HN user

scdoshi

1,039 karma
  Engineer @ Homejoy S10
  Co-founder @ viaCycle S12
Posts37
Comments73
View on HN
stratechery.com 2y ago

Google's True Moonshot

scdoshi
168pts123
www.reuters.com 6y ago

Google backs Reliance's Jio Platforms with $4.5B India investment

scdoshi
1pts1
www.theguardian.com 6y ago

How to Sit Properly at Work

scdoshi
2pts0
www.npr.org 6y ago

The Hummer is coming back as an electric vehicle

scdoshi
38pts60
www.nytimes.com 7y ago

Chinese authorities install app on phones of people entering Xinjiang

scdoshi
200pts5
www.wsj.com 7y ago

Bogle Sounds a Warning on Index Funds

scdoshi
228pts229
www.nbcnews.com 7y ago

Scientists say mysterious 'Oumuamua' object could be an alien spacecraft

scdoshi
2pts0
www.bbc.com 8y ago

IBM’s machine argues, pretty convincingly, with humans

scdoshi
1pts0
www.nytimes.com 8y ago

Google to Sell Zagat to The Infatuation, an Upstart Review Site

scdoshi
169pts104
www.theguardian.com 8y ago

United Airlines engine disintegrates over Pacific, forcing emergency landing

scdoshi
1pts0
www.usatoday.com 8y ago

New California declares 'independence' from California

scdoshi
4pts0
www.businessinsider.com 8y ago

Stranger Things pop-up bar asked to shut down with humorous cease-and-desist

scdoshi
2pts0
mobile.nytimes.com 8y ago

Kaspersky: The Russian Company That Is a Danger to Our Security

scdoshi
41pts63
nytimes.com 8y ago

In India, SoftBank Tries, Tries Again

scdoshi
3pts0
thinkgrowth.org 9y ago

Why Good People Leave Large Tech Companies

scdoshi
410pts245
www.nytimes.com 9y ago

India, Once a Coal Goliath, Is Fast Turning Green

scdoshi
506pts151
www.bbc.com 9y ago

The Chinese man trapped in India for half a century

scdoshi
2pts0
mobile.nytimes.com 9y ago

For Fact-Checking Website Snopes, a Bigger Role Brings More Attacks

scdoshi
2pts0
www.bbc.com 9y ago

Handheld ZX Spectrum 'pain in buttons'

scdoshi
1pts0
scroll.in 9y ago

The powerful potential of community radio stations in India

scdoshi
1pts0
www.bbc.com 9y ago

Can jet engines clean up Delhi's air?

scdoshi
84pts121
www.bbc.com 10y ago

Why India's new bankruptcy law is good for businesses

scdoshi
1pts0
www.skytree.net 10y ago

Free easy-to-use machine learning interfaces: GUI, REST, and SDK

scdoshi
4pts0
www.nytimes.com 10y ago

Some Officers Bristle at Recall of Military Equipment

scdoshi
2pts0
www.bbc.com 10y ago

Word up: The secret story of Scrabble

scdoshi
1pts0
www.bbc.com 10y ago

The mysterious origins of punctuation

scdoshi
69pts15
www.engadget.com 10y ago

Google Search starts connecting you directly to plumbers, locksmiths

scdoshi
1pts0
www.buzzfeed.com 10y ago

Google’s Home Services Product Finally, Officially Launches Today

scdoshi
1pts0
blogs.wsj.com 11y ago

India’s Mars Orbiter Safe After Comet Flyby

scdoshi
1pts0
www.forbes.com 12y ago

Homejoy (YC S10) expands to London

scdoshi
1pts0

This might be just me, but the most important thing to me when I get advice is:

- who am I getting it from

- what do I know about their life/experience

- under what circumstances

Because that let's me adjust how much importance to put on it. Getting advice is generally not the hard part, figuring out which advice to follow and which to discard is.

I might be missing something, but seems to me like the products are still recycled, but as raw materials, not as full devices.

This makes sense, given data is almost certainly bound to be present on phones etc.

Maybe there's a more nuanced way to do this, but this doesn't seem all that bad.

OTOH, having these phones go through a refurb program and selling them probably involves a fair amount or resource use as well.

[dead] 9 years ago

The article describes a hypothetical scenario.

It's clear if you read carefully and pay attention to the dates, but this is the kind of thing that seeds fake news and forwards. Disappointed that shock value and clickbaity titles are being used by a rights advocate group.

Okay, but he's basing this argument on his paper, where he sets out to show that immigrants are in fact, not exceptional.

However, if you believe my reasoning, then he isn't really measuring anything. So, we don't know if immigrants are exceptional or ordinary or worse. Or at least not based on his paper.

Okay, so obviously, an employment based visa program does create conflicts of interest and in general, is not good for the immigrant employee, compared to a non employment based visa.

However, the claim that immigrant employees are somehow not as good as their American counterparts is based on shoddy logic.

The criteria he uses in his paper to measure this:

- high salary - high rate of patent production - Ph.D. dissertation awards - doctorate earned at a top-ranked university - employment in R&D

Because of issues with the employment based visa, he himself argues earlier in the article that immigrant employees end up with a lower salary.

Top ranked universities don't always admit people based on merit. Being in the country when applying to school and speaking the language have huge advantages. A lot of graduate admissions are on a case by case basis, and getting an in person meeting with the professor can make all the difference. Also, top graduate schools tend to be a lot more expensive.

Employment is R&D is also hampered by the fact that immigrants don't have comparatively fewer choices when looking for a job, again because of issues with employment based visas. This is especially true is you want to do research in aerospace or materials because of security clearances.

Overall, this doesn't give me a lot of confidence in his other analyses.

Disclaimer: I'm an immigrant, so I'm not without my biases here.

This is basically the same argument in general against basic income, prepended with "in the case of India, it won't work because... "

I don't know if basic income works, but that's why experiments in the field are required. None of the reasons you have pointed out seem to be apply only to India.

One Percent Stake 9 years ago

Privilege when used in this sense doesn't mean everything is great all the time, it means that in certain situations, some people have an inherent advantage because of something they had no hand in.

One such example is race, hence white privilege. There are other reasons for privilege as well.

Do you think off-shore developers are going to have the same moral stances of a first world developer? I don't think so.

It's not as if first world developers (or employers) are on average more ethical than off-shore ones. You could have made the same point without being derisive of off-shore developers.

But it's also true that if you come to the US during or after college, banks will not issue you a credit card.

Instead, they will issue you a 'secured' credit card, where you get a $300-500 limit on a card against the same amount paid to the bank as security. Only after a year or 2 of this, will the bank actually issue credit.

Maybe you had an account/history with the bank for a while, and that made a difference?

Goodbye Sweden 11 years ago

Is this not essentially like every other nationalist rant?

Too many immigrants, they are taking our jobs/benefits, we're letting the jihadis in, and so forth?

Goodbye Sweden 11 years ago

the xenophobia in this rant basically amounts to "sweden for swedes", but it's more striking when you read this on the About page:

Please note that I enforce a zero-tolerance policy towards racism, violence and extremist comments.

Judging other people by the color of their skin is manifestly absurd. So please don’t submit such comments here

Edit: removed some sarcasm

If you are on the inside and you think the issue is pay scales and job descriptions, surely you've tried to fix these issues and have some data instead of a rant?

Not trying to be sarcastic here, but actually interested th the results

From the article... "You’ve just got a lot of young people raising $1 and $2 million seed rounds for dumb products. How are they going to make money off another photo or text messaging app? It’s like, c’mon guys, let’s challenge ourselves and do something better."

Also, from the article... "Sherbert — a Twitter-like app for four-minute instructional videos"