HN user

four_fifths

154 karma
Posts14
Comments3
View on HN

If you do a bit of digging into most of the popular benchmarks that all the big labs report on, you'll see pretty quickly that they have almost zero correlation with any real world tasks.

The approach that they're taking here of working backwards from a OS repo pull request and reverse engineering a question is unusually well thought out for a benchmark.

I haven't dug into more of the dataset questions yet, but the example they give in the blog post for the question generated for Hugging Face Transformer's repo gives me hope that this could actually be a solid benchmark:

How do the fast image and video processor base classes prevent shared mutable state when instantiating multiple instances?

so if i understand this correctly — you want the speech recognition model to identify a vocabulary of specific terms that it wasn't trained on. instead of fine-tuning with training data that includes the new vocabulary, you input the full vocabulary at test time as a list of words and the model is able to generate transcripts that include words from the vocabulary.

seems like it could be very useful but it really comes down to the specifics.

you can prompt whisper with context — how does this compare?

how large of a vocabulary can it work with? if it's a few dozen words it's only gonna help for niche use cases. if it can handle 100s-1000s with good performance that could completely replace fine-tuning for many uses