Ask HN: Why is creating a custom Firefox search engine so difficult?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18217482
by turova • 8 years ago
2 2 8 years ago

This simple issue has been bothering me for a couple of years now and I've never been able to find anything resembling a solution - I like having control of the search engine options in my browser and want to add custom searches. Chrome maintains the tradition of allowing a URL string with some predefined parameters. Firefox, on the other hand, requires some sort of custom XML mess with no clear and simple way to create a custom search engine from scratch. I see some minimal benefits, such as the ability to pair an icon with a search engine and the ability to use short names, but I just want to type a search into the search bar and have it send me to a custom search of my choice.

Is this shift to OpenSearch format mostly to prevent people from doing away with Mozilla's referral codes in the search strings? I just can't see any good reason this must be so complicated with so little customizability.

To be completely clear, I want to add the equivalent of "https://<customsearchengine>.com/q={searchparam}" to replace any/all of the built-in search options and am not currently looking for other solutions, such as websites with lists of predefined search engine queries. I also don't want to be dependent on finding some online service to do this for me. Any suggestions or feedback on why this process has become so complicated?

Related Stories

Loading related stories...

Source preview

news.ycombinator.com