Ask HN: What is the right way to learn Mathematics?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9009409

by roansh • 11 years ago

8 16 11 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

Please note that I am not asking for good resources, I am asking for the "right way".

The reason I learned to code in the first place was because of my fascination with the idea of AIs in childhood, but when I realized later on that to learn it you need Math, I was in despair. I have decided to (RE)learn everything from the very basics. I have been watching videos and solving examples on KhanAcademy since last two weeks now. (Thanks to Sal). But once in a while I stop and ask myself -- whether it's the right way. Whether I will have true insights into Math when I am done with this. I really need to know the right path before I spend years going in the wrong direction, only to find nothing.

The areas I am interested in are -- Artificial Intelligence, Image Processing, and Computer Graphics.

brudgers2• 11 years ago

Learn the mathematics that's applicable to the area in which you are interested. That means it's recursive:

    function learn x
        if x.prerequisties.know()
        then study x
        else learn x.prerequisites

Not iterative. So start with AI if that's what you want to know.

That's not to say that building up iteratively from foundations is bad. But if it's not directed from the top level, then it may not lead there.

roansh7• 11 years ago

Thanks for writing. I like your approach. I actually have started from the very top level. Let me explain further as why I asked this question in the first place with examples.

Two days ago I (re)learned that (-1) x (-1) = (1). I read many resources explaining why that is true, but it just doesn't strike as 1 + 1 = 2.

To give one more example, just to make clear what I am asking about -- Today I learned about slope of the line, which is = change in y / change in x. Even that doesn't strike. I have already learned these things believing that they are true in my school years. I don't want to learn in the same way.

cottonseed• 11 years ago

It is important to distinguish between axioms (things you assume), definitions and theorem (things you prove from axioms, stated in terms of definitions). So, for basic arithmetic, your assumptions might be the defining properties of numbers: associativity, distributivity, etc. In this setting, 1 + 1 = 2 is basically a definition, while (-1)* (-1) = 1 is something to be proved:

    0 = 0* (-1) (0* x = 0 for all x)
      = (1 + (-1))* (-1) (x + -x = 0)
      = 1* (-1) + (-1)* (-1) (distributivity)
      = (-1) + (-1)* (-1) (1* x = x for all x)

implies:

    1 = (-1)* (-1) (equality; add 1 to both sides)

Finally, slope = rise/run is a definition. It is not something you "see" to be true.

So assumption vs. definition vs. theorem can explain part of it. Another part is familiarity. 1 + 1 = 2 is ubiquitous in daily life. Depending on what you think about, (-1)* (-1) = 1 may not be. You probably have lots of interpretations of 1 + 1 = 2 (counting, number line, shopping, money, etc.) How many such interpretations of (-1)* (-1) = 1 do you have?

I highly recommend this book, written by two mathematicians:

http://www.amazon.com/5-Elements-Effective-Thinking-ebook/dp...

It's now about mathematics per se, but about learning how to learn and think better. Good luck.

ralmeida2• 11 years ago

It seems like you are having trouble internalizing math. I think what you mean by "that does not strike" is that you have not yet developed actual insight into what you are learning. This seems to be what you are missing.

So, you need to learn how to develop this insight. It's not easy, but maybe just knowing what you are looking for (that is, to develop intuitive insight into what you are learning) puts you into the right track, and hopefully it gets easier with practice later.

Here are a few resources. Please note that these are not resources for math, but resources on how to develop insight into math.

- Cal Newport's essay about insight in technical college courses: http://calnewport.com/blog/2008/11/14/how-to-ace-calculus-th... (the general idea still aplies even if you're not studying in/for college)

- BetterExplained Math Cheatsheet - http://betterexplained.com/cheatsheet/ (a collection of intuitive, insight-generating explanations on a variety of math topics, from basic to advanced)

- Coursera's Learning How To Learn course - https://www.coursera.org/course/learning

- A Mind for Numbers book - http://www.amazon.com/Mind-For-Numbers-Science-Flunked-ebook... (the book used in the course above)

I hope this helps. A few basic, general tips for developing insight is to think about applications. For example, your slope of line problem. If instead you called the y-axis "distance travelled" and the x-axis time, can you "feel" that the slope of the line is the speed? What if you substitute "distance travelled" for "revenue generated"? What would be the equivalent of "speed" in this case? Try with a few more examples, and hopefully you will develop an insight that the slope of the line is the rate of change of something, and will be able to apply it to many situations.

brudgers2• 11 years ago

To be honest, mathematics is largely a matter of recognizing what can be replaced by some other what. That the expression \(* -1 -1)\ can be replaced by the expression \1\ is just a random fact. It can also be replaced by \(- 6 5)\ and \(- 6 5 0)\ etc.

Explanations can help, but at some point it's just arbitrary. And treating mathematics at the mechanical level is a very useful abstraction, in my opinion.

I'll add that the way we teach it is pre-computer era. Playing around with something like J is a whole new post-computer age world.

brogrammer90• 11 years ago

Check out the book "The Calculus Direct" by John Weiss.

roansh7• 11 years ago

Thanks for the suggestion, will check that book.

Mz• 11 years ago

1) Make sure you understand the concepts, not just how to crunch the numbers.

2) Make sure you understand how the math relates to the actual real world and is a means to model actual reality.

I know you did not ask for resources, but really good ones are hard to find. So I will note that a good source for good math articles (as well as good math answers) on HN is Colin Wright: https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=ColinWright

ChaitanyaSai• 11 years ago

It might also help to know what parts of math are intuitive and what parts aren't. Our brains just can't visualize tensors, but we can visualize quantities. Trying to relate tensors to the spatial geometry of the world around us -- the world we can perceive -- may not lead to much.

I found this book helpful

http://www.amazon.com/Number-Sense-Creates-Mathematics-Revis...

roansh7• 11 years ago

Thanks! I'll look into it! :)

wodenokoto• 11 years ago

This article hit the front page a few days ago, I think you will find it very informative.

https://medium.com/@warrenhenning/a-software-engineers-adven...

roansh7• 11 years ago

Thanks for writing! I actually read that article that day, and it was really on time. It's a good motivation, but it doesn't talk about how one should learn Math. I find the commends below very informative and I've concluded that I need to spend some time on finding better ways to learn, and what suits me well.

Ask HN: What is the right way to learn Mathematics?

Related Stories