Learning C and ASM, what's the way to go?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=899867

by hilarious • 17 years ago

15 43 17 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I'd like to learn C and ASM (on x86-64) The documentation I have varies between old books from the 70's, and tutorials from websites with the grammar of 16 year olds, from miserable sites. I'm not sure how best to attack this problem. I'd like to learn how to program in C and in ASM, I've read basic things, and understand their usefulness, but I don't know what to read! I have a number of people tell me that they've read near to nothing, but I don't think I have this sort of mindset.

Kind elders of Y, give me guidance.

Thanks

markerdmann• 17 years ago

The classic C book is The C Programming Language by Kernighan and Ritchie (http://www.amazon.com/Programming-Language-2nd-Brian-Kernigh...).

cperciva• 17 years ago

If you want to learn x86-64 assembly language, I recommend a historical approach: Start by learning 8086 assembly language, then learn 80386 (i.e., 32-bit x86) assembly language, then learn MMX/SSE assembly language; and only once you've mastered all of those, start on x86-64.

The x86 instruction set is kludges built upon kludges, and you're never going to understand it fully if you try to jump in at the end without seeing how it developed.

hilarious10• 17 years ago

Do you have any documentation you'd recommend for this, I'm not sure what to read/study.

Thanks for your help cperciva.

jacquesm8• 17 years ago

Agreed, the biggest switch is probably from 286 to 386.

486 and Pentium didn't really do much instruction set wise (sure there were changes), then the next big change is the 64 bit systems.

edit: What do you mean kludges ? It's the most orthogonal instruction set known to man!

tptacek3• 17 years ago

Forget everything about the code, data, and stack segments.

rikthevik• 17 years ago

I learned asm starting with MIPS and then had the luxury of working at a place that was designing MIPS hardware. It was nice to be able to get into the assembler when some kernel modification wasn't working very well.

I have only good things to say about MIPS as a great place to learn ASM. The thing is, the better you understand how processors and pipelines work, the better you'll understand why instruction sets are the way they are.

If you want to learn a very bad assembler (for programmers) but one that's very to understand (for microcontroller designers), there's always 68HC11. How do two 8-bit registers and two 16-bit registers make you feel? (Probably like going to/from memory quite a bit :)

jacquesm8• 17 years ago

For assembly I can recommend Lance Leventhals books.

80386 Programming Guide

And the intel reference manuals.

masterchief• 17 years ago

The K&R book is the classic C reference. I'd also recommend the K.N. King book ... C programming: a modern approach.

parse_tree• 17 years ago

I highly, highly recommend the book "Programming from the Ground Up". It is freely available, and full of small asm sample programs to try out yourself.

Here's a link:

http://savannah.nongnu.org/projects/pgubook/

hilarious10• 17 years ago

Oh, I've been missing out, haven't seen this one, thanks!

springrider• 17 years ago

highly, highly recommand +1, I'm reading it, it's better than any other program books I've ever read. It tells you what, how, why, and it tells in an interesting way.

bbg• 17 years ago

I second the choice of K&R for learning C -- where better to learn C than from the authors themselves.

For assembly I've had a good experience with K. Irvine's Assembly Language for Intel-Based Computers, available on Amazon here:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0132304686?ie=UTF8&tag=...

tptacek3• 17 years ago

My favorite C book is "C Interfaces and Implementations" (CII) by Hanson. It's an excellent bridge from Perl/Python to C; in particular, it gives you resizeable arrays and hash tables, which are the two things you will miss most from high level languages. My advice is, learn to code C for a couple months using CII, then tackle assembly. When you see how C programs are decomposed into functions, and how arguments are passed to functions, you'll understand much more about how assembly should work as well.

I've taught a couple people basic x86 assembly using a programmable assembler we wrote in Ruby. A really great place to start with assembly is to be able to define a array of instructions and be able to "jump in" to them and see what they do.

hilarious10• 17 years ago

CII looks like it'll be an amazing book! Shame it's not available online, I wish it were, I wouldn't sleep tonight!

I'll probably make a purchase when I get my paycheck though, thanks!

CaptainMorgan2• 17 years ago

I'd like to second the K&R book.

In addition, I've found if you're taking an engineering approach, "Applications Programming in ANSI C" by Johnsonbaugh & Kalin was to me a very valuable learning tool.

Do not go without the "C: A Reference Manual" by Harbison & Steele, which to me has been the most valuable reference book to have on my person if I couldn't get or chose not to fancy a good Internet reference.

For Assembly, my coverage has been limited to MIPS, which was in comparison to Intel's version, a lot easier to understand and thus learn from. Check out "Computer Architecture and Design" by Patterson & Hennesy. While of course mostly a book on architecture, it's rooted in learning MIPS to understand architecture and comes with the SPIM simulator software(which I assume could be had online). I also own the book by Bryant & O'Hallaron, "Computer Systems: A Programmer's Perspective" and personally I found that learning MIPS first brought home Intel's ASM a little softer.

hilarious10• 17 years ago

Lovely note, a question, however -- I er, got "C: A Reference Manual" for my birthday, (which got me into this whole business), but it looks very advanced, shall I read it as my first book anyway? and ask questions where I falter? Or, should I go for something more basic?

Thanks again!

