Does a national health care plan make people more likely to start a company?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=764255

by yequalsx • 17 years ago

3 7 17 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

Some years ago I had an idea for a startup but didn't want to go without health insurance. I have a good job and I felt the risk of getting sick or injured without health care insurance outweighed the likely gains from starting a company.

ErrantX2• 17 years ago

Living in the UK I can say it is a big bonus having to not worry about healthcare in any aspect of life: because you know if something goes wrong your guaranteed care.

With that said it isn't FREE: there are taxes and so forth though I believe private US health insurance (like you would be purchasing) is anything from 2-5 times more expensive (my NI contribution on a £33K salary is £130 a month - of which a percentage goes to healthcare - I estimate around £80).

However one big advantage IMO is that the National Insurance Tax is recovered in a standard way by the tax man and there is no tiers or anything - it just covers everything - meaning less stress finding a good deal and ensuring you have adequate deals (I know just ensuring my car is a pain in the bum :) I cant imagine medical!)

The crux being: I dont think it's quite possible to claim it would encourage more startups. But I suspect it would remove another hurdle from any other prospective startups.

yequalsx• 17 years ago

Thanks for the perspective from a national health care country.

I've come to the belief that the lack of universal care in the U.S. keeps workers from being less mobile and from taking risks.

ErrantX2• 17 years ago

Agreed. Take today for example. Dental care is also available subsidized on the NHS (as in were all entitled to cheap or free dental though it is quite common to go private).

Today I am about 150 miles away from home in city Ive not been to before and my tooth filling collapsed. I went to a random dentist this morning and he saw me within 10 minutes (the time it took to request my medical history from NHS records) and my tooth is now fine! There was no questions about insurance, cost or whatever it's all just simple :D

einarvollset• 17 years ago

Yes.

abalashov• 17 years ago

It might encourage, but I don't think its absence materially discourages.

known• 17 years ago

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexicurity FTW

obxerve• 17 years ago

Generally, I would think so. Not so much from the perspective of "risk taking" as other commenter mentioned but more so from administrative effort and business cost / break even analysis.

"Risk taking" is, in my opinion, relatively independent of cost or administrative overhead. Some people would simply not start up any company even when the break even analysis is good. Whereas others would jump on a given opportunity, taking the risk that he / she can do better than the break even analysis.

Does a national health care plan make people more likely to start a company?

Related Stories