A Gentle Intro to MVC

http://nemetral.net/2008/07/31/a-gentle-introduction-to-mvc-part-1/

by nym • 17 years ago

17 2 17 years ago

Nycto• 17 years ago

This article makes me nervous. The author freely admits to a gaping security hole in part 3 of the article. Instead of fixing the code, the author just added an annotation. I just know that someone inexperienced in the ways of PHP is going to copy and paste that code without reading everything thoroughly. I understand the author was trying to keep things simple, but it's irresponsible in my opinion.

jhancock• 17 years ago

I think its great that webapps have borrowed some concepts from MVC. But people should understand that this new thing should be called something like "web_mvc" or less glamourous "web_page_shared_nothing_mvc".

Separation of code and componentized page rendering are well done by web frameworks which call themselves MVC, but are leaving a lot on the table from the original use of the pattern.

The original MVC had models, views, and controllers living independent life cycles. These objects used events and inversion of control to bind and inject themselves into one another. Far more interesting than web_mvc which basically spins up a bunch of objects, renders a page and throws everything away until the next request. The closest thing web frameworks have to original MVC lives in projects like seaside and lift.

A Gentle Intro to MVC

Related Stories