the correct answer, not to your peers.

jen729w• 1 year ago

I got ~28,000.

cellis• 1 year ago

indeed, this is screaming for a leaderboard and eventual Geoguesser. Sadly I do believe the reasoning models can one shot this? Maybe would take away all the fun

me_bx• 1 year ago

The game 'Whentaken' [1] follows the exact same concept.

Just mentioning in case people are interested in alternatives / slightly different UX.

[1] https://whentaken.com/

JimDabell• 1 year ago

Also whichyr: https://whichyr.com

Discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43715024

motoxpro• 1 year ago

whichyr is awesome. I feel terrible about myself that I am systematically below average.

eastbound• 1 year ago

I find the UX of Whichyr much better, but it doesn’t have the geographical component. But you see your final ranking on a gaussian curve and it’s fun!

https://whichyr.com/

And here are other games in that style of 5-minutes cultural guesses:

https://framed.wtf/

https://gaps.wtf/

https://sutom.nocle.fr/

https://globle.org/?

https://worldlegame.io/?

https://flagle.gg/

https://phrazle.gg/

https://numberle.org/

Not working currently but guess a historical moment: https://www.historle.com/?#

Guess a wikipedia page: https://pedantle.certitudes.org

tasuki2• 1 year ago

I'm at 200 tries for the "Guess a wikipedia page" thing, completely exhausted, and not getting anywhere. Very frustrating, yet I can't bring myself to abandon it...

mkl• 1 year ago

Took me 115. I guessed lots of general filler words to work out the structure of some sentences, and guessed lots of general subject words to find a few hits. The grey words that it fills in when they're related can be a bit misleading. I didn't get a single sentence complete before guessing the article.

tesuto• 1 year ago

Out of curiosity, I wonder why the game chose Apple Maps. I would have expected OpenStreetMap. Interesting choice.

mocmoc• 1 year ago

love it

stephenhandley• 1 year ago

Super fun! Would be cool to be able to challenge someone after going through a round. Also maybe clear CTA after round on way to sign up to save your score.

ukprogrammer• 1 year ago

Great idea! What's the tech stack?

alexkearns• 1 year ago

Not quite the same but we created a timeline ordering game for US presidents: https://www.tiki-toki.com/timeline/entry/1842261/US-Presiden...

You can also use our app to create timeline ordering games on subjects of your own choosing.

nokita• 1 year ago

Irretrievably hung my phone requiring a hard reset.

Using Chrome on vanilla Android on Samsung.

mh-2• 1 year ago

Seems like an issue with the OS? Surely a web page in a userland app like Chrome shouldn't be able to do that..

brahma-dev• 1 year ago

This is how it renders for me. https://imgur.com/a/kJmNMUR

pastage• 1 year ago

Some photos are off by at least 100 meters and it is surprising how easy a photo can be off a year so easily. I believe it happens because the easy timestamp is at the time of development, means you can easily be two years off. Also surprising how easy it is to get exact date and time of day on some of the photos.

phgn• 1 year ago

Why do I have to pick both a location AND year? Why not focus this game on the year only?

cheschire• 1 year ago

You’ll probably enjoy this game then

https://whichyr.com/

tasuki2• 1 year ago

All the pictures I got were from the US. That makes me happy with my 3955 (Top 31%) score, though I'd have appreciated more geographical variety.

kaishiro• 1 year ago

That's like asking why a weather app needs both a date and city - the temperature on July 4th matters, but it's completely different in New York vs. Cairo. Same with this - the year sets the global context, but the location defines the local experience.

cosmodev• 1 year ago

I just clicked to take a quick look, and suddenly found myself playing it's a simple but surprisingly enjoyable game

rossant• 1 year ago

Nice. Got 30,527.

junon• 1 year ago

30,592/50,000 is higher than I thought I'd get. This is fun!

One of the photos was someone holding a phone with Timeguessr on it. Still managed to get the date wrong - it was taken in 2024.

eej71• 1 year ago

I got lucky - I got the Hagia Sophia twice.

captn3m0• 1 year ago

I couldn’t figure out how the time picker worked (and that there was a time picker) till the third round when I realised I was being penalized. Got 34k still.

trebligdivad• 1 year ago

I'm glad you figured it out...I don't see a map to put a pin into.

Humphrey• 1 year ago

This is fun! While some are obvious, and some you need to "cheat" by Googling - it's really fun looking at a part of the world you wouldn't normally browse a map of.

whamlastxmas• 1 year ago

Very fun!

golfer• 1 year ago

Cute game! Needs an easy way to maximize the picture so you can see it full screen (on laptop).

