Ask HN: I want to solve traffic congestion problem, where should I start?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20359751

by maddy1512 • 7 years ago

4 8 7 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

I am a Machine Learning Engineer and I am quite frustrated and fed up of the traffic congestion problems in my city (Pune, India) and want to help in solving this problem.

Where should I start?

sigmaprimus• 7 years ago

https://mutcd.fhwa.dot.gov

itg• 7 years ago

Start by realizing this will require lots of domain knowledge and expertise, machine learning by itself won't solve anything. You will need to work with a team of city planners, civil engineers, etc.

maddy15123• 7 years ago

I never said I want to use machine learning (if it needs to be used I am well equipped to use it)!

As for domain knowledge I think that can be learned with time (this is a long term project), I have worked on three domains (namely, Advertising, Retail and Finance) without having any clue about it at first.

So what I want is theories/books on this problem and how other people have solved it successfully/ not successfully etc... Ofcourse Since I am a technologist and not a town planner or a govt. authority I want to propose a solution from technological perspective. And also I just want to start small by say using web cams to alert/predict future traffic jams and just alert authorities via social media?

onion2k• 7 years ago

You need to accept that there are a large number of people who don't want to fix the problem, and will actively try to stop you, and that no matter how clever, effective, cheap and world-changing your solution might be you're going to need to become a marketer and a politician to actually get anyone to take it seriously.

perfunctory• 7 years ago

I don’t have any domain expertise but I found this project to be pretty cool https://www.vox.com/2016/8/4/12342806/barcelona-superblocks

In general I guess you’d have to get into public advocacy / local politics space.

maddy15123• 7 years ago

This is amazing, but as a technical guy I cannot change/plan/design city routes (I wish I could!). I forgot to add to the question description but I have added in the comment, that I cannot eradicate traffic jams as that involves government/politicians/city planner etc, while traffic aversion is more dependent on using technology, I thinks that's where I fit.

But anyways thanks for link, I got to know something that I had not known earlier.

maddy15123• 7 years ago

Since I am a technologist and not a town planner or a govt. authority I want to propose a solution from technological perspective. And also I just want to start small by say using web cams to alert/predict future traffic jams and just alert authorities via social media?

Then next step would be to feed this systems output to traffic signals and dynamically increase/decrease their timings? I have a lot of radical ideas and if you have one I would be glad to hear it out.

Again keeping in mind that traffic jam eradication vs aversion are a different problems. Traffic jam eradication/prevention requires a lot of experts from different domain to work in collaboration (town planner + civil engineers + road engineers + gov. authoritarians etc).

While I think(may be wrong) traffic aversion can be done using technology + some domain knowledge.

grizzles• 7 years ago

You could set up some ASLR cameras, and create a website showing how much the city would make by doing congestion charging. Local governments always love revenue.

Ask HN: I want to solve traffic congestion problem, where should I start?

Related Stories