Ask HN: Which are good LINQ equivalents in other languages?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27770361

by IanSanders • 5 years ago

2 7 5 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

Rounin2• 5 years ago

In Java, the closest alternative that's part of the standard language is streams. Off the top of my head, it goes something like this:

List<Integer> numbers = number_list.stream().filter(number -> number > 3).collect(Collectors.toList())

boolean isTrue = Stream.of(boolean_array).anyMatch(Function.identity());

String checkForNull = Optional.ofNullable(some_xml).map(SomeXml::getSomeField).map(SomeField::GetSomeAttribute).orElse("nothing here");

Rounin2• 5 years ago

Many other languages have similar mechanisms to the Java streams API. Scheme, and probably Lisp in general, is well known for it. Then we have Ruby, Crystal, Python, D, JavaScript...

I can't think of other languages that have something exactly like LINQ, though, unless you count SQL.

aliasEli• 5 years ago

But this lacks the compact syntax of LINC. I don't think there is a real equivalent in other languages (I don't know F#).

croo• 5 years ago

Not part of the standard library but querydsl is the closest to it in java.

whb07• 5 years ago

codegeek• 5 years ago

Eloquent in PHP/Laravel is a good contender.

Graffur• 5 years ago

Off topic question about LINQ.. when should you use it? C# can be written in s few different ways. Some linq type solutions can be elegant but if the next person updating expects classic c# style it probably isn't the best option

Ask HN: Which are good LINQ equivalents in other languages?

Related Stories