HN user

Boulth

1,680 karma
Posts15
Comments536
View on HN

the monetisation strategy for New Vector is selling Matrix hosting (https://modular.im) and helping out big folks like Governments who want to jump on board Matrix. While the company is certainly not profitable yet, it certainly has a path to being sustainable (otherwise folks like Automattic wouldn't invest!)

Thanks for this info! Exactly what I was looking for.

Nope, worse is that investors subtly want to extract value from them e.g. utilizing user data from identity server on vector.im or so.

Even if they just "went Keybase" not having people outside of the org working on it would slowly bring them the XMPP fate (irrelevance).

Very cool. If you liked that check out their Sorcery series of games. I played them over and over for weeks. Highly addictive!

Matrix allows you to host your own server, federate messages in real-time between servers, and still benefit from end-to-end encryption between multiple client devices.

This sounds like XMPP so nothing new.

What sets the Matrix apart is that they have the money and spend time and effort to get their clients into good shape. The E2E verification is a prime example: looks simple and works well.

VC money mixed with open source software again. It didn't end well for Keybase. I hope Matrix has a monetization strategy.

Edit: for people interested there are company docs at https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/10873661/filing-h... eg. "25 Mar 2020 Total exemption full accounts" document (2.2) shows a yearly loss of almost 2M pounds.

Edit 2: it seems Matrix people no longer control 50% of their company shares, or I'm reading it wrong: https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/10873661/persons-...

Yes, totally. I've also migrated to Linux after decades of working on Windows.

Still, it's interesting development (nope, I won't be coming back).

I worked on Windows for two decades and tried WSL1. Windows is not super annoying but as a developer all my tools were actually Linux native or cross platform so one day I just cut the middle man and switched to Linux. It wasn't such a big leap but my productivity definitely increased.

WSL is nice when you don't have choice. Linux is actually the optimum choice for most developers.

It's not a big problem because tokens lock themselves after 3 tries so even if someone got your token they'd have to guess it. Having separate subkeys for each token is nice but works best only with the signature subkey. For encryption it doesn't work as GnuPG encrypts only to one subkey. The same with authentication subkey: it doesn't matter if you revoke it because SSH doesn't understand OpenPGP revocations.

I think you confused this with security.txt standard. WKD is not enumerable (unless explicitly configured like that) so the issue doesn't exist.

Is there a setting that allows that "push to allow" for a short while?

Yes there is. In a newer firmware.

2) when I ssh into a system and touch the button to allow it, and the push allowed the use of they key for a short while, am I not in the same problem as before - as the system may be compromised and may be performing other operations I'm unawares of?

Yes but the window of opportunity for the attacker is smaller. Also: it's your setup that requires multiple key operations within short time interval, for some people touching every time is sufficient and most secure.

I think the proper solution would be 1) don't use forwarding unless necessary 2) setup touch-to-use on a Yubikey so even with your scenario the attacker couldn't just use the key (it requires touch to be used).

Mailvelope 6 years ago

Yeah maybe it should be more obvious but Mailvelope just adds end to end encryption to existing webmails (through extension overlay).

Firefox 72.0 7 years ago

From the property name it sounds like your property is about trust roots (CAs) and parent's about client certificates (for mutual TLS authentication).