HN user

wangii

217 karma
Posts2
Comments222
View on HN

yep, that's my first thought came to my mind as well. it's a great talk fueled with the passion of engineer, especially relevant in the era of LLM.

good observation! however, I'd argue it's the distribution channel and installation friction did the job in the cases you mentioned.

given how easy it's to replace LLM API in claude code, and how easy it is to write a claude code clone with itself (Fable is pretty good!), the collapse is coming.

Ted Chiang is a great Sci-Fi author, but his remark `GPT-3 and similar models as a "blurry JPEG of the Web"` was misleading at the best.

I share the view with others the term `consciousness` is not well-define yet, therefore his assessment is pointless. Maybe the real question to ask, if consciousness is merely an illusion at the macro level, when the observers not looking at the tech/implementation level deep enough, just like the term "intelligence" itself, might be more precisely captured by drifting amongst high dimensional manifold pitches.

The idea of software developers' job is to translate specification into codes is dying. Now what I'm experimenting is to make my developers into competing project manager and developers are replaced by AI. I think the key advantages of developers, junior or senior, are the process + data oriented style of thinking, therefore way ahead of people from many other domain.

I told my developers: the day of making good money by sitting in front of computer and typing is long gone. Go to the clients' scenes and build the whole thing from scratch, with some assistant from sales and domain experts. Now you are the PM.

It's all about the right mind set at the very top level. At the beginning of the PC era, nobody would bet IBM to lose. Same in the dawn of internet, all money was on MS. so it happened to Nokia and Ericsson.

Google is a giant without a direction. The ads money is so good that it just doesn't have the gut to leave it on the table.

she's done pretty important work but since then obsessed with the vague term `spatial intelligence`. what does it mean? there isn't a clear definition in the piece. it seems very intuitive & fundamental but tbh not *rigorous*, nor insightful.

I bet it's a dead end.

I feel it's a pretty dangerous optimization before we REALLY understand what's going on inside of the LLM. e.g. guys believe in the geometric interpretation will have something to say, and it would probably hurt if you are using "filler" tokens.

Besides, the assumption (not a universal fact) that "forming complete sentences in mind before articulating word by word" seems overly simplifies activities happens in our mind: do we really have a complete planning before start talking/typing? as a Buddhist I lean towards it's an illusion. further more, what about simultaneous thoughts? are we linear thinker in the sentence level?

anyway, pretty neat math!

not able to sign in with github:

Unable to process request due to missing initial state. This may happen if browser sessionStorage is inaccessible or accidentally cleared. Some specific scenarios are - 1) Using IDP-Initiated SAML SSO. 2) Using signInWithRedirect in a storage-partitioned browser environment.

the problem is then the total number of computation drops dramatically therefore leads to much less "thinking" power. i think the idea originated from an understanding that when we write/speak, we have an overall idea. my current hypothesis is it's probably an illusion.

you may want to search for "filler" papers to read.

People make same kind of mistakes all the time, instead of judging the contents, we look down to things that are "mostly repackaging" what already exist. Brand new things are extremely rare, mostly just remix of things we've seen everyday.

We Need Taiwan 3 years ago

The Taiwanese are some of the most wonderful people you’ll ever meet.

this applies to everywhere. no new information.

As a free and open democratic society, they would deserve our support for that alone.

ah, so it's really about ideology?

If that’s not enough, then we should support them out of pure self-interest, as we’re all better off for having them.

??