Show HN: I built a site to roast landing pages

https://www.roastd.io/

by designaas • 3 years ago

21 21 3 years ago

roastd.io

penjelly4• 3 years ago

on mobile i see a few issues with your site,

- cutoff brands

- cutoff proof of tears section. what is the section even for?

- cutoff FAQ header text

- margins are MASSIVE, so much whitespace

- dialogs that animate in too slow

- quoting JBP? not sure necessary here and will expose you to unwanted criticism

edit: just realized JBP quote is something a client received as criticism. Not a fan of that personally, no I'm not a jbp hater, but use your own words

penjelly4• 3 years ago

that took 5 mins, we can go deeper but you'd need to send me 99$.

forgotpwd162• 3 years ago

How much more to redditfy it rather provide serious feedback?

designaas6• 3 years ago

Thanks for the feedback!

I've tried testing on multiple devices and am not seeing the same issues regarding styling but will continue to test and make improvements. Regarding JP I love the man personally but I respect your opinion.

penjelly4• 3 years ago

I'm on a pixel 4g. brave browser, all are definitely issues for more than just me.

Mxbonn• 3 years ago

I was kind of hoping that this would be a site that let anyone roast landing pages. This however is landing page for company that roasts landing pages.

designaas6• 3 years ago

Good idea, maybe a future idea

optymizer2• 3 years ago

You might have 10 years of experience in UX design, but whoever made this landing page did not bother to read it on a mobile device.

ilikehurdles• 3 years ago

It looks mobile optimized to me on iPhone.

designaas6• 3 years ago

What issues are you having? I've tested on mobile.

optymizer2• 3 years ago

* "Why should I pick you to humiliate n" is what I see on my phone. Samsung S22, Chrome window is being reported as 412px wide, 892px tall.

* I'd say whitespace use is dubious for my taste, but it is definitely inconsistent between the 3rd and the 4th review.

* Once I tap on 'Menu', I can't dismiss it by tapping outside of it. It's actually very annoying.

Miscellaneous complaints, just because my mantra is that if I'm going to be roasting other people's work, my stuff better be perfect.

* animation is overused imo, but the hero animation is janky, presumably because the rest of the site is still loading.

* autoscrolling 'proof of tears' with no way to stop or scroll them? From a 'user experience designer'? They do scroll rather slowly, but if the top sentence catches my eye, it goes off the screen and I have no way to bring it back.

* too many colors when you take the icons into account (and the color palette isn't my cup of tea, but that's fine)

I won't charge you anything for the QA feedback because I would like you to succeed with this and I wish you all the best.

Good luck!

forgotpwd162• 3 years ago

Is this supposed to be a parody? https://files.catbox.moe/lb3t5q.png

throwaway2016a• 3 years ago

I think it's supposed to be edgy and unvarnished but it just comes off as crass and unprofessional.

designaas6• 3 years ago

No parody, I say it how I see it.

penjelly4• 3 years ago

the irony of the feedback questioning the brand's displayed by the client requesting review: "who tf are these guys?" when the site itself only lists unfamiliar brands itself is striking.

XCSme• 3 years ago

I noticed the same thing, especially that there seem to be only like 3-4 brands repeated.

agluszak• 3 years ago

Ugh, most landing pages are so bland and generic anyway. And the purpose of this service is to "roast" any deviations from the norm.

designaas6• 3 years ago

Sometimes but also to give feedback in a tongue in cheek manner regarding the user experience and conversion optimisation.

thrownaway5612• 3 years ago

why should i pay for something that show hn gives me for free?

thrownaway5612• 3 years ago

watch Hyperplexed on youtube if you want to see an actual cretics and fixes of websites and apps.

https://www.youtube.com/@Hyperplexed

Show HN: I built a site to roast landing pages

Related Stories