HN user

nvme0n1p1

412 karma
Posts0
Comments100
View on HN
No posts found.
[dead] 1 day ago

LLMs fall back on things like that when there's nothing good worth mentioning about a project. They simply emit tokens. If there are no good tokens they could emit, they emit bad tokens instead.

6.2MB - actually a bad thing

pure Go - irrelevant at best

no fzf - actually a bad thing

It's bold to call something that has prevented real-world attacks "security theater", with the justification that one day the world might change enough that it's less likely to prevent future attacks. Was the printing press worthless, just because we have laser printers nowadays?

Anyhow, If you believe LLMs will kill security research, then surely you must also believe a cooldown of 1 week would be enough time for your favorite LLM to analyze a new package version?

the app just hung there trying to figure out how long its command line can be?

That's common on linux. Many tools read from stdin if a file path isn't given: cat, xargs, base64, cksum, etc.

The citation thing is a little silly, I'll give you that one.

If he wanted AI slop, I'm sure he's capable of asking an AI himself. He asked a forum full of people because he wants a real answer from a knowledgeable person. If you didn't have anything to contribute, you could have just left it for someone else to reply.

Yeah, it turns out human culture has a lot of depth and complexity, even so-called "mid" culture. If you think you can write a better explainer, I'd love to read it.

Whoa, I have my very first crazy internet stalker. What fun!

Do an internet search for "go garbage collector benchmark" if you're curious what the grownups are talking about.

Yeah that's not great. It's easy to be faster than go if you haven't thought about memory management yet. I bet go with GOGC=off is faster than plain go too.

Good for what? A hammer is good for driving a nail, but not good for driving a screw.

Safe for what? My house is safe for humans, but not safe for tropical birds.

Clean enough for what? Our water is clean enough to wash my ass, but not clean enough to wash a telescope mirror.

Sorry but life is not a Disney movie where some things are unequivocally good/safe and other things are unequivocally bad/unsafe. There are gradients and conditions, and communication requires a shared language between participating parties to navigate them.

safety in general

This is impossible. General words like "safe" and "good" are subjective, and useless in a technical context unless you ground the discussion by giving them specific definitions. Otherwise everyone ends up talking past each other.

So you would prefer weapons that cannot reason at all?

Um, yes? It's bad enough humans are murdering each other. At least a human can in theory be held accountable for pulling the trigger. The last thing we need is an unaccountable ralph loop reasoning about which schools and churches to bomb every time it wakes up.

if it had a better llm underpinning it

Ah yes, the "LLMs are intelligent, you're just not using the newest fanciest model" fallacy. This time with innocent lives on the line. If only we used ChatGPT-8.9 instead of 8.8, those poor kids would still be alive today.

GitHub is meant for developers. Plenty of OSS has forums or Zulip/Discord chats for ordinary users to get support in a more casual way. Sometimes not, but there's just as much closed source software with poor support too.

GP proposed the site should solve the problem once at the source, and everyone benefits. You counter-proposed that every individual reader should take manual action on every headline they see. That's a lot of redundant wasted effort across the userbase.

To continue your analogy, that would be like if Gmail got rid of spam filters, and then told people to stop complaining endlessly and manually copy every email they get into SpamGPT to ask if it's spam or not.

SISC is there because it's not notable, so the busybodies haven't even noticed the page exists. Odin, however, is notable, and that put it on their radar as a target for attacking its notability.

If a stock market observation has no predictive power, then it's worthless.

I look forward to your weather report too: "It's always sunny outside until one day it starts raining. Every time."