Is it annoying to have non-hackers on HN?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8910439

by avni000 • 12 years ago

8 9 12 years ago

news.ycombinator.com

As HN becomes more popular and mainstream, how do hackers feel about having more non-hackers on the site - favorable because it provides an opportunity to teach or irritating because it changes the dynamics and intent?

godzillabrennus• 12 years ago

I came for the free beer but stayed for the physics lessons.

jsilence• 12 years ago

As long as discussion stay focussed and commentors try to actually contribute valuable input I don't care about their profession/attitude.

subrat_rout• 12 years ago

I have seen quite a good number of contributors here are non-hackers. As long as the post or comment stays relevant and constructive then it does not matter. Rather I have seen few hackers whose posts are nothing but quite arrogant and non constructive or a way to vent or show off.

izolate• 12 years ago

Honestly, yes. But only if those non-hackers consist of people in industries I don't look upon favorably: marketers, advertisers, recruiters.

I come to HN seeking primarily technical discussion. Although tech is my primary interest, if your area of interest is as nerdy as tech (science, for example), you're more than welcome here in my eyes.

Rooster61• 12 years ago

Marketers yes. Advertisers yes. But recruiters? I don't have a problem with a recruiter seeking to become more knowledgeable about the tech field.

Granted, I don't want to see HN become a morass of hiring threads, but if and when I have another job to apply for, I'd like the recruiter to have some idea of what he's talking about and reading HN articles isn't exactly detrimental to that end.

krapp• 12 years ago

'non-hackers' is a pretty loaded term.

While I don't have any doubt that more and more diverse users causes friction for those who prefer HN to cater to the sort of stories and culture they prefer, it's worth mentioning that the site is about 'anything that satisfies intellectual curiosity', not hacking in any particular sense.

I'm not annoyed. Some of the most interesting stories i've seen here have had nothing to do with 'hacking' at all, whatever that means.

avni000• 12 years ago

Appreciate this perspective - I agree that hackers/non-hackers is a very inaccurate label and I like the idea that it's for "satisfying intellectual curiosity".

jgeorge• 12 years ago

Non-hackers who want to be hackers have to learn somewhere/somehow. Non-hackers that want to get information on technical subjects could do far worse than get their news here. Personally, I welcome anyone here as long as they understand the conversation here should remain technically focused.

I lament the people ("hackers" and "non-hackers" alike) that seem to try to convert HN into their other non-technical favorite discussion forum.

firebones• 12 years ago

Preemptive edit:

There must be something I don't understand, because the thread cited below isn't in the front page results if I'm logged in, but IS on the front page if I'm not logged in. So I will leave the post because of the points related to liberal arts, but rescind my voting conspiracy mindset.

=====

Take a look at this thread:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8914678

It's about reading, and literature. I commented on it when it was on the front page. Went back to view the thread later and it was nowhere in the first 600 results.

I don't know why for sure yet, but it wouldn't surprise me to learn that it had something to do with the liberal arts nature of the post offending some of the hardcore flag killers here.

Non-engineering disciplines may attract a significant number of down voters and haters that the answer to your question is, in the opinion of the masses and filtered through the editorial policy of the voting/flagging system: yes.

I disagree. I think every field has its hacking contingent, and the point of liberal arts is to find breadth and interdisciplinary connection, which produces equal, if not richer, insights than narrow specialization.

So my answer is no, it's not annoying to have non-hackers on HN. I'm here to learn and to form those connections across disciplines.

It is annoying to have shills, or black-and-white silo thinkers. But these are independent of the hacker/non-hacker dimension.

Is it annoying to have non-hackers on HN?

Related Stories