Ask HN: Joke on CV?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9726353

by haack • 11 years ago

4 13 11 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I've just updated my CV (with thanks to some awesome feedback from HNer's) and added "Crushing it since 1993", in reference to HBO's Silicon Valley. Will startups and trendy big techs appreciate this? Or is this just a bad idea?

The CV: https://www.dropbox.com/s/41n6g530impvhni/CV_v2.7.pdf?dl=0

vonklaus• 11 years ago

1993 - Present

Self

Crushing It.

andrewmcwatters• 11 years ago

I think it's hilarious and not a big deal.

visakanv• 11 years ago

If they like you, this won't stop them from hiring you.

If they don't like you, this won't get them to hire you.

So non-issue, really. Enjoy yourself.

j3_d1• 11 years ago

Just my opinion but even if I wanted somebody with a good sense of humour, if they can't be serious at the appropriate time I'd write them off. I'd say no. But good luck & you know your audience better so try it, you can always change it :)

eshvk• 11 years ago

Is there a reason you keep emphasizing your age? 22 and the "Crushing it since 1993" thing?

ch215• 11 years ago

My 2p worth: if there's a chance, however slim, that it won't go down well then I'd say leave it out. It's not worth the risk of some grouch binning your CV, which looks great by the way. All the best.

pestaa• 11 years ago

I think it is perfectly fine. Not pushing but adds a little human touch.

EDIT: Apparently, it doesn't mean you've been programming since '93, but notes the year you were born. Then it's just plain silly.

DanBC• 11 years ago

It's probably a bad idea. Your CV is a piece of professional communication. You probably want to keep it formal as much as possible.

You also don't have "a CV"; you have a template that you adjust as required for each company. Some places may like "crushing it", so add it for them.

Remember that some companies have a vicious pre-filter. You misaddressed the envelope? Bin. Used "sincerely" instead of "faithfully"? Bin.

(But please do test this and write a blog post with the results!)

EDIT: your age is irrelevant information in the UK. By law they are not allowed to consider it so you should not have it on your cv.

bbcbasic2• 11 years ago

Used "sincerely" instead of "faithfully"? Bin.

Unless you named the recipient.

I prefer "yours hopefully" for job applications.

partisan• 11 years ago

I am starting the process of hiring now and a resume with that particular phrase would leave a really bad first impression.

It might not put you out of the running altogether, but I would see you in a different light: as someone who is not entirely serious and is still in the post college party phase, will come to work late or skip altogether, will leave the position within a short period of time to chase the next shiny ball, etc.

That might not stop me from hiring you, but then I would wait to see if my intuition is correct, if you are in any way different from what I expected, etc. That would determine how much I will invest in you as an employee.

So you see, it won't prevent you from being hired, but it will change the way I perceive you as a candidate and future employee.

zbuf• 11 years ago

I've no idea what you're on about, so for me it would just make you seem a little odd (sorry) -- and an overall negative impression.

You have to explain the reference in the question too, so I think you get that. After all, the best jokes are the ones that need explaining, right?!

bbcbasic2• 11 years ago

Bad idea IMO. To me that particular phrase is quite meaningless (like rockstar, unicorn, *10 programmer etc.) and arrogant sounding at the same time.

Might as well say "I'm the dog's bollocks"

If 1993 is your year of birth then it is even worse!

Esox• 11 years ago

I've done a bit of hiring and, to add to what others have said, I would leave it out. I have had some CVs cross my desk in which the author had taken some liberties with more casual phrasing and they were generally poorly received by the entire interview team.

To be honest, it doesn't really add anything of value and you're banking on someone understanding the reference (I didn't at first) and getting a laugh out of it.

For the small amount of value it could add you're taking too much of a risk of evoking a negative reaction.

Ask HN: Joke on CV?

Related Stories