Ask HN: Which game has an impressive AI?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7732491

by intull • 12 years ago

11 11 12 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

Games like SimCity, FIFA, Galactic Civilizations, etc boast an outstanding AI play. Which game(s) do you think has an impressive AI ?

Any of them Open Source?

redxblood• 12 years ago

Well, i think it´s important to note that games must not only have AI that can play well, but rather programmers must make them "fail" sometimes, in order to seem more human, or make them "hesitate".

I guess what you´re trying to find out is which games have AI which correctly portray how a "great player" would act in such a game, and not which games have overkill bots that 360 scope you all the time.

Not sure this can count, but the AI of Pandemic, the game where you are a virus and have to destroy humanity is very well done. It is an accurate portray of a real world scenario under such circumstances.

Ps. Sorry for typos. English is second language over here.

intull• 12 years ago

Haven't played the game myself, but I have heard about it! Have to give it a go one day.

mcintyre1994• 12 years ago

The mobile port Plague Inc is fantastic as well, great time killer.

yen223• 12 years ago

Black and White. The Creature AI was a work of art, considering the age of the game.

rrss1122• 12 years ago

I loved Black & White, loved Black & White 2 more. The creature AI was fantastic, you could teach it right from wrong (from your own perspective) and it would do what you taught it. Wish there would be another entry in the series.

georgeecollins• 12 years ago

Left for Dead has robust AI. It is made so that a scenario can be played over and over again with different layouts of computer players. The design of the zombies requires teamwork. I believe the key to the fun of that game is in the single player is the AI. Without good AI it would be no fun at all.

It is not open source but I did see a presentation about its pathing on the internet.

VPrime• 12 years ago

The Unreal Tournament series has some of the best AI. They react and behave very human. In UT 2003 (or 2004 can't remember) they even respond to voice commands.

There was even a programmed Unreal Tournament bot that passed the turing test.

kindiana• 12 years ago

Check out Three Body Problem, not really AI but... awesome

MojoJolo• 12 years ago

I only play two games most of the time: DotA2 and NBA2K14. I can say they have pretty impressive AI. For both games, I rarely beat the AI with the hardest difficulty. Unfortunately, the lack of intelligence of the team mates for both games gives me a disadvantage that also adds to its difficulty.

psyklic• 12 years ago

F.E.A.R. The AI engineer is an MIT graduate and employed AI planning research into the game rather than a typical state machine approach.

See http://web.media.mit.edu/~jorkin/gdc2006_orkin_jeff_fear.pdf

yzzxy• 12 years ago

I've never played myself, but AI War: Fleet Command is said to have an extremely interesting AI opponent that is the focus of the game. The AI is actually meant to be an AI in the context of the game. The player must manipulate the AI's learning to be successful - not pursuing successful strategies too far and saving "tricks" for when they are most impactful.

Ask HN: Which game has an impressive AI?

Related Stories