Google's "iLost" Motorola ad faked an address to "lose" iOS 6 Maps

http://appleinsider.com/articles/12/09/27/googles-ilost-motorola-ad-faked-an-address-to-lose-ios-6-maps

by joshus • 14 years ago

16 16 14 years ago

DRAGONERO• 14 years ago

Why fake a location on a flawed map? Was the goal just to get caught in doing that? It seems a bit silly to do something like that since Apple Maps is in such a bad shape.

natesm• 14 years ago

All they had to try was "53 and 3". Apparently the Ramones were singing about Singapore :)

splawn• 14 years ago

could it be something like a movie using a 555 prefix on a telephone number?

smackfu• 14 years ago

Are we sure the Apple hasn't fixed this since the release? I know people were complaining about getting sent to Brooklyn for what should be Manhattan addresses.

>So why would anyone actually be "looking for 315 E 15th" in New York? The only reasonable reason would be to locate an actual address that does exist in Brooklyn

I'd be really surprised if Apple is checking whether particular street numbers are assigned when it is finding their location. That seems very dependent on iffy data. In fact, I just checked it, and it will gladly locate an address past the last number on a street, and just put the number at the end. (If you get really crazy with the number, it will say 'Approximate Location') Google does the same thing.

akmiller2• 14 years ago

Why does Apple Insider continually use "Google" in this story instead of Motorola Mobility. Yes, Google owns them but they are still their own entity. It's silly to suggest that since a company owns another company that they oversee everything that company does. I think it's fair to say "Google's Motorola Mobility", but if you just read this article you would think that Google itself was behind the advertising campaign.

barista2• 14 years ago

If Google owns the entity then Google better be behind these campaigns

akmiller2• 14 years ago

Have you never worked for a large corporation that owned or was owned by another entity. I have and I can tell you that while we were owned by someone else we still operated as an individual company. Their may have been some changes, but day to day operations were very much unchanged.

akgerber2• 14 years ago

Just because a piece of land doesn't have a building on it (even if it isn't currently legally buildable) doesn't mean its address "doesn't exist". New York City is glad to point you at the address: http://gis.nyc.gov/dcp/at/f1.jsp?submit=true&house_nbr=3...

akgerber2• 14 years ago

Likewise, the stretch of "E 15th St." in Brooklyn is actually named "Marlborough Rd." on the ground in the stretch where #315 is located: https://maps.google.com/maps?q=315+E+15th+St,+Flatbush+-+Dit...

It does look like the city understands the alternate name, not that that'd help you when you're out looking at street signs: http://gis.nyc.gov/dcp/at/f1.jsp?submit=true&house_nbr=3...

barista2• 14 years ago

Just checked and Bing gets it too!

WildUtah• 14 years ago

Errata to the writer: the hotel name you could not locate in Sapporo is written in kana, specifically katakana, one of the four distinct alphabet and glyph systems the Japanese written language requires.

Only the name of the city of Sapporo is written in kanji as you suggest.

FireBeyond3• 14 years ago

You know "Sequences and screen images simulated"?

Know why that is on most cell phone ads?

Because other manufacturers complained of deceptive practices in advertising when Apple would talk of how easy (and quick) it was to do something on the iPhone compared to other phones...

shinratdr2• 14 years ago

Actually that message was present long before Apple was popular. Digital images are always super-imposed onto devices after filming because the camera picks up the actual device screen as somewhat washed out.

I do love the anti-Apple explanation you have concocted from thin air though. Plausible enough that some might buy it. However most on HN won't buy it because they aren't 12.

FireBeyond3• 14 years ago

One apology: "Sequences shortened".

And, no - the 3GS was targeted for a class action:

http://www.wireless-weblog.com/50226711/the_iphone_3g_class_...

"Twice as fast at half the price"

The venerable 37S acknowledged that, as a result, the 3GS ads started including that phrase.

http://37signals.com/svn/posts/1328-apple-iphone-ad-sequence...

http://www.idownloadblog.com/2012/03/30/siri-la-suit-fake-ad...

But nice pro-Apple shilling to make me sound like the bad guy.

-- signed, an iPhone 4, 4S, iPad 3, 2G nano, 160GB classic iPod owner.

Google's "iLost" Motorola ad faked an address to "lose" iOS 6 Maps

Related Stories