HN user

Gerard0

96 karma

meet.hn/city/de-Leipzig

Interests: Psychoanalysis, Cycling, Books, Open Source, Philosophy, Writing, Music.

Posts2
Comments62
View on HN

I am sold! I will definitely get Hopkins’ book. It sounds amazing. I read about his life on Wikipedia: What a life story and unfortunate end. Thank a ton for the elaborated reply and the recommendation.

About Langs: It is really unbelievable how many thinkers/ideas have been buried because they were uncomfortable or because someone with power or authority basically just erased/canceled them. This haunts me a bit nowadays and I try to stay alert.

For example, I still agree with many of the ideas, practices or theories of my first years among lacanians and psychoanalysis in general. But there’s also many things which I see totally different now. Not only because I kept learning, reading and so on: many ideas were just being smashed or repeated. Some authors were just banned with some obscure mention or some story and that was it.

Since a couple of years I have been reading mainly Spanish texts or translated into Spanish from French. Perhaps Darian Leader is the only exception. Great British psychoanalyst! I really like his books. He does have an introduction to Lacan (comic hah). I know Bruce Fink is quite popular and I have heard and read bits and pieces which have been good. But I haven’t read one of his books and if I am not mistaken he has an introductory book.

Around 2021 I joined an online seminar with an Argentinian guy: Bruno Bonoris. His ideas really, really helped me. He published a book on 2022 and I found it very clarifying. It is not an introduction to lacanianism but it goes through many of Lacan’s ideas. Some are praised, some are criticized, some are clarified (mainly regarding to how other lacanian schools use this or that concept). It also does this with many of Freud’s ideas and some post-Freudians. Not author by author but regarding some concepts.

I was struggling with some ideas and his book, together with his Seminar, really changed everything for me. It helped me put some things together, connect some ideas and it put words on things I had the feeling were a bit off or weird (but had learned (and repeated?) from my first analyst for example or first seminars).

The book is called “Qué hace un psicoanalista? Sobre los problemas técnicos”. Do you happen to read Spanish? Even if you don’t, I translated with AI from chapters into German in order to share them with my girlfriend and I was surprised with the results (haha sorry, it was my first time translating something so long and about psychoanalysis). Maybe you could try this or does the idea give you the chills?

It might be a quite weird recommendation but it might also be a good one depending on where your interests lie.

I am not sure if other fields are the same, but I have found this one hard to navigate! Reminds me of the words of a lacanian analyst at the beginning of a IPA conference he was invited to: “There are only two things all psychoanalytic schools agree on: 1. That Freud is the founder of psychoanalysis. 2. That if the analysand doesn’t show up to his session, the person will have to pay for it anyway.”

And yes, as you know, psychoanalysis is not really popular on here! But tell me, how come you are so involved? Is this a new interest, an old interest now being taken upon again or…?

I never heard of Robert Langs nor Masud Khan before, thanks!

Let me appropriate something I heard Jean Allouch (fantastic guy, died some 2 years ago) say:

"What interests me is madness and the way of welcoming it, which is called psychoanalysis."

I used to say I practice lacanian psychoanalysis, but more and more (thanks to exchange with colleagues, seminars and so on) I have been trying to expand my knowledge.

Just like you discovered, there are so many great ideas and authors which were simply forgotten. It's a tough path to walk!

Damn! I have been reading about Amusing Ourselves to Death on here since weeks and I assumed it was a new book from a contemporary author! I'll get it now, thanks for being the one who finally got me to :)

It is definitely not easy. Specially because you cannot "see" their past work or results except from someone telling you about it. I practice psychoanalysis (lacanian if you gotta give it a name) and really liked your wording: "finding someone a bit more invested into figuring things out". Feel free to hit me up (gerhn cupipo com) if interested in starting an analysis (or anyone reading this). We can have up to 4 sessions which you won't have to pay for unless you think we are up to something and decide to continue.

Talk, talk, talk.

I did a mix of talking together with some basic grammar.

Right now I am super fluent in German but still make mistakes. Just the damn articles are a pain.

When I hear someone speaking Spanish, my native language, and says a 10 word sentence, everything correct except of an article, I immediately think "oh shit, that's how I sound in German!", haha. Because even if almost everything was perfect, it sounds off.

I could have written these words in German but it would have been much harder. As I said, I am much more fluent in German than in English although my English is waaay better. I can read a book and write things down; in German? Hard :o

Motivation is really important. I work at Lieferando/Takeaway (courier with the bigass ugly backpack) and I am in charge of showing the workflow to the new hires.

It doesn't stop to amaze me how many Syrians who fled the war can speak soooo good. There's all kind of cases.

Half of the people hate the country, complain about it and hate the language. So many of them have been here for 5-10 years and their German sucks or just basically doesn't exist.

No easy answer but you really have to like the thing and try to talk. Retrieval, retrieval!