Ask HN: Does listening to music keep you focused?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4316581

by adambenayoun • 14 years ago

4 20 14 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I've read an article about the new trend in the Olympic games is that swimmers are walking out to the pool wearing headphones - and keeping them on right up until the last seconds before they climb onto the blocks.

It seems that music keep them concentrated up until the last minute when they jump onto the pool and it allows them to not be distracted by the crowd.

I am now curious what kind of music you guys are listening to in order to stay focus and increase your concentration.

Anyone?

allstruck• 14 years ago

I have a "motivation" playlist on Spotify, the songs either have lyrics which are either motivating or non-existent. I find while coding or writing that lyrics can get in the way too so I have some playlists which are focused on purely lyric-free songs...

lazyjones• 14 years ago

Usually oldschool techno/house music ... but nowdays I find myself being distracted too much by things on the screen (curse this 27" display...) so I should probably consider using blinders.

dsirijus4• 14 years ago

Some funk or disco (Sly and the Family Stone) in the morning to start the engines, some non-vocal groove (Medeski, Martin & Wood) throughout the day, and some energetic rock (Queen) to draw out extra juice by the end of the day.

When going gets tough, some really loud noise (Mike Patton).

When I learn something new intensively, some baroque polyphony or nothing.

Of course, the music I really care about I don't listen while I'm working.

adambenayoun2• 14 years ago

Thanks for sharing this

dsirijus4• 14 years ago

It's about controlling your emotional response (not dynamics really), which music does great. And you have the ability to control what you listen to. Conclusion is self-evident.

kellros• 14 years ago

Music in itself is distracting - especially if you love certain music and dislike doing work - then you will focus on what you love.

Music will only help you concentrate if the music is about the very thing you want to be concentrating on.

Perhaps they are listening to some variation of "SWIM SWIM SWIM".

dsirijus4• 14 years ago

I've found silenced office much more distracting than one filled with some tunes or radio.

You might recall the article about anacoustic chamber here on HN - the very silence of it made you brain perceive otherwise imperceptible sounds much louder.

dsirijus4• 14 years ago

About the olympics guys listening to music right up to climbing on blocks....

It might be that they need to maintain a particular rhythm in swimming, and they're just playing the song which happens to be or is artificially made to be that exact target ideal beat.

Might even be that there's no music in there, just the beat.

adambenayoun2• 14 years ago

Interesting take - I've read that their fans are unpleased with this trend. Also - I'm wondering if Sun Yang who got had a Dr. DRE headphone received money to endorse this product.

penguat• 14 years ago

I find it helps when there are loud conversations going on. I am normally more inclined to listen to the conversations than focus on my work. Other than that, it can be distracting.

I'm quite a fan of http://musicforprogramming.net/

Paul_S• 14 years ago

This is just noise. You might as well use actual white noise at this point. Different strokes I guess.

munimkazia• 14 years ago

Depends on the kind of work. For more trivial tasks, music helps in concentration. Otherwise, it is distracting.

jpswade• 14 years ago

plusfm helps me get "into the zone"

http://www.plusfm.net/

renas• 14 years ago

Yep it does! No doubts about that.

Of course you should not shield yourself from healthy office talks :-D

why-el• 14 years ago

I stay focused with pretty much anything in my ears. Sometimes I even listen to very thoughtful discussions while coding, like an interview with the maker of The Wire for instance :) It won't work for most people, but it does for me.

With this said, music is the most effective, and I am currently rocking it with the lastest album by Passion Pit called Gossamer (available on Spotify US).

eshvk• 14 years ago

I usually listen to Post Rock (e.g. Explosions in the sky) when I write code. It is mostly (99%) instrumental and that helps me avoid voices of any kind. Also, invest in really good headphones/earphones. That helps block out sound of any kind.

AznHisoka• 14 years ago

I tend to listen to anything with no lyrics, or at least things I can't understand like foreign music. Otherwise it is distracting.

imp• 14 years ago

Well, part of the reason the swimmers are wearing headphones is that they got them free: http://www.billboard.biz/bbbiz/industry/branding/beats-by-dr...

yolesaber• 14 years ago

Bop jazz (e.g. miles and parker, early Coltrane, Monk) really puts me in the Zone. The complexity and intricacy of the music keep my brain going even if I'm stuck on a problem, so I rarely get up from my workstation. I just lean back and close my eyes, letting the cascading melodies wash over my mind. A solo or two later and I'm back on the keyboard.

tokenrove• 14 years ago

I do listen to music sometimes when programming, but it's interesting to note the study cited in DeMarco and Lister's Peopleware (IIRC) where they found programmers (in a ridiculously contrived study) who listened to music produced "less inventive" solutions than those who didn't. I've always taken that as an interesting caveat.

Ask HN: Does listening to music keep you focused?

Related Stories