HN user

pointhi

8 karma
Posts0
Comments7
View on HN
No posts found.

Live synchronization of layout and schematic files is a feature you find in EAGLE, but in almost no other EDA program.

If you say KiCAD is not an professional EDA due to missing live synchronization, the same argument applies also to Altium, Cadence Allegro, and most other EDA systems which are considered as professional by most people.

[dead] 2 years ago

OSH Park reports 37% of projects uploaded in 2023 were created in KiCad: https://nitter.net/oshpark/status/1749531515103666670

Those numbers are likely biased toward hobby electronic designers located in Europe and USA. It would be interesting to see the numbers from manufactures with different target audiences.

I'm the creator of the Altium importer in KiCad, and yes, importer development is time consuming but important for people without access to those programs. I even looked into Allegro and reverse-engineered initial bits, but without access to those programs it is practically impossible to write something meaningful. At least for Allegro, you can export to Fabmaster and import it into KiCad.

It's also easier to write importers for the ASCII file format than for the default binary file format, but for the former one the user needs to have access to the proprietary program to export it, which makes them unsuitable for some use-cases.