Ask HN: How to track real people impressions? Not bots.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4593968

by skennedy • 14 years ago

4 4 14 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

User agents, IP addresses, and browsers loading javascript are all methods I've heard of to measure whether an impression is a real person. Is there a checklist, good guide for lessons learned, or a toolkit out there you would recommend?

JoachimSchipper2• 14 years ago

Is there a reason you cannot just outsource this problem to AWstats/Webalizer/Google Analytics/etc? It's a hard problem, and those packages have done quite a bit of work to solve it.

(From experience, switching from - IIRC - AWstats to Webalizer reduces your traffic by a lot, as the latter's robot detection algorithm catches more robots. IIRC - it's possible that it's the other way round...)`

skennedy• 14 years ago

Unfortunately, I need a solution that can track metrics for each individual customer and display results to them. Not an overall site tool.

JoachimSchipper2• 14 years ago

grep "^/$CUSTOMER" access_log | awstats?

ColinWright• 14 years ago

Just a suggestion: If you want to post the same question again, don't post the same question. Ask what you really want, and explain why existing tools don't meet your needs. Make it clear that you've investigated existing offerings, and share your findings.

Ask HN: How to track real people impressions? Not bots.

Related Stories