CaptainMorgan2• 17 years ago

My advice is absolutely not. References are just that - to be looked up for something you've lost or just don't have the capacity for in your own memory; they're not made to be read back to back, or at least I could not do that. Question to ask might be, would you read the English dictionary back to back? Kudos to those that can or would. :)

You talked about learning C and ASM, and K&R and the other books (excluding C:ARM and CS:APP) are fine learning tools. So to answer your question, do not read it first, but have it by your side when something isn't clear... think of it like a dictionary to look up functions that were not well addressed (or even talked about at all) in the learning books.

sangaya• 17 years ago

For C, absolutely K&R.

For Asm, I concur with cperciva that the best way to go is to start at 8086 and work your way towards more modern assembly.

For 8086 I highly recommend "The 80x86 IBM PC and Compatible Computers (Volumes I & II): Assembly Language, Design, and Interfacing". I learned from this book and thought it was very helpful.

For more modern stuff I really enjoyed "Computer Systems: A Programmer's Perspective". It will be most beneficial after reading through K&R and being familiar with ASM. It focuses a lot on programming techniques, tips, and tricks so that compiled C/C++ code is turned into efficient assembly.

Finally, if you'd like to build a whole system end to end, the Motorola 68HC11 microcontroller is a fun little piece of hardware to play around with. "MC68HC11: An Introduction to Software and Hardware Interfacing" is a good book for this purpose.

Best wishes on your journey into the low-level programming world!

PS. I'm biased. I have read and own all of the above mentioned books. Thanks for getting me to brush off the dust again ;)

gte910h2• 17 years ago

The best way to learn assembly is to do it on a risc chip, then work up to a CISC chip.

So pic, mips, etc first, then X86

device• 17 years ago

It might help to take a step back and ask why first. Are you working on a project that requires both?

If you just want mercenary ability with C and ASM, you'll have no problem finding the resources - just a matter of finding the best book. I'm sure you'll get plenty of recommendations here.

It sounds you want to enrich your general programming knowledge though. In that case I'd recommend learning computer architecture concepts - once you have that down, learning C and ASM will be a pretty transparent process. In fact, I'd recommend it even if you just need it to hack on something specific. I took an architecture course at uni that used this book, and it was pretty decent: http://www.amazon.com/Computer-Organization-Design-Fourth-Ar...

hilarious10• 17 years ago

I'll take a look at that, thankyou :)

pan693• 17 years ago

OK. Depending on your programming background you're facing a steep learning curve. That's why I recommend a bottom up approach for you.

First read "Code" by Charles Petzold. This book will get you "in the mood" and in the right frame of mind: http://www.amazon.com/Code-Language-Computer-Hardware-Softwa...

Then I suggest you pick up a good book on Assembler. This might be a good choice: http://www.amazon.com/Professional-Assembly-Language-Program...

Start writing some drivers for Linux. Like a memdrive or something. Do it all in Assembler! Oh, you need to read other books on how to do this...

Then pick up the K&R book on C. Now write your memdrive driver in C.

That should get you started. I think it will take you at least up to two years before you're passed the learning curve and to be comfortable with this level of programming.

Oh, you need to be willing to do it for the love of it because it's highly unlikely that you will make a living using these sort of technologies (nowadays).

Good luck!

PS: I miss the old days...

hilarious10• 17 years ago

Sounds good, thanks bro, interesting approach ;D

jacquesm8• 17 years ago

I wouldn't start off by writing a driver in assembler, probably better to write it in C first, then use the -S flag to get the intermediate and study that until you drop.

hilarious10• 17 years ago

Writing device drivers in C, and then using the -S flag ... have you seen the output gcc -S on Linux (Ubuntu) returns for a trivial hello world program? ;)

pan693• 17 years ago

I can assure you that if you want to learn C AND Assembler and you start with C, you will never ever get to the Assembler bit. A memdrive isn't that difficult and if you never solve a 'real' problem, you never learn anything because you don't have to push yourself. Just my 2 cents...

korch• 17 years ago

When I was 18 and decided to first try programming, I picked assembly to start with since I had read somewhere that all other languages could themselves be written in terms of assembly. The book I learned assembly from was Randy Hyde's online version of his textbook Art of Assembly. I used the DOS version, because I didn't know what Unix even was at that time; but here's the newest Linux version: http://homepage.mac.com/randyhyde/webster.cs.ucr.edu/www.art...

Like other commentors, K&R would be my best recommendation for the second book. You might as well start off on the right path towards enlightenment.

hilarious10• 17 years ago

Not trying to rub you the wrong way but I'm not interested in learning HLA, which is what AoA covers, purely LLA.

Thanks!

drhowarddrfine• 17 years ago

You are exactly right even though Randy won't like you (or me) saying that.

gte910h2• 17 years ago

Do all the projects in K&R, then buy a pic board and pic compiler and get on it.

zimbu668• 17 years ago

I worked through Assembly Language for the PC(http://www.amazon.com/Assembly-Language-Brady-programming-li...) in highschool. You start with the basics and at then end you have a working hex editor, for DOS anyway. In terms of programming knowledge gained it was more than any college class I took, heck more than most college semesters.

pfedor• 17 years ago

I recently decided I wanted to learn assembly language. So far I haven't started but I spent an hour or two perusing books on assembly language on Amazon, reading product descriptions and users' reviews, and I decided to start from this one: http://www.amazon.com/Professional-Assembly-Language-Program...

The reasons I chose it are

(1) It's introductory, i.e., a good first book for a complete noob. (2) It's very Linux-centric. Most good books on assembly language assume you use Windows or even DOS it seems. (3) One of the reviews says, "you will get a good workout using the gdb debugger." Sounds like fun.

Learning C and ASM, what's the way to go?

Related Stories