Ask HN: Is Eliezer Yudkowsky a genius playing the long game?
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35429490To those who are unaware, Yudkowsky recently published an article calling for the banning of any ML training and the use of force by the international community to forcibly stop anyone who disobeys, even saying WW3 would be preferable to more ML training.
At first glance Yudkowski's recommendations seem pretty hyperbolic. But now I'm wondering if this guy is actually taking the "long view" and will end up being remembered as one of the great thinkers.
The AI/ML revolution is just getting started, and it promises to upend much of human society. I'd say a backlash is inevitable, and will intensify as the tech gets more and more capable. Given that there WILL be a major backlash in the future (far more major than what we see today), I think Yudkowski may have positioned himself as the "grandfather" of a new, budding ideology defined by anti-technology and anti-AI views. Like Smith or Marx before him, Yudkowski makes provocative proclamations about a concept that seems like it will define our coming century. I wonder if what he's said so far is already enough to make him the "face" of an anti-AI movement that in my opinion will likely grow to rival even the most powerful ideologies of history.
EDIT: To clarify, basically what I'm trying to say here is that Yudkowski is being farsighted by being the first one to claim this "shut it all down" position. Many people are going to join this camp in the future and now it may well be known as "Yudkowskiism" or something like that.