The Metaphysics of the Hangover

http://iasc-culture.org/THR/THR_article_2017_Summer_Edmundson.php

by pepys • 9 years ago

61 26 9 years ago

Nursie5• 9 years ago

Hangovers are a wretched, miserable thing, it's true, but beyond the flowery language of metaphysics, they are at least in part due to our drug of choice.

Ethyl Alcohol is not kind to the body, its metabolic pathyway involves formaldehyde, for a start. There are other substances, other alcohols even, that can have similar effects but without the specific awfulness of the hangover.

Certainly, what the author describes as putting the walls back up, that's likely going to happen regardless of the drug, but the pain, nausea and dehydration are signatures of booze, and these will affect your mind too - makingyou more wretched and self pitying.

donmatito2• 9 years ago

Curious - what other alcohols?

Nursie5• 9 years ago

Things like "2M2B", tertiary-Amyl alcohol.

The downsides tend to be foul taste and massive potency - much over 15ml can kill someone. It doesn't undergo metabolism to aldehyde so the traditional hangover doesn't happen, and the duration can be much longer.

There are others. I'm not vouching for the safety of any of them (even ethanol!), for the record, and have not tried 2M2B.

andrepd2• 9 years ago

IIRC we don't really know what causes hangovers. Can you give more info on that thing you said about different alcohols not giving hangovers?

swiley• 9 years ago

My cousin who drinks/drank a lot says it's really dehydration. Apparently if you drink a lot of water at the same time you tend to not get them.

Nursie5• 9 years ago

AFAICT (and if there is someone properly versed in the biological sciences here I will gladly defer to them) at least part of the experience of hangover nastiness is down to the formation of aldehydes (particularly acetaldehyde * ) by the action of alcohol dehydrogenase on ethanol. Tertiary alcohols such as tert-Amyl Alcohol don't get acted on by this enzyme.

I'm not for a second denying dehydration, lack of sleep, side effects of ethanol itself etc etc and many other factors are likely to play a part.

( * I said formaldehyde, looks like I was wrong about that on a quick search, it's acetaldehyde)

-- edit -- The wikipedia page on it is quite interesting, particularly the relation of acetaldehyde to the enzyme differences in people with a specific genetic change (usually of east asian descent) and their ability to consume alcohol... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hangover#Acetaldehyde

Real_S• 9 years ago

The breakdown of ethyl alcohol is as follows:

alcohol dehydrogenase ethyl alcohol -> acetaldehyde

aldehyde dehydrogenase acetaldehyde -> acetate

Much like formaldehyde, acetaldehyde is a toxic mutagen. Depending on your diet, genetics and the health of your liver, alcohol consumption can lead to an accumulation of acetaldehyde. This is why many asians get "red-faced" from drinking, they actually accumulate acetaldehyde due to their genetics. The other major toxin in many alcohols is methyl alcohol, which can break down into formaldehyde, but is actually pretty toxic on its own.

These are fun facts to share at drinking parties ;)

ribfeast• 9 years ago

This article is long-winded, pretentious and misses Kingsley Amis' best definition of the metaphysical hangover:

When that ineffable compound of depression, sadness (these two are not the same), anxiety, self-hatred, sense of failure and fear for the future begins to steal over you, start telling yourself that what you have is a hangover. You are not sickening for anything, you have not suffered a minor brain lesion, you are not all that bad at your job, your family and friends are not leagued in a conspiracy of barely maintained silence about what a shit you are, you have not come at last to see life as it really is and there is no use crying over spilt milk.

52-6F-62• 9 years ago

I'd never caught that quote before, and I've read Amis before. That's great, thank you. I'm going to stash it away for those much needed moments...

draw_down2• 9 years ago

I don't recommend getting too florid with it. Alcohol is bad for us, we know that and drink it anyway because it's fun, and if we're not careful the next day is uncomfortable. Drink with food in your stomach and have water while you drink, and try not to feel too sorry for yourself.

bradford• 9 years ago

There's a common notion that drinking with food in ones stomach and proper hydration can prevent a hangover. I'm not sure that you're personally making this claim, but it's a personal mission of mine to dispel the claim as utter BS.

The sad truth is that a hangover happens because it's your bodies response to metabolizing a poison. Drinking less is the only real prevention, and proper rest/time is (generally) the only treatment. I'd have been saved a lot of pain had only someone told me this when I was younger, instead, I received a bunch of misinformed advice which, while probably well intentioned, did absolutely nothing to help.

Sure, eating well and drinking water will make you feel better, but that's true in any situation, so the explanatory power of it is lacking.

some further reading for explanation, in case anyone is interested:

http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/your-complete-g...

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/in-search-of-a-cu...

twic• 9 years ago

As the SciAm article mentions, NSAIDs are somewhat effective. Take a dose of ibuprofen before going to sleep and you'll be a better off in the morning.

synicalx• 9 years ago

Having food in your stomach probably doesn't do anything for a hangover but it definitely helps you while you're drinking.

Alcohol on an empty stomach is never a good idea, unfortunately quite a bit of personal experience in this area...

rootw0rm• 9 years ago

this is why i stick to ether.

The Metaphysics of the Hangover

Related Stories