Ask YC: Where to improve?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=91947

by samson • 19 years ago

2 3 19 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

www.tipgroups.com

starting to think its almost ready to promote (not that I actually got a clue how to do that).

ALL suggestions are welcome. (don't spare the rod) :)

raju2• 19 years ago

To start, nice idea! Congrats.

To start off, I am on a Mac with FireFox...

1. Your sign-up screen and log-in screen have a very different look from the home page, and from each other (one is centered, one is to the left, one shows the table borders, the other dosen't) 2. I am not sure I understand the need for a "Go Back" button on the sign-up screen. 3. When you go to the login screen (or the signup or the About page) the Title of the page disappears. [It shows only the hyphen] 4. Is there a reason why Google Stuff, Car Buying etc show up on the left hand side, and never change? Refreshing the page does not help, but the top "Groups" section starts. 5. Is there a way to browse the groups without having to refresh the page (Much like Amazons recommendations... maybe?) 6. When viewing a Tip, the Works! and Unique links don't look like links (or buttons) and only clicking on them tells you that there's something there...

P.S. I did not create an account, but I hope this gives you something to work with. Good luck!!!

samson• 19 years ago

Thanks raju for the feedback. Regarding (1),(2) (3) yea I got to clean those areas off.

(4) yea there is a reason, but not a very good one. I'll figure out a way to arrange groups thats more intutive to for the user, perhaps simply by most tips in group. (5) I guess your refering back to the mainpage. Whats there right now is simply just a random group display. I'll rethink on that thought about the group browsing, I've tried to build the site on the principle of clean and minimalstic and avoid any flash or ajax whenever possible. (6)I noticed that too last night when I added those buttons, but I thought "well they look good in IE" no big deal,...aha but you've noticed it too so I guess they've got to go.

raju2• 19 years ago

samson, I like your idea of a minimalistic design. If you would rather not have any fancy ajax or flash, then may I propose for an easy way to search for tags and tips etc...

My apologies if I sounded too critical, but I certainly hope the input helped. Again, Good Luck.

Ask YC: Where to improve?

Related Stories