HN user

skibidithink

159 karma

Perhaps a lunatic was simply a minority of one.

Posts0
Comments36
View on HN
No posts found.
The MacBook Neo 4 months ago

OS X / macOS has been ahead of Windows for a long time for anyone who lives in a web browser.

Non-Zero-Sum Games 7 months ago

Which facts are misrepresented?

The point is that the author picks some arbitrary critique and calls them fallacious, when the core of the disagreement is elsewhere.

Right, all the games that they think will be successful. Most games won't- it's a power law market.

There's nothing preventing a game dev from selling exclusively on their own site. It's not as though Steam has exclusive access to Windows customers like the App/Play Store do on their platforms. Steam earns its customers and their trust and developers follow.

Non-Zero-Sum Games 7 months ago

Critics are typically saying that giving out scholarships limited by race is racially discriminatory.

Non-Zero-Sum Games 7 months ago

You did say it.

with slots going to the rich and privileged) [...] AA just pushes against THAT

It doesn't give away the slots reserved for the rich.

And it's not a tiebreaker between equally qualified candidates. At Harvard, Africans who performed in the 4th decile were admitted more often than Asians in the 10th decile. [1]

[1]. See page 11 (by document numbering). https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/20/20-1199/169941/202...

Non-Zero-Sum Games 7 months ago

None of my arguments require any assumption on why. But I would say that it's because of prestige and signaling.

Non-Zero-Sum Games 7 months ago

AA doesn't prevent the rich from buying admissions. It redistributes slots from middle and lower class folks with the wrong ethnicity.

Non-Zero-Sum Games 7 months ago

And many against affirmative action will agree that there have been massive historical injustices for certain demographics that have lingering effects. The difference between these two sides is which value they prioritize.

Non-Zero-Sum Games 7 months ago

It's only positive sum if they grew because of affirmative action. And if affirmative action caused net friction, it'd be a Moloch.

Non-Zero-Sum Games 7 months ago

Even if some critics of AA are committing that fallacy, debunking a weaker argument when a stronger argument exists is ineffective.

The implicit argument is that AA's largest challenge is a coordination problem. It's not. It's a clash in values and a fight over zero-sum rewards.

Non-Zero-Sum Games 7 months ago

Lots of interesting insights, but their affirmative action take is a miss.

Critics of affirmative action often commit the fallacy of letting a failure in one area doom the entire enterprise. This ignores the interdependent nature of affirmative action. [1]

Affirmative action sets up a zero-sum game where fixed resources like university admissions and employment offers are redistributed to people with the "correct" demographics. The conflict is not a disagreement over effectiveness. It's a misalignment between meritocracy and equity.

[1] https://nonzerosum.games/unlockingsolutions.html