HN user

ReadEvalPost

279 karma

Engineering Manager @ FUTO.

cmdprompt at gmail.

Posts3
Comments87
View on HN

I've tried to explain this paper to people in similar circumstances and have also struggled!

In my mind the key point of departure between this paper and the more standard computational functionalist approaches is the importance of metabolism. Metabolism _precedes_ organism. The body is first deeply entangled with the environment through exchanges of resources (content causality) before it is capable of building computers (vehicle causality). Having built and alphabetized the world we can understand them in terms of discrete state transitions.

I expect my explanations have been unsatisfying as we can immediately move to seeing metabolism as some alphabetized input/output system that can be immediately placed back into the computational framework. Moving outside of this framework requires engaging with the enactivist/organicist traditions, which is a rich but minority view.

Reality Check 1 year ago

Ed's main critique is about business sustainability -- it's true that there are many articles about AI on IP issues or ethics but he is unique in actually crunching the numbers on profit.

FUTO | Austin, TX | ONSITE | Software Engineer | Full-time | https://futo.org

FUTO is an organization dedicated to developing, both through in-house engineering and investment, technologies that frustrate centralization and industry consolidation. Through a combination of in-house engineering projects, targeted investments, generous grants, and multi-media public education efforts, we will free technology from the control of the few and recreate the spirit of freedom, innovation, and self-reliance that underpinned the American tech industry only a few decades ago. Our principles are here: https://www.futo.org/about/what-is-futo/

There is consensus today that social media is broken. At FUTO we aim to fix this. In this role you will act as product owner of Polycentric (https://gitlab.futo.org/polycentric/polycentric), our open-source decentralized social network that also forms the basis of FUTO ID. Additionally you will also provide support for our next generation social media project.

More info here: https://futo.org/jobs/polycentric/

FUTO | Austin, TX | On-site / Hybrid / Remote | Full Time / Hourly

FUTO is an organization dedicated to developing, both through in-house engineering and investment, technologies that frustrate centralization and industry consolidation. Through a combination of in-house engineering projects, targeted investments, generous grants, and multi-media public education efforts, we will free technology from the control of the few and recreate the spirit of freedom, innovation, and self-reliance that underpinned the American tech industry only a few decades ago. Our principles are here: https://futo.org/what-is-futo

FUBS is our self-hosted programming system (including it's own programming language) that practices radical incompatibility with the existing software stack: https://gitlab.futo.org/eron/public/-/wikis/FUBS We are hiring a software engineer to help us develop an overlay network: https://futo.org/jobs/software-engineer-networking and have a general opportunity post for highly independent engineers: https://futo.org/jobs/senior-software-engineer-general-oppor...

FUTO is also hiring for hourly engineering roles on the revolutionary cross-platform video streaming app Grayjay https://grayjay.app/

Recommendation Engine Developer - Grayjay aims to introduce a feature that recommends creators/videos to users based on their interests. The initial task involves developing an algorithm to tag channels in a way that correlates them with similar channels. https://futo.org/jobs/recommendation-engine-developer-grayja...

FCast Developer - We seek to create an open source casting protocol for wide adoption. Some work has already been done (see https://fcast.org/). You can help bring FCast to a wide developer audience by making libraries for multiple languages and are interested in bringing FCast to new platforms (Roku, AppleTV, TizenOS, WebOS, …). https://futo.org/jobs/fcast-developer-grayjay

To apply, send your resume and cover letter to jobs at futo dot org with the subject of the position you're interested in.

That advice makes sense if we're talking about 800B+ parameter models that require a gigantic investment of capital and time. For models that fit on a consumer GPU you're leaving chips on the table to not take advantage of training / fine-tuning. It's just too easy and powerful not to.

"Build, don't train" is poor advice for a prospective "AI Engineer" title. It should be "Know when to reach for a new model architecture, know when to reach for fine-tuning / LoRA training, know when to use an API." Only relying on an API will drastically reduce your product differentiation, to say nothing of the fact that any AI Engineer worth that title should know how to build and train models.

The article's thesis is that EA's moral realism stance (which finds it's apotheosis in utilitarian moral calculus) is ill-supported and highly questionable, especially when combined with theological anti-realism.

It's definitely not written to win over any EA supporter, that's for sure.

Do you love? Do you dance? Do you desire? Do you rage? Do you weep? Do you choose? Every moment of your existence you exert your will on the world.

A denial of will is a denial of humanity. I want nothing of a science that would do such a thing.

Certainly we can say our ML models are becoming more general in the sense of being able to cross-correlate between multiple domains. This is quite a different story than "becoming a general intelligence." Intelligence is a property of a being with will. These models, and machines in general, do not posses will. It is we who define their form, their dataset, their loss function, etc. There is no self-generation that marks an intelligent being because there is no self there at all.

It is only the case that ML expands our own abilities, augments our own intelligence.

Harm is done to the ecosystem when we concentrate cows in one place and feed them chemically fortified slurry. When cows are allowed to graze pastures, they instead have a positive effect on the local ecosystem.

As such, I am extremely skeptical that the right way forward is to reduce and concentrate the essence of a cow into bioreactors and feed them chemically fortified slurry.

Alternative reading of the same information: "US monitors border using novel technology."

Nations have the right to restrict entry, which entails checking if someone is coming in. That's not hunting.

I must admit I was hoping for much more controversial ideas than what Volume 1 contained. There are plenty of well-argued dissident ideas online, these articles take only a small tentative step outside the mainstream.

Notably missing Doomer Optimists who accept the reality and inevitability of collapse, while viewing it as an opportunity for localist, agrarian communities to rise in the wake.

His book Green Wizardry contains by far the best description of matter, information, and energy I've found in any work. Ignore outsider perspectives at your own peril.