When someone blocks ad's what really happens?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4773801

by idealform01 • 14 years ago

3 4 14 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

If I have an ad blocker, does the website selling as space or the advertiser know? Page views are usually what is used to charge for ads so if I visit the page and the ad is blocked via my browser, it seems to me that people are still paying for ad's that do not reach the user.

Am I missing something?

jameswyse• 14 years ago

I've noticed a few websites begging me to turn off adblock, I'm not sure how they detected it though. I think adblock removes the ads entirely from the DOM so perhaps they're just checking if their elements still exist with some JavaScript.

lumberjack• 14 years ago

I'd imagine that you can create a script that would run always that alerts the provider that the user is blocking ads. Then to eliminate false positives you inject some code in your ad script that disables the other script from running. That's probably just one of many possible approaches.

unsquare• 14 years ago

If the Publisher ( Website Owner ) is selling directly ( No Middle Men / Network ) to the Advertiser and hes transparent , he will use a way to track "real" impressions. Ads that aren't shown to the visitors won't count. ( This is only for CPM based ads ) Publishers know that people use adblocker and can easily detect it , it's not uncommon to replace the blocked ads by an internal image / message asking you to disable it on their website.

But yes , if you buy advertising on some websites , you may pay for impressions that never happened.

Feel free to ask more questions on the subject.

fsethi• 14 years ago

From my experience, the ad blocker is actually blocking the ad coming from the incoming server, so no impression is counted.

If you are using something that replaces the ad with another image (Add-Art for example), the underlying ad is likely being served.

The latter is good for the publisher, good for the user, not so good for the ad network or the brand / utility purchasing the ad space.

When someone blocks ad's what really happens?

Related Stories