HN user

gagaga

127 karma
Posts2
Comments50
View on HN
The New Foursquare 12 years ago

Yelp's ratings, reviews, recommendations, and tips aren't very good for food, bars, and things to do. I've always found Foursquare's to be much higher quality.

I hear sentiments like this a lot, but I don't agree. Many companies have training on how to use Google Calendar/Drive properly. That doesn't mean these products are too complicated.

I imagine Bing has greater marketshare/engagement when compared to Google Search than Google+ does when compared to FB.

Crunchbase 2.0 12 years ago

Seems like a step back from the old design? Not a great browsing experience and for company pages, there is not very much information above the fold anymore.

The New Deal 12 years ago

The network you'll make at top-tier schools is IMO a lot more important than anything else.

What would happen if we valued forums the way we value tech sites? What would SomethingAwful's valuation be in today's tech world when it had the engagement and content creation power it held in the early 2000s ?

To me, Quora is really nothing more than a glorified forum.

The users can dictate the ordering of apps and folders on the Metro Start Screen. Not only that, users can incorporate spatial organization to make apps even easier to scan and find quickly. You could argue that this is a better design. However, all designs have pros and cons and are not necessarily best for all use cases.

As to your second point, I think the question is how do you improve your UI without breaking previous mental models/behavior?

So your problem isn't with the small-start screen vs big screen, but with the density of information? With the Metro Start Screen you can customize apps, folders, and their sizes to your liking, or just type what application you want and hit enter to launch it.

Actually it's a terribly efficient design. The usability studies that involved eye-tracking showed that when the start menu is open, users gaze is purely focused on the start menu, not other objects on the desktop. If this is the case, then why not use the whole screen as your start menu? Now you can show many more apps, search results, and allow users to spatially group apps and folders to their liking.

The backlash came from the fact that it was a change from 20+ years of ingrained behavior, not that it was an inherently poor design. However, you could argue breaking the previous mental model of users will definitely create issues and therefore is a bad design.

As someone who has worked at Microsoft, I can tell you they spend thousands of hours on usability studies and the managers watch. Also there are countless readouts and documents summarizing the findings.

Microsoft spends an incredible amount of resources on usability studies.