Ask HN: Does PHP drives you crazy?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=643667

by zyb09 • 17 years ago

5 9 17 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

So for the last 3 years I've been busy switching back and forth between C#/Java/C++ and latly I've been working on an Webapp in PHP.

I find doing things in PHP is absolutly tendious, yeah of course everything is easy as shit, but the inconsisticies and the way it's documented really makes my brain bleed. .. and where the hell is my little rudimentary debugger?

Don't know if there is some higher level programming style to PHP, but what do you guys think?

noodle• 17 years ago

re: driving me crazy -- nope.

re: documentation -- a little annoying, but i've seen worse.

re: debugger -- http://xdebug.org/

re: higher level programming -- are you using a framework?

jawngee2• 17 years ago

I think if PHP is driving you crazy, you're doing it wrong.

Get a good framework (Recess is the most promising, CodeIgniter is fairly sane).

jrockway2• 17 years ago

I think if PHP isn't driving you crazy, you're doing it wrong. The only way to win is to not play.

The frameworks you suggest don't work around any of PHP's language inadequacies, they only work around its inability to easily write web applications. Once your HTTP requests is parsed, you still have to do something, and that's what PHP makes hard.

jawngee2• 17 years ago

Dude if PHP is hard for you then you have a serious brain deficit.

Nobody said anything about better languages, I don't think anyone would argue that point at all, so why you constantly feel the need to interject it in all of your criticisms of PHP, I'm not exactly sure.

jrockway2• 17 years ago

Yes, PHP is bad. I ranted about this in the past:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=579250

(To make a long story short, PHP makes all of the same mistakes as Java with respect to OO, but doesn't have the workarounds that Java does.)

trickjarrett• 17 years ago

Joy of joys, another language rant.

raganwald• 17 years ago

What do I think? Honestly?? Meta-answer: The choice to conduct a poll to ask what HN members think of PHP is not the best wayto move forward.

Is this actionable? Why are you asking whether PHP drives us crazy, as opposed to a question like "Which language/framework should I use for building a Webapp in my spare time?" What do you plan to do with our answer?

If you are just shooting the breeze here, write a blog post! If you are going to make a concrete decision, tell us what it is so that we can give you realistic advice.

Second, polls are ridiculously biased, especially with the question you asked. Your question presumes we use PHP, it drives us crazy, and we keep using it! Do you think anyone who doesn't use PHP will say "No PHP doesn't drive me crazy because I build webapps in Erlang?"

Are you looking for PHP delelopers to tell you that they aren't crazy and to suggest why? The question is remarkably unclear.

My personal advice is to decide what decision you're trying to make and then do some research. Are you thinking of switching away from PHP? Looking for libraries/tips to make it saner? Or what? When you figure out what you want to do it should be simple to use the Internet to get answers.

zyb09• 17 years ago

I don't wanna poll anybody, sorry if there was a misunderstandig. I'm not trying to build some Webapp in my spare time here. I've written now tons of PHP in the last 3-4 weeks on an internal project and it's pretty much running and functional by now. Definitely not in a phase we're I wanna switch frameworks or something.

Somehow though, lots of stuff you do in PHP doesn't quite feel right and you constantly get the feeling that anything can break at anytime. If you're mixing in jquery and doing lots of ajax requests, you're just cross-calling functions anywhere around some loosely tied together code. When you even have to think hard about what kind of scope your variables & code are living in, it seems hard to get solid sturucture in PHP. So I was just wondering if that happens to everybody, that dares to touch this language :>

mixmax• 17 years ago

Well it seems to be very fashionable to bash PHP these days, but you know what? It works, and it works well. It scales well, some of the webs largest sites are programmed in PHP, it's free, it has loads of libraries, it's mature, you can always find help and free code on the net, and PHP.net has the best documentation I've seen for a programming language.

Sure there are issues with it, just like there are issues with everything else. But I can't help noticing that people who program in PHP tend to just get things done instead of complaining about how they can't get anything done in a language that doesn't even have semi-enclosed nomads with closured scaffolding on the IO stack.

Ask HN: Does PHP drives you crazy?

Related Stories