State of the Specialization: Generics over primitives in Java and JVM

http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~briangoetz/valhalla/specialization.html

by udalov • 12 years ago

83 1 12 years ago

cr.openjdk.java.net

paol• 12 years ago

Interesting. This just reinforces my opinion that they made a terrible decision with the original implementation of generics in Java. Basically they set themselves the constraint that generics would have to be implemented without touching the JVM, in the name of a completely unnecessary form of forward compatibility (basically you can compile generics-using code in Java 1.5 and run it on a 1.4 JVM).

The only upside was that the existing collection classes could be "upgraded" to generics, rather than having to create a new set of collections classes. When faced with the same decision, C# went ahead and did just that - eliciting complaints from exactly no-one - and in return gained powerful and robust support for generics at the VM level. Contrast that with the contortions being proposed in the article just to try to extend Java generics to fundamental types.

State of the Specialization: Generics over primitives in Java and JVM

Related Stories