Ask HN: How do you play synchronized audio across multiple receivers in 2024?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40530646

by metadat • 2 years ago

8 11 2 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I last explored this in 2010, and there weren't any great solutions other than doing it yourself from first principles. Have things changed in 14 years?

I've got two empty pools and a few huge subs laying around...

It's crazy that it's 2024 and there isn't an ESP32 module which does this.

huesatbri• 2 years ago

I’ve had success with Snapcast when looking into this previously https://github.com/badaix/snapcast

metadat2• 2 years ago

Since posting this, I also discovered Balena-sound:

https://github.com/balena-io-experimental/balena-sound

I haven't yet been able to try it yet, but may be an alternative to snapcast.

karmakaze• 2 years ago

If your rooms are ethernet wired, I just found these USB extenders[0] that I was hoping could eliminate audio latency with bluetooth. I don't know if sync would still be a problem though.

[0] https://www.gefen.com/product/usb-2-0-extender/

salawat• 2 years ago

Are we talking one speaker say left speaker, playing sample 0, duration 0-5s, then right speaker playing second sample duration 5-10? Except increase number of speakers to X with physical locations completely unknown or unaccounted for anywhere in the underlying software itself?

Because last I'd heard, and I'm definitely not in the scene, all of that was coordinated by programs, before having the transduction work parceled out to mostly dumb speakers. And even then, I'm not aware as to whether playback software is "smart" enough to train itself w/ regard to latencies between individual playback nodes to ensure things sync up properly... That gets into the nasty world of things like DRAM signal training, because in a sense, each of your signal paths is just a glorified signal trace to the system in question, of unusual length compared to other motherboard traces.

I know there's ASICs built into most graphics cards nowadays for things like audio mix/encode/decode, but as far as I was aware, getting things relatively sync'd up for any non-trivial network of speakers was still very much an exercise left to the student; and with most programmers having taken the route of "but why would you need that?" to avoid answering what is essentially a really, really, hard network characterization/DSP question.

Long story short, I dunno, but sounds like an immersive literature deep dive in the making to me!

tgittos• 2 years ago

I have a bunch of Sonos speakers and hooked them all up to a Mac running Airfoil (https://rogueamoeba.com/airfoil/mac/).

It isn't perfect and audio occasionally de-syncs or a speaker drops out. On a dedicated wireless channel playing a local source I imagine it would be pretty solid.

Not really an option if you don't have a Mac to run Airfoil, though if you do you can use the Satellite (https://rogueamoeba.com/airfoil/satellite/) program to sync Mac your other non-Apple devices to the host.

bcrl• 2 years ago

Install a low power FM transmitted and use old analog radios as receivers. A friend did this at their island cottage.

toomuchtodo• 2 years ago

Can you do this with software defined radios?

solardev• 2 years ago

I think Sonos sued the heck out of Google for doing this with Google Home speakers. They won the jury trial but then a judge invalidated their patents https://www.theverge.com/2023/10/10/23910694/sonos-google-pa...

Probably not an easy thing to do to begin with (there are papers on the algorithms involved, last I checked) and the specter of big audio companies coming after you isn't fun either.

Edit: Despite that, there's https://github.com/geekuillaume/soundsync

metadat2• 2 years ago

Too bad it's gotten no updates for 2+ years, if it worked with Windows, Linux, and Airplay devices that would be quite the perfect trifecta!

jonathan-re• 2 years ago

In the live audio production industry audio over IP with Dante is the industry standard these days.

https://www.getdante.com/products/software-essentials/dante-...

dave78• 2 years ago

I've been using Chromecast Audio devices in my house for something like 8 years now and they work perfectly. Some are just the audio device plugged into powered speakers, some are speakers with Chromecast built in. Unfortunately the CC Audios aren't made anymore but I think you can still use regular Chromecasts (possibly with an HDMI audio extractor if needed).

The sync between devices has always been flawless for me.

Ask HN: How do you play synchronized audio across multiple receivers in 2024?

Related Stories