4.2.2.2: The Story Behind a DNS Legend

http://www.tummy.com/articles/famous-dns-server/

by falava • 11 years ago

3 3 11 years ago

dalke2• 11 years ago

This comes up about once a year. The previous ones with many comments, including further context, are https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1282213 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6426605 .

falava• 11 years ago

Oh thanks!

I'm intrigued. Today you have found two dupe posts coming from me.

How can you be so fast finding the dupes and replying with this info?

It has to be a very time consuming task if it is not automated (appreciated anyway).

If you have automated the task I want to know how! :-) (If you could briefly explain)

In both cases I've just posted it and expected to upvote the most recent thread, but a new post was created and I have directly supposed that the stories were new (from the forum perspective).

I don't understand the mechanics by which the forum allows dupe posts. Maybe it should only allow to dupe a previous post when it's very recent (less than a day) and don't have any upvotes, or automatically show the previous discussions when is old (months)

dalke2• 11 years ago

Didn't realize it was you both times.

I recognized the posts. The packing one was only last week, and this DNS Legend one, while older, was written by someone I know.

When that happens, I go to the search link at the bottom of HN, and look for the title, or use the key words. That finds the hits. I then check to see if there were many comments.

The FAQ says "If a story has had significant attention in the last year or so, we kill reposts as duplicates. If not, a small number of reposts is ok."

Duplicate posts are hard to detect. The packing one from last week has a tracer on it, as "?src=hn", so the URL is different than the one you submitted. Also, due to the vagaries of voting, sometimes the moderators think a post didn't get the notice it should have, and don't weed out duplicates even if there haven't (yet) been any comments. There's also a problem if a dozen sources report the same topic, like when Citizenfour recently won the Academy Award.

4.2.2.2: The Story Behind a DNS Legend

Related Stories