Ask HN: Does Preapproved Job offer akin Preapproved credit card exist?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40443095

by shnkr • 2 years ago

1 9 2 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

Conditions can be screening round, post background checks on experience with previous employers. No other interview rounds.

If I build a product on this idea, I know every job seeker under the sun would jump in but what about the employers? Does a market exist, can I expect early adopters?

talldayo2• 2 years ago

Sounds to me like you're just describing corporate certificates. Sometimes if you show up to a related job (eg. Cisco Admin with a Cisco cert) you might get to waive the tech interview. You'll have a really hard time getting employers to accept your authority if they've never heard of you though; I doubt anyone would preapprove an employee that has a card from a company nobody knows.

Your best shot (imo) is to find a way to officially certify developers for a demanded tool. Otherwise I don't ever see this idea taking off.

shnkr2• 2 years ago

NO certificate or authority, I'm a nobody.

Take LinkedIn as example, and the messages from recruiters inviting for an interview. Why can't they get the profile checked by hiring managers and send out an offer directly? Once the candidate accepts it, collect the documents and run background checks and deny if there is discrepancy.

talldayo2• 2 years ago

I simply think you're going to have a hard time skipping technical interviews. Every employer will want to see what you're capable of; if they have two candidates and one of them turns down a tech interview, the other candidate is almost certainly getting the job.

dexwiz2• 2 years ago

Something like this wouldn't even be legal in many areas, because employers are limited on the information they can share about employees beyond employment status. That is why referrals are person based and not company based.

Also you assume employees would love it. But what happens when you get blackballed in the system by a bad actor? How do you dispute what prior employers said about you?

shnkr2• 2 years ago

How do you dispute what prior employers said about you?

Are they not doing that already? Even with all the current processes, employers are taking a chance. If a candidate profile is good, can't they take the same chance without all those processes?

dexwiz2• 2 years ago

Recruiters don't call up a business and just ask "how was X at their job?" They are given a list of referrals by the candidate. I am talking about situations where a toxic boss may say negative things for personal reasons. Currently, the candidate can filter out these by choosing people they assume will give positive reviews.

gregjor2• 2 years ago

You won't know what past employers say about you. If you can show a past employer badmouthed you or hindered you getting hired you probably have a legal cause of action in the US.

Past employers generally only confirm dates of employment, title, vague job responsibilities. Calling a company to check prior employment will go to HR. The most telling question: Would you hire Joe Bloggs again? Beyond that past employers rarely say anything for fear of lawsuits. A former "toxic boss" may cost you a job prospect but by doing so they have put a pot of gold on the table for you and your lawyers.

Only an idiot lists references when they aren't sure what the reference will say if contacted. Of course recruiters and employers know that, so they only give so much weight to what former colleagues or professors have to say.

Professional certifications may have some value, as long as everyone knows they are fair and objective and measure actual abilities. So many useless certificates exist, and even the good ones get gamed, that I doubt they carry much weight.

jonahbenton• 2 years ago

I mean, this is what universities used to be, in some cases still are. Reasons universities are going to be better than you is that they have a tighter filter.

The "every job seeker" who "jumps in" is in practice bottom of the barrel- that's why they are seeking. How are you going to make them more attractive than any of the certificate/upskill/bootcamp/yadda yadda things that already exist.

Moving a little higher up the abstraction tree, either you are taking responsibility for the work/person or you are not. If you are, then you are a contracting agency. If you are not, you are a body shop. These are both just cattle businesses. Employers are not finding their staff through those commodity channels.

That said, the hiring market is so broken for all sides a good sounding pitch that ignores the reasons for the breakage can probably get traction. But absent a strategy- like top of market consultancy as a service- or bottom market consolidate federal work programs/grants/yadda yadda into a single place- it doesn't seem like the legs will run that long.

gregjor2• 2 years ago

Reputable agents and outsourcing firms offer exactly this service: already vetted candidates who can bypass interviews. That works because the agency or outsourcing firm can bear contractual responsibility for performance. Recruiters and online job boards don't have any skin in the game, and therefore don't deserve any trust.

I work through an agency, haven't done anything resembling a modern tech interview in 15 years.

Disclaimer: 10X Management represents me, but I post my own opinions, I don't speak for them.

Ask HN: Does Preapproved Job offer akin Preapproved credit card exist?

Related Stories