HN user

JTxt

191 karma
Posts1
Comments118
View on HN

Yes, there's some parametric things you can do in Blender. You can have a beizier curve that you can later change the facet count on... and you can use a spin modifier on a shape, but you're not going to get a perfect tangent line off a perfect circle like you can in a proper CAD tool for example. and you can boolean with another object, are you're not able to add a perfect fillet at that intersection.

In Blender, with care and if you're clever, you can do many of the same things you can with a CAD program... good enough for many cases. But Blender is still more of an artist tool than an engineer tool. For serious uses you're going to run into the limits.

There are free cad parametric modelers. FreeCAD is one.

You can use Blender for some CAD work... But it's not a solid modeler like solidworks/inventor. It doesn't have many of the precision and parametric tools.

Blender's internal representation of objects is vertices (defined with IEEE single precision floats) connected by lines, and faces --just the shell of the object, and no real curved surfaces (just more and more faceted to approximate curves, and smoothed normals to look curved.) It also does not have guaranteed precise measurements. Blender can do some parametric and Boolean operations and many of the same things, but sometimes it fails and the limitations get in the way.

Some have built CAD tools into Blender, but it's a hack on an artist's tool. For some types of CAD projects, it'll do great, particularly in some very creative directions, but I'd start with the other tools you mentioned.

I export Inventor models to Blender for better rendering and animation.

It still has the powerful tiling window system. There's no overlapping windows so you don't close windows, you combine and subdivide windows to make the tool layout you want.

But now there's Tabs for different default window setups: Layout, modeling, Sculpting, UV Editing... So you shouldn't have to change the setups much, they're already designed for the task. You can can still customize/ create your own. That feature was already there as a drop down but now it's more accessible and you can add more default layouts.

UV editing has a tab at the top now. There's a few things to keep track of to be successful with this tool and hook up with materials, but I don't think the difficulty is much different then similarly powerful tools. There's youtube tutorials that will walk you though it.

Yes, Eevee is a fast pbr renderer and can give very similar results to cycles with no effort, except there's some setup needed to do indirect lighting and reflections... and some tweaking needed for good lamp shadows in some cases, but the payoff is huge. I have a high resolution render that takes 12 minutes in cycles, 30 seconds in eevee with no grain... some features are not there line a shader bevel, but otherwise very similar, and there's workarounds for that.

Exactly I wanted to hear doom soundtrack music but "doom" did not work.

https://bitmidi.com/search?q=doom

I had to dig more to remember the level format and search for https://bitmidi.com/search?q=E1m4

Perhaps a crawler can find the identical file (checksum/md5) and collect meta data: alternate filenames, urls, zip archive names... It was next to this file in this list/zip archive... And in this sub folder name, on this page on this wayback machine link... So associations can be built automatically?

Also for each unique checksum with listed alternate file names, Perhaps user content: ratings, similar files, comments... A wiki like page where the automaticly generated meta data can be vetted... Oh and suggested sound font and other settings to play that particular file maybe.

Fun challenge!

BTW https://bitmidi.com/search?q=E1m1 crashes it for me.

It's cool you can drag a file on it to play. Except on mobile, so perhaps the ability to play from url.

Awesome work, thanks! Looking forward to seeing where this goes.

Why Python? (Why code?)

-What do you want to make with it? Who will that effect? How?

Why browse?

-How many LOC have you written in the past week on something you want to make? (...or that would get you close to something you want to make?)

Why force yourself?

Why just learn?

...

What do you do instead?

If you continued, what would your life be like in 5 years?

Would the people previously mentioned be missing out?

Would that be a bad thing?

I'm voting up all the https://scratch.mit.edu suggestions. I was active in that community and with the developers early on. I wish I had it when I was little.

You can browse projects with the 5 year old then view the source and figure out how they work. Show that they can change things.

It's awesome that you want to promote creation over just consuming content like most of their peers.

Scratch your own itch with it too. Make a 3d renderer or CRUD app, fractal explorer, or game... they might like to see what can be made and what excites you.

They may get into the story and animation projects made by other kids first, that's good too.

Right, I remember advanced 3d software fitting on a floppy. But now a simple Android app can be over 50mb.

No you don't need a video on your login screen.

TIL: the optical mouse works by taking a picture of the desk surface and does Optical Flow with the previous capture to get relative position.

The result reminded me of the old Logitech Scanman handheld scanner. except that had a 1d light sensor (like a flatbed scanner) and a radial encoder attached a to a roller to advance the scan lines down and the user pulled it down. (kind of like a 1d mechanical mouse.) I had a ton of fun with that growing up.

Nice. For dates we'd go to a library or book store, take random books and dramatically read the first, middle, and last lines. And speculate on the rest and/or make fun of it.

Impressive! I think a "Lathe" tool could be made from your "Draw" shape tool fairly easily.

Interesting problems you have... Balancing flexibility/power/precision and simplicity/low learning curve/finger input.

I'd be tempted to go more the flexibility route... but what is essential? for who? Where's the line drawn for "dead simple"?

Would precision for the "drafters" slow down/confuse the "doodlers"?... Could build flexibility underneath and carefully build an advanced UX that people can graduate to, but at what costs?... At what point is the focus lost?

I took a picture of my finished Styrofoam hot chocolate cup and straw. Hot chocolate was the first guess. It gave an option for "from mix water added", done. Very cool. Edit: just logged my coworker's lunch in about a minute: Cucumber, grill cheese sandwich in one picture, it let me add them from a list. Ramen soup took another try at a lower angle.

Discoverability? It's much better than VIM's at least. (That used to not be the case.)

Most features can be found in Menus. Every clickable UI element has a tool tip if you hover.

With your mouse over the 3d port, hit the spacebar and fuzzy search for commands.

Most times there's a menu option there's a hotkey listed to the right... or you can right click a menu item and "Assign hot key."

You can also right click things and click "Online Documentation" for documentation on it.

Granted, I don't see an easy way to discover that "TAB" is for switching between edit and world mode when an object is selected... though you can switch modes in the "Object Mode" drop down 3d port menu. there's not a tool tip for it. ...and probably other things. It would be helpful if a better getting started guide/beginner walk through (like this introduction.) could be found in the splash screen and help menu easier.

It looks like a start to a remake of the visualization plugin for Winamp, Milkdrop2. Apparently opensource now.

https://sourceforge.net/projects/milkdrop2/

There's many many presets/scripts made for it.

http://ghostco.de/milkdrop_pack/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zdL_JSsY6qo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VoshHRG1Qbk

I see someone started to port it to the web: https://github.com/gattis/milkshake (though it did not work for me in chrome.)

Edit: here's one that works, you can edit the presets:

https://butterchurnviz.com/