Jordan-117• 1 year ago

Love their selection of photos more than the competition -- more likely to contain giveaways like a famous location from an unusual angle or a subtle date, so it feels more like detective work than guesswork. Just wish it reset at midnight local.

king_phil• 1 year ago

Did not work too well for me on mobile. One time it did not scroll but went back, one time controls were missing

mh-2• 1 year ago

I didn't try the web based one, but the mobile app works great.

setsewerd• 1 year ago

Yeah I had issues with the mobile web version as well. Worked for 4 rounds but then the time selector stopped moving when I tried to select, and the map stopped loading detail when zooming in (and wouldn't let me place a pin). Started over and the same thing happened in the 3rd round.

Still a great little game though

sundarurfriend3• 1 year ago

Scrolling with the mouse on the image (no Ctrl or anything, just scroll) zooms into the section of the image you're on, for anyone else trying "Open image in new tab" or other ways to zoom in.

I'm a big GeoGuessr fan, and had heard of TimeGuessr occasionally in those circles. I'd assumed it would be mostly pictures from the USA and so wasn't massively interested, and from trying it out now, I wasn't too far off: most of the images were from the US and Western Europe, and every single picture so far has been from a rich country. There are obvious reasons for that, and it's not a bad thing in some absolute terms, but it makes it kinda boring for me - the big appeal of GeoGuessr for me is that you routinely get dropped off in a country that you don't often think of, and momentarily get to see and imagine life through their eyes.

Maybe over time, TimeGuessr will also accumulate images from more varied places - or maybe one of the alternatives mentioned in this thread (whentaken and whichyr) already do better in that regard?

InitialLastName• 1 year ago

I don't know, my pictures definitely biased towards "cameras are accessible in these places" but I had modern Nepal and Bangladesh, as well as 1930's Finland.

NooneAtAll3• 1 year ago

Scrolling with the mouse

once again nobody cares about laptop users :/

baw-bag2• 1 year ago

It's not that. They changed recently to 100% zoom. It used to be much more fine. Zoom in a little, Zoom out a little. For the past week, it's been max zoom in either direction. Kinda annoying.

sundarurfriend3• 1 year ago

I myself am on a laptop actually :D but with a bluetooth mouse connected.

Does yours not have two-finger drag on the touchpad be equivalent to a scroll? That also seems to work on this website, although of course it's a bit more inconvenient than using an actual mouse.

baw-bag2• 1 year ago

Its not true!

I have been playing TimeGuessr for 11 months, I do it before bed.

I have been all over, I personally really struggle between Vietnam and Thailand and got even that wrong with Cambodia. I am simply ignorant but it's not just rich countries.

sundarurfriend3• 1 year ago

That's good to know. I just tried another game, and got: Belgium, Denmark, USA, UK, USA. Not exactly the variety I'd hoped for! But I'll try it out occasionally and see if I ever get lucky with an interesting round.

fnky• 1 year ago

First game, the places I got was:

- Argentina - Belarus – I guessed Poland, because the picture dipicted Polish soliders right after WII - Poland - France - Finland

pmxi• 1 year ago

This is really cool.

However, my first photo said "Times Square, NY" in the corner, with a copyright for 1908 which gave it all away.

SamBam• 1 year ago

Fun! I was surprised how often I was 1 year off and in the right city for things that I was just guessing about.

On small error I found: there's a photo that's outside Piazza Navona in Rome in the 30s, which it lists as being 700 meters away at Piazza Venezia. I know I'm correct -- I lived a street away from there.

hdjrudni• 1 year ago

Maybe it moved 700m since the 30s? =)

Arech• 1 year ago

I absolutely love 3 dimensional nature of the game and how carefully many images are chosen to allow for a precise spacetime localization with a bit of a research. Super enjoyable experience in startling contrast with geogessr, which I don't even want to open. Thanks a ton!

osigurdson• 1 year ago

It should be called "locationguessr" imo since that is what you are guessing.

diego_moita• 1 year ago

There's an year slider on the bottom right. You're supposed to guess the year too.

gandalfgreybeer• 1 year ago

Just in case you enjoyed this, and based on you using “locationguessr”, I’d recommend looking up Geoguessr :)

nisse72• 1 year ago

I guessed 2021 for one photo which turned out to be Joe Biden's inauguration fireworks. It tells me I was 20 years off?

elwell• 1 year ago

That was really fun; I was pleasantly surprised with 43,165. Trusting intuition worked well.

wdutch• 1 year ago

Oh nicely done! There was me thinking I'd done well with 38,332 / 50,000. It'd be nice if the site itself showed how well you did relative to others but I can't see anything like that, maybe I'm missing it.

INTPenis• 1 year ago

It wasn't really clear to me that you had to select the year as well as location. Because the year was already written in a red box, so I never tried to change it.

oofnik• 1 year ago

41,481. Nice. That was a fun time waster.

breakyerself• 1 year ago

There was a chalkboard menu in the picture with the date on it, but it said I was 50 years off. Meta data isn't always reliable.

TimeGuessr

Related Stories