HN user

asifjamil

327 karma

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/asif; my proof: https://keybase.io/asif/sigs/QAS1vYFe-bEgOYKGJmn2eKIJKzACro-qfEhSzfcUJHs ]

Posts16
Comments49
View on HN

Hate to rain on this person's parade, but his findings are mostly meaningless. You cannot simply infer neurological activity from a single electrode. Besides the need for a proper ground/reference, you also need electrodes placed in the correct anatomical locations to derive any meaningful insights into attention networks.

Just came here to see if anyone else noticed it and it's funny that it's the only comment ATM :D

I think someone should come up with a browser extension to disable custom scroll jacking.

A wonderful piece, almost read like a novel.

At the end, I couldn't help but try to derive some overall take-away. The best I could come up with was to cherish your friendships and always try to keep in touch. One concern I would have is whether or not today's internet-based culture could hinder this?

The view of brain oscillations driving (or even partially modulating) neural activity is further supported by research involving stimulating the brain using Alternating Currents [1] I'm currently doing my PhD on this topic, and it seems so far that targeting AC (with an entrained frequency) to various motor-related neural networks can actually enhance the motor skill and even motor learning.

Brain oscillations are quite phenomenal, and the causal role of these synchronisations still require further research.

[1] http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2012.05.021

iPhone 6 12 years ago

I would venture the trend is because there are consumers (maybe a significant percentage) who, when comparing different options, simply make a choice based on "bigger is better".

I completely agree here. Good information here, and lots of potential when you think about it could be applied with other machine learning algorithms that are currently being used with "real-time fMRI". Indeed, I don't think we're far off from reducing the gap between neuronal activity and behavioral patterns, but we need to keep in mind that the brain is incredibly complex, highly variable between individuals, and most of the time, presents quite a poor signal-to-noise ratio with the technology currently available.

I'm actually a PhD student studying this exact technology in Germany. I can say without a doubt that this type of stimulation has proven potential in enhancing cognitive functions (if proper protocol and safety aspects are respected). This is a really exciting field which I think will really explode in the next few years once the montage and paradigms are optimized (which is exactly what I'm working on!)

Reusing modes can actually be quite good if you're concerned about space efficiency.

For example, having excessive controls in the car stereo might be a bad idea since drivers could potentially be distracted. So having the big volume knob to fine tune the bass level for example would be much more preferable to having six individual knobs that the user would have to look through and find.

Black Swan Farming 14 years ago

Is it possible that this is simply just the effect of a Bell Curve (i.e, the normal (Gaussian) distribution of a field)?

Okay, I wouldn't really call his article a "critique". He's just presenting his thoughts on an app that hasn't even been released, and his points seem valid based on the initial feature list of the app.