HN user

emil-lp

695 karma
Posts3
Comments248
View on HN

But as always, the methodology is buried: how many open problems were tried until they found a success?

Not only that, but they have like 500 world-leading experts in mathematics and IMO alumni, so how do we know one of the agents wasn't hardcoded to return a proof that the mathematicians had found?

I'm a mathematician/graph theorist, and I've tried ChatGPT 5.3, 5.4, 5.5, and now 5.6 on a bunch of simple-ish open problems, and I've never gotten a solution.

Grok 4.5 14 days ago

The hardcore nerds have always been political. Wake up.

You're using the sell my soul to the devil argument.

If you achieve what you want to, it doesn't matter if you sold your soul on the way.

I don't know which field you're talking about, but in general, math and cs journals do not have page limits.

By the way, one of my favorite pastimes is to download the latex source for papers on arxiv and read all the commented-out stuff.

% we should make sure this theorem is actually true

2n choose n is just: you must move East 20 times and South 20 times. Hence any solution looks like a permutation of 20 Es and 20 Ss. Now, only look at the indices for the Es. There are 20 of them. Out of 40.

40 indices, pick 20. Those are East moves, the rest are South moves.