A Review of MVC

http://mikepackdev.com/blog_posts/34-a-review-of-mvc

by fcoury • 14 years ago

24 5 14 years ago

azza-bazoo• 14 years ago

"a program is without value before it is used by an end user for something valuable"

Nice snippet of advice there. Also the rest of Trygve's original post is an excellent reminder (and in simple terms) of MVC as an idea, rather than MVC as a label to slap on the next bit of JS code you publish on github ... which is basically all the intro paragraph says.

sageikosa• 14 years ago

Pattern not product? I agree.

I do believe that many nouvelle programmers in their rush to absorb and contribute to the art integrate too many things too quickly and try to fabricate the magic recipe they just learned about into a hammer they can pound on everything regardless of whether the particular problem is a nail or not.

alttab• 14 years ago

I would say the same thing about over-using and integrating frameworks. Backbone, NodeJS Mustache and coffee script. For what? If all a programmer has ever done is use frameworks they will never understand tacitly the problem its trying to solve.

I'm a strong advocate for using no framework, then building your own, then and only then introducing a library or framework because they can do it better.

This allows you to understand the pain of its absence, understand how to fundamentally solve the problem through abstraction or organization, and then fully leverage and reap the benefits of a well designed framework.

Some would say you don't need to walk 100 miles to understand the value of a car. But thats from the product side. I would say you need to understand the weaknesses of a car to build the next generation vehicle.

Xurinos• 14 years ago

Here are a couple of the reports:

Including Thing: http://heim.ifi.uio.no/~trygver/1979/mvc-1/1979-05-MVC.pdf

Revision: http://heim.ifi.uio.no/~trygver/1979/mvc-2/1979-12-MVC.pdf

chris_wot• 14 years ago

It's interesting that MVC is mostly introduced to most people as part of a web based architecture. From my understanding of MVC, the view can be updated by the model, and view can update the model. Which makes sense in the context that you have multiple views into the model. This doesn't tend to happen with web based MVC.

A Review of MVC

Related Stories