Singapore: no more cars allowed on the road, government says

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/oct/24/singapore-no-more-cars-allowed-on-the-road-government-says

by t1o5 • 9 years ago

20 9 9 years ago

theguardian.com

merricksb• 9 years ago

Discussed previously:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15536481

cs702• 9 years ago

Interesting.

The economic and environmental rationales are compelling.

After reading this, I'm wondering if the prohibition of private vehicles will be unavoidable in the future for large, densely populated areas with growing populations.

holydude2• 9 years ago

Places like Singapore are an isolated incidents. They have nowhere else to grow (unless they want to reclaim land from the ocean sort of what seoulites did with Songdo).

xbmcuser• 9 years ago

If I recall correctly Singapore has increased it's landmass by about 20% in 50 or so years by reclaiming land from the sea. I have to say though they have plans that by 2030 no place should be more than 10-15min walk from an mrt station and have been trialing different kinds of self driving tech for the last mile travel. I expect in 10 years they might actually get to a point where owning a car might not be worth the hassle.

EGreg2• 9 years ago

I find it interesting that Singapore ranks very high on the "Economic Freedom" (read: business friendliness) indexes but is for sure a nanny state, that fines you for chewing gum on the street and so on.

Libertarians use it as an example of prosperity resulting from freedom but there is heavy intervention and central planning everywhere. How do they explain the thiving in the face of this?

ciguy2• 9 years ago

They don't and never have fined anyone for chewing gum. Just the sale and import of gum are banned. You can go to another country and bring back gum for personal use, though doing so may be of dubious legality. I know plenty of friends that have done so many times with no issues.

EGreg2• 9 years ago

You're right, I accidentally conflated it with spitting out gum:

It is illegal to drop litter, and to “spit any substance or expel mucus from the nose upon or on to any street or any public place”. Penalties for a first offence can be as much as S$2,000, or S$10,000 for doing it three times. In both cases you may also be forced to clean the streets wearing a green vest.

Singapore: no more cars allowed on the road, government says

Related Stories