HN user

itopaloglu83

1,214 karma
Posts1
Comments443
View on HN

Fable’s ability to understand concepts and combine different aspects together is quite impressive.

Opus keeps wondering around unrelated topics, and you find yourself scattered and constantly telling Opus to focus on the problem.

Claude Sonnet 5 22 days ago

More and more I find myself trying to stop Opus from doing something stupid, and at every turn I need to tell it to stop overcomplicating things.

I think the models are being optimized for wealth extraction from users and companies, instead of solving problems.

I don't know why Opus would try to create an entire library when I told it specifically to do something simple that would take 2-3 lines of Python.

I think it’s a general misconception with folks that export controls only apply to weapons, forgetting that it applies to many high-end manufacturing and technology.

I’m surprised about some of the reactions, but again anyone who has a security clearance wouldn’t touch any of this discussion with a ten-foot pole also.

There are tens of thousands of defense contractors that not only work with export-controlled stuff, but even top-secret and other higher levels.

Getting just a secret clearance takes up to a year, and expecting to do this for all employees, in this AI market? Not going to happen, things move way too fast.

People complain about the US approach, but almost every high end manufacturing is being export controlled, from ASML machines to high end optic used in missiles.

The amount of tracking is already at insane levels, none of this is being done with good intentions.

We must get rid off cookie banners permanently and a browser level “do not track” must be enforced.

Nothing can be gained by meeting in the middle with these intrusive ad companies.

In my experience Claude tends to immensely over complicate things and go for a complex abstraction scheme even when all it needs to do is two lines of code. Combined with its eagerness to just code and more importantly pay more attention to the last prompt causes it to do an insanely complex solution first and then patch things with half assed attempts. The whole ordeal results in a code that on an initial glance looks okay, but quickly breaks down and becomes unmanageable. A significant effort is needed to push back Claude’s tendencies, so I mainly find myself pushing back or looking for ways to write an initial prompt with enough guidance, but only Fable was following them properly, Opus simply acts like a rhino in a china shop.

Digital Markets Act was supposed to define markets and allow competition, however it quickly turned into some existing monopolies putting their fingers into some American businesses and not addressing the main issues.

Whenever a successful European company like ASML is mentioned in the same context of monopolies due to their earned success in the semiconductor industry, then none of the market control (and I’m not just talking about digital markets here) goes out of the window.

Then I keep asking myself, are monopolies a bad thing that needs to be regulated because they can kill innovation and suck resources from nations, or does that only apply when it’s certain American companies only when they threatening the benefits of certain oligarchs.

If you are a tech company that becomes as successful as to be a monopoly or a participant in an oligopoly with a strong network effect, why wouldn't you be recognized as a gatekeeper?

Exactly. There are numerous monopolies that are scumming resources and wealth out of masses and not being tackled either because they’re owned by the right people or they’re strategically important. Then the discussion about how monopolies are bad and that’s why we’re addressing them becomes a mute argument. It’s supposed to be a government of the people, but sometimes it’s using it as an excuse to serve the interests of the few in right places, and not the successful companies.

I was pointing out the arbitrary and political nature of the decisions being made.

A company being a monopoly is a problem, unless it’s a European one like ASML etc. Then it’s a technology they built over the years and they should reap the benefits of it.

Which one is it, are monopolies bad or the markets, digital or not, defined by how much European involvement and ownership it contains? Or is DMA a tool to catchup in certain markets by curbing the external parties?