HN user

shridharxp

57 karma
Posts0
Comments15
View on HN
No posts found.

There are concerns that AI might/will make mistakes. Instead of optimizing for producing perfect code, they think that AI can fix bugs as fast as it produces code and are optimizing for MTTR. Sounds like decision made by people who don't write code regularly, as there is this Architectural drift that happens where you are no longer aware of what's happening in your codebase. As a junior guy I so want this to happen.

ClaudeCode:

- Making functions async without need; it doesn't know the difference between the two or in which scenarios to use them.

- Consistently fails to make changes to the frontend if a project grows above 5000 LOC or a file goes near 1000 LOC.

- The worst part is it lies after making changes.

ChatGPT:

- Fails to implement mid-complex functionality such as scrolling to the bottom when new logs are coming in and not scrolling when the user is checking historical logs.

These models are good at mainstream tasks, the snippets of which you find a lot in repositories. Try to do something off-beat such as algorithmic trading; they fail spectacularly.

Few months ago, the founder was talking about "AGI" and ridiculous universal basic compute. At this point, I don't even know whom to believe. My first hand experience tells ChatGPT and even ClaudeCode are no where near the expertise they are touted to be. Yet, the marketing by these companies is so immense that you get washed away, you don't know who are agents and who are putting their true opinions.

It would be interesting to consider where humans would find fulfillment when what they have done every day for years is rendered worthless.

Discovery Coding 1 year ago

I use a mixture of both discovery and planning. The problem with pure discovery approach is I sometimes start to code when I am not completely attentive because of deadlines, and if I am working with a larger codebase it is difficult to instantly start writing code because you need some time to understand the context. I always have a text file open all the time where I note down stuff such as: context, plans, ideas, edge cases, conflicts, todos etc.; it serves as a swap memory.