Math books like Infite Powers or Calculus Made Easy but for other topics?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42999671

by leandot • 1 year ago

13 10 1 year ago

news.ycombinator.com

I recently read the above because I wanted to refresh my calculus skills and they were exactly the level and depth for a busy software engineer. Do you have other examples of foundational math books that are readable for the interested layman, e.g. for linear algebra?

bwb• 1 year ago

This might be a fun one: https://shepherd.com/best-books/textbooks-for-learning-linea...

I interviewed Ivan and he shared five of his fav books on the subject.

ColinWright• 1 year ago

You might consider "An Infinitely Large Napkin"[0]

Previously submitted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42999258

[0] https://venhance.github.io/napkin/Napkin.pdf

a_tartaruga• 1 year ago

This is the best for what it is trying to do

smatija3• 1 year ago

Linear algebra doesn't have many preconditions - so being used to math texts is much more important for it than having some pre-knowledge.

Easiest to start will be either Linear Algebra done right by Axler or Linear algebra done wrong by Treil - try both, they take very different approaches to introducing the subject, so one of them may be compatible with you.

After finishing either of these I heartily recommend you Finite-Dimensional Vector Spaces by Halmos - it's way more abstract, so I cannot recommend it as first introduction to LA, but it proves its results in very beautiful and a bit uncommon way. It's probably my favourite book from undergrad.

smatija3• 1 year ago

The best math book for a software engineer imho is Concrete mathematics by Knuth (of TAOCP fame).

Problems in it are a bit tough to chew through though.

aristofun• 1 year ago

not for software engineer, but rather an algo geek or a hardcore hacker

For a typical application level developer (even super senior one) this book is way too deep and complex.

smatija3• 1 year ago

Here I believe we disagree a bit about what engineer means.

WillAdams• 1 year ago

Possibly too simple for you, but I've been going through the _Make:Geometry/Trigonometry/Calculus_ books which use 3D printed objects and OpenSCAD to teach math concepts:

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/61739368-make

i_don_t_know• 1 year ago

I enjoyed “Introduction to Applied Linear Algebra – Vectors, Matrices, and Least Squares” because it focuses on a relatively few concrete concepts in linear algebra, and explains and motivates them with lots of practical applications.

It’s a free download with additional material at:

https://web.stanford.edu/~boyd/vmls/

impendia• 1 year ago

(Math professor here)

What do you mean by "foundational"?

I love Calculus Made Easy, but in my opinion the reason it's so good is that it doesn't try to be foundational. It relies on quick and dirty tricks -- especially, treating dy/dx as a fraction when it can't be formally defined as such, but where doing so makes the subject much more intuitive and easy. It's not really a good foundation for further study, you need something that doesn't cut corners for that, but it's fantastic for what it is!

My favorite foundational book is Linear Algebra by Jim Hefferon:

https://hefferon.net/linearalgebra/

It is free, and I've seen the author on HN occasionally. It's foundational in the sense that it builds up the subject brick by brick, assuming the minimum realistic prerequisites needed, and it does an outstanding job of this.

But it's a slow read, essentially by design. If you want something quicker, you might try Interactive Linear Algebra by Margalit and Rabinoff:

https://textbooks.math.gatech.edu/ila/

Again free, with lots of widgets to play with.

Some other textbooks I really like:

Epp's Discrete Mathematics is fantastic. The newest edition is astronomically expensive, so go looking for used copies of previous editions.

Carter's Visual Group Theory is tremendous fun. Once again not foundational per se, but if you want to learn what group theory is all about without slogging through lots of formalities, that's a great choice. I'd say that roughly it's in the spirit of Calculus Made Easy.

Also, if you enjoy poker, check out Dan Harrington's books on the subject. In the course of explaining hold'em strategy, they will teach you lots about probability, counting, expected value, and game theory in an applied setting. They're fantastically written.

Math books like Infite Powers or Calculus Made Easy but for other topics?

Related Stories