HN user

pot8n

90 karma
Posts0
Comments25
View on HN
No posts found.

The real raison d'etre with these new wave of commercial NoVPN products like this one and Tailscale is to build a high margin SaaS business without really having the infrastructure liabilities of SaaS businesses. The problem with these kinds of products is that they are, from a security perspective, a disaster. Not only your entire network is compromised if they get hacked or if even they want to get into your network whenever they want which is an unlimited power I've never seen in any SaaS product, also your network becomes prisoner to their services, so if their services go down for any reason, you and everyone in your network will be unable to connect to your network even if it's perfectly working.

At least Twingate doesn't try to do sanke oil advertising like Tailscale and sells itself as an "open source" (go have a look at their Github open issues, it's a complete disaster) while it is not. Also the other thing is, if you have a relatively small company of 50 people you will end up actually paying MORE than those seemingly overpriced yet established products like Zscaler ZPA.

For me, the only serious alternative to expensive products like ZPA are Zerotier and Pritunl. They are as transparent as open source yet still viable as businesses without being greedy or captive to VC money to extract every single dollar out of you.

I am sure I wouldn't use a service that can literally get into each and every device of my private network if they want to or worse, they get hacked. Each and every device in the network automatically accepts whatever public keys and endpoints that get advertised by their servers and automatically connect to them. It's not only an overpriced mediocre product. From a security perspective, it's the most dangerous SaaS service I've ever seen.

My biggest fear is once this company gets tied to WireGuard and the security disasters come out, WireGuard's fate will be tied to a mediocre commercial product that put money above engineering decisions.

Golang didn't succeed because it is simple or powerful or any of the, I apologize, nonsense your hear from the Gophers. Golang succeeded because it was the only available relevant option and alternative to the aging Python and Java when the cloud took off in the early 2010s.

GitHub Codespaces 6 years ago

I've already been using VSCode remote over SSH on cheap yet powerful Hetzner instances. You can do this on any cloud vendor and you can, if you want, put your home directory as a volume and resize up and down your machine as you want.

No, I haven't but your service is making it literally impossible to browse with Firefox and Tor (understandably because you're here to make money from your customers labeling people like me as a threat in their dashboards not to enable people to actually browse easily). Even reCAPTCHA doesn't do that.

I am still amazed that anybody can still make any money in the very low barrier-to-entry business of SEO. Probably the quote of Einstein on human stupidity is literally correct after all. Especially after I fell for the click-baity failory posts again.

I am not really sure you understand how it works. There is no hosted/not hosted versions of it. You must connect your "opensource" client/agent through their coordination servers hosted by them to host and publish the public key to the other devices in your network and you can not skip their service. So Tailscale is effectively as opensource as any commercial opensource VPN client. It's entirely useless when not used with their commercial service and users have zero control over the software unless when used with their servers. The "open source" thing is great from a marketing and business perspective because you basically benefit from the open source marketing and the community thing from the unsuspecting users and enthusiasts pros without giving away literally anything.

I've been using Tmux for years now when sshing to servers and I still can't even make some copy-paste with my mouse.

Honestly that's the least of all problems and catastrophes of Tailscale. You must have 1000% of confidence in their own servers security, if the published public keys hosted on their servers have been tampered then the entire network is compromised. Also, if their service is down, you will be unable to connect to your network even if it is completely fine and working.

Replaced Wireguard with Tailscale

facepalm

So you replaced FOSS Wireguard with a rebranded yet paid Wireguard service? Also how is NodePort is considered "internal" service? The whole point of NodePort is to be accessed from outside the cluster which can be easily done with the real Wireguard.