Ask HN: Contrary Opinions

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23111524

by dvduval • 6 years ago

1 7 6 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

Wow, it seems that people have a political persuasion and if you cross it, you lose points here. So which is more important, points or being honest? Haha I'm going to go with the honesty.

Gibbon1• 6 years ago

On HN the truth must never be used as a weapon to make someone feel bad.

dvduval3• 6 years ago

I agree with you. Is important that we are thoughtful of others as we also try to provide our point of view. The problem I ran into this evening was that when I provided my point of view there was an immediate political response. And I was also downvoted. so my point is obviously politics have some power here. I was not even trying to be political tonight.

drenvuk• 6 years ago

This isn't the way to go about this, dealing with idiots or not.

dvduval3• 6 years ago

Okay, so what is the right way to go about this?

unwoundmouse• 6 years ago

Point on the doll where you got downvoted

dvduval3• 6 years ago

Thank you, but I didn't quite understand your reply. doll?

brudgers• 6 years ago

Under the premise that the author is trying to meet readers where they are at, short contrarian comments are largely indistinguishable from trolling behavior in open online fora. "Haha I'm going to go with the honesty." doesn't isn't symptomatic of other interpretations of the behavior.

Don't get me wrong. On it's own, the comment reads as a simple description of a reasonable personal behavior. In the heated context, it doesn't it adds fuel to the fire more than it reflects light on the topic.

Complaining about downvotes is contrary to the HN guidelines. Yes they hurt. They are feedback on the quality of the comment. How might the idea have been written differently in order to be better received by its audience? Better writing is what's in your control.

Ask HN: Contrary Opinions

Related Stories