HN user

desilentio

64 karma
Posts1
Comments22
View on HN

I think both video and audio were skippy to the point of uselessness. I've also used Jitsi with moderate success with a couple of interlocutors, where video disappeared now and then.

I'm not a company, I'm at a university, and the u. has decided to use Zoom, perhaps because it doesn't care about security, or because it thinks being concerned about Zoom is being paranoid.

As for Zoom, I don't understand why people trust them or still use their product if they are at all concerned about security. It makes very little sense.

I certainly don't trust them, but I do use Zoom (from a dedicated unprivileged user, so it can't do any harm beyond recording my conversations), because my colleagues use Zoom, and because there doesn't seem to be any working alternative. I got them to try Jitsi once, which simply didn't work.

PS. There may be working /secret-source/ alternatives, but I don't know why one should think Zoom /more/ untrustworthy than them.

Since everybody is now using Zoom and not Skype, I would expect the NSA to try to get the same access to Zoom conversations as they have to Skype conversations. And I don't have the impression that Zoom would say no to billions of dollars to protect its users' privacy.

Isn't the whole point of end-to-end encryption -- not to have to trust any third party -- undermined by secret source? If one does not trust Zoom not to snoop on content passing unencrypted through their servers, why should one trust them to provide true end-to-end encryption? And, if one does trust them to provide true end-to-end encryption, why might one not as well trust them not to snoop on unencrypted content?

Beg the Question 6 years ago

That's a valid point. But isn't it a bit archaic to have the thing begged for as a direct object? Wouldn't it be more normal to say `beg for the question'?

Beg the Question 6 years ago

Why don't you just say `raise the question'? Should a language be deprived of everything that is not obvious (to everyone)?

Beg the Question 6 years ago

This claim on Wikipedia is false. The article referred to does not claim that `petitio principii' or `begging the question' is a ``mistranslation''. Nor are they. They are both perfectly correct and reasonable translations of `τὸ ἐν ἀρχῇ αἰτιεῖσθαι' (from Aristotle), which means to beg (ask, αἰτιεῖσθαι) one's interlocutor to grant one the very point in question (the ``question''), which one set out (in the beginning, ἐν ἀρχῇ) to demonstrate. (Literally, it means: ``the (thing) in (the) beginning (to) beg''.)

Beg the Question 6 years ago

It is important to understand that `question' does not here mean what it normally means (a query), but rather `the proposition in question'. Begging the question is asking one's interlocutor to accept as true the very proposition in question.