Ask HN: Do you limit your code to a certain line width?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4844528

by rustc • 14 years ago

12 23 14 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

If yes, then 1. How much? 2. How strict are you in following the limit? 3. What do you think about this?

I'm interested because I was trying to format code to 80 chars wide, but I find that a little less. I think between 100-110 is a sweet spot for readability.

PS: I write Ruby/JS.

stray• 14 years ago

I limit it to 132 characters, the standard line printer page width.

I follow it completely, regardless of language.

davismwfl• 14 years ago

I used to be fanatical about 78 character width because we would print code from time to time and following wrapping lines can be a royal pain (ahh, the 90's).

Anymore I have been "ok" with 120 characters for most code, mostly because screen sizes have gotten so nice and I rarely print code anymore.

That said, I do still try and keep code around 80 characters wide where ever possible though, I just find the formatting and code legibility to be better in most circumstances. Also, I find this keeps people from nesting things too deep (C/C++/C# come to mind), because it becomes hard to follow the code, hence they start breaking code into more modular components.

My other reason, I sometimes work off only my laptop monitor and while it gets wide, I find myself scrolling left and right when code exceeds 90ish characters in width and that bugs me.

eduardordm3• 14 years ago

Programmers using line lengths as a reason to building modular software is something that I never heard in my life, not even as a joke.

yen223• 14 years ago

For object-oriented languages, long line lengths are signs that you are violating the Law of Demeter: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Demeter

rachelbythebay3• 14 years ago

80. It shocked me to learn that some people don't hard-wrap their code at all. I ran into some github repository with comments which went on for 200+ characters and couldn't figure out what kind of maniac would inflict that upon the world.

I wrote a post about it which generated some responses, and it seems IDEs are to blame. Once you get into some of those environments, keeping things (relatively) narrow for the sake of others might just go out the window.

I covered it here, including a screenshot of what a typical dev session for me looks like: http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2012/08/31/lines/

DrinkWater• 14 years ago

Are you serious with these green terminal sessions? Wow....my eyes

rachelbythebay3• 14 years ago

Yes. My monitor can be astonishingly bright with other settings. I used to do black-on-white in the past, but that was on a different display which wasn't quite so powerful.

eduardordm3• 14 years ago

When I code C for embedded hardware, I agree 80 is more than enough, but that's because that is a simple language and the artifacts always lead to smaller widths.

Now, try that in C++. You can loose 10+ chars to indentation (namespacing, etc) alone. I think the 80 chars puritanism is just plain idiotic, specially in some languages like Obj-C.

Take this kind of bureaucratic crap:

[[NSNotificationCenter defaultCenter] addObserver:self selector:@selector(whateverChanged:) name:UITextViewTextDidChangeNotification object:nil];

If you start hard wrapping every long call you find you will end up with incredibly long files, filled with framework crap instead of useful information.

rizwan• 14 years ago

And yet, Google's Objective-C style guide (adopted by many) is uncompromising in its 80-character line length:

http://google-styleguide.googlecode.com/svn/trunk/objcguide....

jdavid2• 14 years ago

javascript can have a lot of indents with all of the closures, so ... in those cases I might set the indent spacing to 2.

I still think that it's just common good manners to keep code to 80 chars, those languages should work better to not be so verbose.

orangethirty• 14 years ago

80, if possible. Some places dont follow that practice, though. 80 keeps it tidy.

Pinatubo• 14 years ago

I'm pretty strict about 80. For whatever reason I find it easier to scroll down with my eyes rather than read across a long line.

rustc• 14 years ago

I'm sure _everyone_ would find it easier to read scrolling down rather than horizontally.

mixmastamyk• 14 years ago

79, narrow columns easier to read (think newspaper), printable, keeps nesting to a minimum, and helps keep edits (in version control/diffs) reasonably surgical. On widescreen allows two windows to be side to side.

eshvk• 14 years ago

I used to wrap to 79 because I used to write a lot of Python but once you get to the world of Java, 79 hampers readability. I still feel uncomfortable (and guilty) going beyond 79 though.

ohashi• 14 years ago

I am not very strict about it. I generally try to keep it on my screen. If it starts to horizontally scroll, I will split it up. This used to come up a lot while crafting longer SQL statements. I just started writing them on multiple lines instead of out habit.

caw• 14 years ago

I'm not strict about column widths. If it starts to look too long (100+?), I check the column position and see if I shouldn't hard wrap it. Most of what I write isn't super long or super complex one-liners.

If I were working on a team based project, then I would absolutely adhere to a basic style guide regarding whitespace, line widths, etc.

loungin• 14 years ago

80 as well. Keeps stuff tidy across many monitors, and as a lucky bonus at work a NERDTree window and two 80 column windows fit perfectly on one monitor.

Edit: guess I should add I primarily work in Python, C, and Javascript.

ishbits• 14 years ago

80. So I can have 2 code windows side by side. Be it emacs or eclipse.

jdavid2• 14 years ago

I have a column usually set to 80 chars, or sometimes 100, and I manually make sure that it's not much longer than that unless it would hurt code readability to make a new line.

I try to have two windows open on my MacBook Pro 80-100 chars per line allows me to do that, most of the time.

It is a pet peeve of mine when developers try to fit as much on one line of code as possible. There are tools to compile code, you as a developer should try to make your code as human readable as possible, that is unless you like being the only one to maintain your code.

Ask HN: Do you limit your code to a certain line width?

Related Stories