Ask HN: Help me make a decision

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8908502

by newmie • 12 years ago

4 18 12 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

$125K (incl. bonus, stock) - company A

$150K (base, stock options based on performance) - company B

company A is a large well respected hightech company (~200B market cap)

company B is a growing, recognizable but not a well recognized or popular, low employee satisfaction hightech company (~2B market cap)

similar job profile for both

growth is mostly self driven but maybe more challenging in B due to culture

company culture - A has significant advantage over B

which would you accept?

a3voices• 12 years ago

Company B for sure! So I could pay off my mortgage faster :-).

newmie7• 12 years ago

what about long term career prospects? Having A on resume is a huge+

mark212• 12 years ago

Company A, without a doubt. Culture matters a whole lot. And the experience of seeing how one of the behemoths does it from the inside, good and bad, is valuable. (Don't have any info about your job history; this last point could be less important if you've already had that experience.)

newmie7• 12 years ago

yes, this is what is drawing me to A. But it also involves 75% travel compared to 20-25% at B.

EDIT: I typed 7% earlier instead of 75

atrust4• 12 years ago

Company B. I believe there are more opportunities in future.

newmie7• 12 years ago

true, but swimming against the tide can either pay off really well or bite you really hard

atrust4• 12 years ago

You can always quit and find another job. Not a big deal nowadays.

atrust4• 12 years ago

It also depends on what you really want. Make a list of pros/cons and then go from there. Think hard where you see yourself in the future. Go with the company, which can help you to get there.

atrust4• 12 years ago

One important thing I would also add here. Think about your daily work in both companies: how valuable it is, how does it impact the company in general.

Right now I work in a huge corporation. The work I do is not THAT important. I mean, it's important, but if I ever decide to leave, that will not affect the company a lot. They will find another engineer and that's it. Such model is good for business, I guess. But, it's important that every employee feel how valuable they are. Not just feel, they should exactly know, that the work they do does really-really matter to a company. This is just imho.

hashtag• 12 years ago

Company A. I value personal growth and happiness over pay differences. And it seems like Company A will help me more base on what vague information is provided.

europa• 12 years ago

Take B. Keep looking for a position at company like A or better and pays better or equal to B.

gyardley• 12 years ago

The travel you mention in the thread is more significant than anything else you've talked about in the post.

A job with 75% travel basically puts the rest of your life on hold - significant other, relationships with friends, etc. It's harder to stick to proper fitness and diet when traveling so much. You've got to deal with all that travel-related stress (ugh, airports). And business travel tends to get old and boring really, really fast.

Given all that, company B is the winner - although personally, I wouldn't take that job either. Even 25% work-related travel is a pain in the ass.

newmie7• 12 years ago

Agree on the travel part. I am fine with 25% travel. I think its a good balance. Plus, if you want to climb the leadership/management ladder, cant escape travel much.

argonaut• 12 years ago

Your wording is a bit unclear. Are you saying B would challenge you more, or that personal growth would be challenging to attain at B? Are you saying that B's base = 150k and that your stock goes on top, or that base + your estimate of how many stock options you'd get = 150k?

Another important factor that's often not considered is how long your commute is to A and B.

newmie7• 12 years ago

personal growth would be challenging to attain at B because the culture is sure to throw hurdles in the way.

B = 150K base + options (not yet awarded)

commute is not an issue in this case. thanks for bringing it up though

iamjoday• 12 years ago

It appears very hypothetical situation...but for a given data, I can always almost say that Company A will NEVER pay less in total package than Company B for the same job role (assuming its the same as you have not provided any data for it...)

It's like saying... Faecbook will pay less than Zynga for an in demand SE. They will surely match offer of Company B if they want you.

2. Culture is extremely important not just to grow but to work every day and leave home satisfied.

3. Travel is personal choice.

Best of Luck! Nash, http://joday.com

newmie7• 12 years ago

I assure you its not hypothetical.

You would be wrong to assume large companies beat every other offer. Large companies rarely beat other offers. Even Google does not do it unless you are a rock star.

Also I never pitched them against each other ... I dont see that as a professional behavior, I negotiate separately. But I agree I did not do a good job of negotiating with A, maybe I was starstruck

Ask HN: Help me make a decision

Related Stories