HN user

rosskimbarovsky

155 karma
Posts21
Comments11
View on HN
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Buzzwords and the Paradox of Credibility

rosskimbarovsky
14pts4
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Crowdsourcing, the Gulf Oil Spill and the Arrogance of BP

rosskimbarovsky
19pts13
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Book Review: Rework (by Jason Fried and David Heinemeier Hansson)

rosskimbarovsky
6pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Book Review: Delivering Happiness by Zappos’ CEO Tony Hsieh

rosskimbarovsky
8pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Why Every Small Business And Startup Must Understand Social Currency

rosskimbarovsky
13pts2
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Startup Tip: Not Every Failure Is A Learning Experience

rosskimbarovsky
18pts8
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Twitter’s New Ad Policy And The Dangers Of Tying Your Business To Another

rosskimbarovsky
15pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Startup & Small Business Tip: Marketing One-To-One

rosskimbarovsky
10pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

7 posts for entrepreneurs on motivation, fear of failure & more

rosskimbarovsky
11pts2
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Tips for startups and small business: creating a presentation

rosskimbarovsky
7pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Social Media Revolution – Unbelievable Facts and Figures

rosskimbarovsky
16pts11
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Startup tips-12 post on pr, marketing & venture capital

rosskimbarovsky
13pts0
rosskimbarovsky.com 16y ago

Startup marketing tip - why it's important to market to customers one-to-one

rosskimbarovsky
5pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Tips for startups for dealing with customer resistance to change

rosskimbarovsky
7pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Google Crowdsourcing Investments

rosskimbarovsky
11pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Fiat Crowdsourcing Car Design

rosskimbarovsky
3pts4
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Small Business Tip: Conference Banners

rosskimbarovsky
1pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

11 Great Posts About Startup Strategy, Investment, Branding & Biz Models

rosskimbarovsky
3pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

What Can You Learn From The World’s Best Brands?

rosskimbarovsky
1pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Twitter Link Roundup

rosskimbarovsky
5pts0
blog.crowdspring.com 16y ago

Whores, Vegetarianism, Moral High Ground & Capitalist Baggage

rosskimbarovsky
13pts2

I co-founded crowdSPRING. Illustration projects are perfectly appropriate crowdsourcing projects (we've done many for startups, big Brands and some of the world's best agencies). Let me offer a few suggestions that should help you get a good result regardless of where you post your project:

1. Be sensitive to your budget if the illustration is complex. Many people forget that illustrations can be rather complex - and you're talking about a large illustration (which might have many components and may need to interface with other on-page elements). You'll attract better illustrators if you can stretch your budget a bit (depending on complexity, of course).

2. Limit initial scope. If you ultimately need a full page illustration, you might initially ask for an illustration of a portion and then narrow your selections and ask a few people to show you more complete illustrations. Asking everyone to do full page illustrations - especially if your budget is modest - might limit the number of participants.

3. Identify styles you like. Even more important than sketching your idea is a reference for the types of illustrations you like. Many illustrators have a particular style and if you can be clear at the beginning, you'll help them focus on showing examples of work that you're more likely to like - rather than just take stabs in the dark submitting random illustration styles.

I hope these are helpful and wish you luck with the illustration (and your MVP!)

Ross

There are some similarities, but frankly, more differences. crowdSPRING projects are, on average, much higher in value. There are typically many more $1000+ projects, for example, and often, $5000+ projects on crowdSPRING.

crowdSPRING offers graphic and web design projects (99designs does too). But crowdSPRING also offers industrial design (products and product packaging) and copywriting projects.

More info about differences here: http://bit.ly/whycS

That's certainly a fair point - proposed solutions aren't guaranteed to work. But given InnoCentive's long history of helping the government and some of the world's smartest companies solve really complex problems, surely it was worth at least an exploration. I'm certain the InnoCentive community would have helped - and still will - whittle the ideas down to those that make the most sense.

The simple truth is that BP isn't able to solve the problem. I hope they will. But for the moment, rejecting potential solutions seems short sighted.